Re: [pfSense] ipsec packets in one direction are too big

2013-10-28 Thread Dan

On 10/28/2013 02:19 PM, compdoc wrote:


>Any thoughts??

May not answer your question, but you did ask...

I set up my first ipsec tunnel with pfSense and it has been wonderful, 
but I had to set System menu > Advanced > Miscellaneous tab > Enable 
MSS clamping on VPN traffic, and set it to 1375 before I got a stable 
connection. Before that SSH seemed to work, but VNC and RDP 
connections would just stall until I changed the setting.


 I read about using TCP-MSS to handle issues like this.  I feel like 
this is just putting a hack together instead of fixing the actual 
problem.. thanks though
___
List mailing list
List@lists.pfsense.org
http://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list


Re: [pfSense] ipsec packets in one direction are too big

2013-10-28 Thread compdoc
> Any thoughts??

 

May not answer your question, but you did ask...

 

I set up my first ipsec tunnel with pfSense and it has been wonderful, but I
had to set System menu > Advanced > Miscellaneous tab > Enable MSS clamping
on VPN traffic, and set it to 1375 before I got a stable connection. Before
that SSH seemed to work, but VNC and RDP connections would just stall until
I changed the setting. 

 

 

___
List mailing list
List@lists.pfsense.org
http://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list


[pfSense] ipsec packets in one direction are too big

2013-10-28 Thread Dan

Hi,

I am stumped on this one.   I have three sites.  Each one connects to 
the other two via ipsec.  I'm having an issue in only one direction, and 
I cannot figure out what is going on.



To test, I am using the following ping command.
ping -D -s 1472 


Site A(10.1.0.1)
- can ping site B and C with "-s 1472"

Site B(10.2.0.1)
 - can ping site A with "-s 1472"
 - can ping site C with "-s 1410"Max. If I go higher, my ping reaches 
site C, but the reply doesn't make it back.


Site C(10.3.0.1)
 - can ping site A with "-s 1472"
 - can ping site Bwith "-s 1410" Max.


I ran tcpdump on Site C interface enc0, and sent a ping -s 1472 from 
Site B. tcpdump shows the ping coming in, and the reply going out. If I 
initiate a ping from site C, and runtcpdump on site B, I don't see 
anything coming in.
Using public IP addresses (with no ipsec), Site C can then ping B with 
-s 1472. so I don't believe it is an MTU issu.



Anythoughts??


___
List mailing list
List@lists.pfsense.org
http://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list