Re: piano ties

2018-08-19 Thread Werner LEMBERG
>> Thanks for your try. Alas, the notation you are suggesting is not >> standard in piano notation – the first quarter needs a separate >> stem. > > Back to the music at hand, I would propose challenging the notion > that "the first quarter needs a separate stem". How absolute is > this rule in

Re: piano ties

2018-08-19 Thread Aaron Hill
On 2018-08-19 10:04, Werner LEMBERG wrote: The main difference is that the quarter note does not get its own column. Thanks for your try. Alas, the notation you are suggesting is not standard in piano notation – the first quarter needs a separate stem. As one infrequently bound to theory

Re: piano ties

2018-08-19 Thread Werner LEMBERG
>> It essentially boils down to the fact that inter-voice ties (and >> slurs) would be tremendously helpful for notation of piano music. >> >> Does anyone know what obstacles prevent an implementation of such a >> feature? > > Any reason you don't move the Tie/Slur engraver to Staff level if >

Re: piano ties

2018-08-19 Thread David Kastrup
Werner LEMBERG writes: > It essentially boils down to the fact that inter-voice ties (and > slurs) would be tremendously helpful for notation of piano music. > > Does anyone know what obstacles prevent an implementation of such a > feature? Any reason you don't move the Tie/Slur engraver to

Re: piano ties

2018-08-19 Thread Werner LEMBERG
>> \relative c' { >> \clef "bass" >> \time 3/4 >> << { 2. ~ | >> \oneVoice\shiftOff \hideNotes 2 r4 \unHideNotes } \\ >>{ d!2. ~ | >> \oneVoice\shiftOff 2. } \\ >>{ f4 e2 ~ | >> \oneVoice\shiftOff \hideNotes 2 s4 \unHideNotes } >> >> } >

Re: piano ties

2018-08-19 Thread Aaron Hill
On 2018-08-19 02:18, Werner LEMBERG wrote: please have a look at the attached left hand piano staff image. I need the following, very ugly code to write it with lilypond. \relative c' { \clef "bass" \time 3/4 << { 2. ~ | \oneVoice\shiftOff \hideNotes 2 r4 \unHideNotes }

piano ties

2018-08-19 Thread Werner LEMBERG
Folks, please have a look at the attached left hand piano staff image. I need the following, very ugly code to write it with lilypond. \relative c' { \clef "bass" \time 3/4 << { 2. ~ | \oneVoice\shiftOff \hideNotes 2 r4 \unHideNotes } \\ { d!2. ~ |