Re: linear raid space utilization

2006-01-21 Thread David Greaves
Andy Gajetzki wrote: Hi there, I recently had a disk go bad in a linear RAID built with mdadm. The particular disk that failed was the last device of the RAID. I am curious about how devices are utilized in a linear RAID. Would the md be filled sequentially from device 1 upto 5? In other

Re: linear raid space utilization

2006-01-21 Thread Neil Brown
On Saturday January 21, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi there, I recently had a disk go bad in a linear RAID built with mdadm. The particular disk that failed was the last device of the RAID. I am curious about how devices are utilized in a linear RAID. Would the md be filled sequentially from

Re: linear raid space utilization

2006-01-21 Thread Andy Gajetzki
Thanks for the help. I used ddrescue to grab /dev/hdb and am now using e2retrieve. I am somewhat optimistic that there will be at least partial recovery ;). Have a great remainder of the weekend, Andy Gajetzki On 1/21/06, David Greaves [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Andy Gajetzki wrote: Hi there, I

Re: Save to use spindown?

2006-01-21 Thread Gordon Henderson
On Sat, 21 Jan 2006, Gerd Knops wrote: Hi, I have a RAID5 setup with 3 250GB SATA disks. Often the RAID is not accessed for days, so I wonder if I can extend the life of the disks by spinning them down, eg by setting the spindown timeout for the drives with hdparm -S nn. The hdparm man

Re: blog entry on RAID limitation

2006-01-21 Thread Carlos Carvalho
Jeff Breidenbach (jeff@jab.org) wrote on 17 January 2006 00:45: Is this a real issue or ignorable Sun propoganda? -Original Message- From: I-Gene Leong Subject: RE: [colo] OT: Server Hardware Recommendations Date: Mon, 16 Jan 2006 14:10:33 -0800 There was an interesting blog

Re: blog entry on RAID limitation

2006-01-21 Thread Carlos Carvalho
Neil Brown ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote on 18 January 2006 09:47: On Tuesday January 17, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Neil Brown wrote: In general, I think increasing the connection between the filesystem and the volume manager/virtual storage is a good idea. Well, I agree in principle however

Re: Save to use spindown?

2006-01-21 Thread John Hendrikx
Mark Hahn wrote: you seem to be assuming that the drives have a lifespan measured in hours-spinning. that's not at all clear. for instance, drives are typically rated 40-50K start-stop cycles, which is ~40/day over a 3-year service life. you clearly do not want to auto-spindown unless you

Selective spin-up

2006-01-21 Thread John Hendrikx
I recently extended my raid array with a 9th drive, and I find that the 300 watt PSU I use is insufficient to start the system. What happens is that I activate the machine, the machine starts powering up for 3 seconds orso (spinning all the hard drives up about half way) then power cuts out.

Re: [PATCH 000 of 5] md: Introduction

2006-01-21 Thread Adam Kropelin
NeilBrown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: In line with the principle of release early, following are 5 patches against md in 2.6.latest which implement reshaping of a raid5 array. By this I mean adding 1 or more drives to the array and then re-laying out all of the data. I've been looking forward to

Re: Save to use spindown?

2006-01-21 Thread Mark Hahn
of my drives at the moment are below 10 start-stop cycles, even though the array is only used very lightly for a few hours every day. but my point was that very lightly doesn't tell you how many start/stop cycles. if the spindown timeout is less than ~10 minutes, you _could_ hit 50K cycles

RE: Save to use spindown?

2006-01-21 Thread Guy
During a start and stop the disk's heads touch the surface. At speed the heads glide on a cushion of air, and don't touch the surface. AFAIK, the heads and surface don't wear while in use. Also, if disks are anything like light bulbs, they will fail during start. I have never seen a light bulb