Re: Raid sync observations

2006-01-08 Thread Bill Davidsen
Gordon Henderson wrote: On Wed, 21 Dec 2005, Sebastian Kuzminsky wrote: But how does the performance for read and write compare? Good question! I'll post some performance numbers of the RAID-6 configuration when I have it up and running. Post your hardware config too if you

Re: Raid sync observations

2005-12-21 Thread Sebastian Kuzminsky
Andy Smith [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Wed, Dec 21, 2005 at 12:55:47PM +1100, Christopher Smith wrote: Why would you use RAID6 and not RAID10 with four disks ? I was wondering the same thing. It's true that RAID6 is guaranteed to still run degraded after losing 2 devices, whereas a RAID10

Re: Raid sync observations

2005-12-20 Thread Sebastian Kuzminsky
Sebastian Kuzminsky [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Question 1: Why didnt the raid sync I/O show up with vmstat? Question 2: Why was it limited to 17 MB per second? The maximum was left at the default, 200 MB/s. The min was also at the default, 1 MB/s. I get 60 MB/s per disk with hdparm -tT

Re: Raid sync observations

2005-12-20 Thread Andrew Burgess
I just created a RAID array (4-disk RAID-6). When mdadm -C returned, /proc/mdstat showed it syncing the new array at about 17 MB/s. vmstat 1 showed hardly any blocks in or out, and an almost completely idle cpu. Question 1: Why didnt the raid sync I/O show up with vmstat? I switched to iostat

Re: Raid sync observations

2005-12-20 Thread Sebastian Kuzminsky
Andrew Burgess [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Question 1: Why didnt the raid sync I/O show up with vmstat? I switched to iostat because of similar observations with vmstat. iostat at least shows you which devices it is looking at and it agrees with /proc/mdstat's numbers in my experience. Right.

Re: Raid sync observations

2005-12-20 Thread Jeff Breidenbach
I'll just call it sync access pattern overhead then. As another data point, I've been adding more and more drives to a RAID-1 array. Yesterday I just added a fourth disk which is still syncing. mdadm --grow /dev/md0 -n4 mdadm --manage /dev/md0 --add /dev/sde md0 : active raid1