Re: [pfSense] pfsense 2.4rc wirespeed?

2017-09-03 Thread Eero Volotinen 
Thanks for information. I didn't know that about speedtest.

Tested with laptop from switch and now speed looks cool:
http://beta.speedtest.net/result/6593218471

So, my hardware has enought power to process almost gigabit wirespeed :)

Eero

2017-09-03 14:20 GMT+03:00 Adam Thompson :

> The speedteet server code is not optimized for high upload speed
> measurement. When running speedtest from a machine on the same subnet, in
> the same rack in the same data center as the speedtest server (I worked for
> an ISP) you will still get funny results. Or even two VMs running on the
> same hypervisor, more recently at a different ISP.
> Use iperf or something (anything!) better to make more accurate
> measurements before questioning pfSense, IMHO.
> -Adam
>
> On September 3, 2017 3:59:24 AM CDT, Eero Volotinen 
> wrote:
>
>> Hi,
>>
>> Is there any setting to optimize pfsense nat speed?
>>
>> Tried with speedtest and upload speed is abit slow?
>>
>> Retrieving speedtest.net configuration...
>> Testing from Suomi Communications (77.246.193.181)...
>> Retrieving speedtest.net server list...
>> Selecting best server based on ping...
>> Hosted by Elisa Oyj (Helsinki) [9.91 km]: 3.648 ms
>> Testing download
>> speed
>> Download: 882.05 Mbit/s
>> Testing upload
>> speed
>> Upload: 249.09 Mbit/s
>>
>> Link is symmetric gigabit carrier grade line. Just wondering why upload
>> speed is so slow and download is much faster?
>>
>> --
>> Eero
>> --
>>
>> pfSense mailing list
>> https://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list
>> Support the project with Gold! https://pfsense.org/gold
>>
>>
> --
> Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.
>
___
pfSense mailing list
https://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list
Support the project with Gold! https://pfsense.org/gold

Re: [pfSense] pfsense 2.4rc wirespeed?

2017-09-03 Thread Adam Thompson 
The speedteet server code is not optimized for high upload speed measurement.  
When running speedtest from a machine on the same subnet, in the same rack in 
the same data center as the speedtest server (I worked for an ISP) you will 
still get funny results.  Or even two VMs running on the same hypervisor, more 
recently at a different ISP.
Use iperf or something (anything!) better to make more accurate measurements 
before questioning pfSense, IMHO.
-Adam

On September 3, 2017 3:59:24 AM CDT, Eero Volotinen  
wrote:
>Hi,
>
>Is there any setting to optimize pfsense nat speed?
>
>Tried with speedtest and upload speed is abit slow?
>
>Retrieving speedtest.net configuration...
>Testing from Suomi Communications (77.246.193.181)...
>Retrieving speedtest.net server list...
>Selecting best server based on ping...
>Hosted by Elisa Oyj (Helsinki) [9.91 km]: 3.648 ms
>Testing download
>speed
>Download: 882.05 Mbit/s
>Testing upload
>speed
>Upload: 249.09 Mbit/s
>
>Link is symmetric gigabit carrier grade line. Just wondering why upload
>speed is so slow and download is much faster?
>
>--
>Eero
>___
>pfSense mailing list
>https://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list
>Support the project with Gold! https://pfsense.org/gold

-- 
Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.
___
pfSense mailing list
https://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list
Support the project with Gold! https://pfsense.org/gold

Re: [pfSense] pfsense 2.4rc wirespeed?

2017-09-03 Thread Eero Volotinen 
System is this:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B016VHBA7C/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o00_s00?ie=UTF8=1
http://www.supermicro.com/products/motherboard/Atom/X10/A1SRi-2558F.cfm

Intel(R) Atom(TM) CPU C2558 @ 2.40GHz
4 CPUs: 1 package(s) x 4 core(s)
AES-NI CPU Crypto: Yes (active)

If it can download over 800Mbit/s, why it cannot upload at same speed?
(tester is speedtest-cli)

Eero



2017-09-03 13:52 GMT+03:00 Alexandre Paradis :

> it might be your desktop cpu that is too weak.
>
> not enough info here.
>
> On Sun, Sep 3, 2017 at 4:59 AM, Eero Volotinen 
> wrote:
>
> > Hi,
> >
> > Is there any setting to optimize pfsense nat speed?
> >
> > Tried with speedtest and upload speed is abit slow?
> >
> > Retrieving speedtest.net configuration...
> > Testing from Suomi Communications (77.246.193.181)...
> > Retrieving speedtest.net server list...
> > Selecting best server based on ping...
> > Hosted by Elisa Oyj (Helsinki) [9.91 km]: 3.648 ms
> > Testing download
> > speed...
> .
> > Download: 882.05 Mbit/s
> > Testing upload
> > speed...
> > .
> > Upload: 249.09 Mbit/s
> >
> > Link is symmetric gigabit carrier grade line. Just wondering why upload
> > speed is so slow and download is much faster?
> >
> > --
> > Eero
> > ___
> > pfSense mailing list
> > https://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list
> > Support the project with Gold! https://pfsense.org/gold
> >
>
>
>
> --
> Alexandre
>
>
>
> -BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-
> Version: Mailvelope v1.3.2
> Comment: https://www.mailvelope.com
>
> xsFNBFZvl5sBEACmVYP3VsN/OtDyb+oNz9GHcN2fdWIeil+N3gL7vRuhcb+x
> 6D3uHiC5kqtvivGVuV+/jQK1OFkHRki8CBFKjAAtGZbZ3qeKRjuZlU+McZv0
> dh9J/ELp1LdQ1NH1WFTDYUDaPW+7aQaBa8TsRnmEX9759XYJGc36FYf+Y1CN
> AB2AOA04JHcaspZyDwa8KP3G6rqCGs5+D/kJB5qrMW0nuMamlaT71lHYhb1l
> 9LzU90sdRw0mkMNqf4J2iK6w/cBMlWOfHMo3LtuWkrTFacqvNbxq2+AnKO6w
> XgYu4qKxapk7wQeDuzsocJX3iSAT/xfNki7GU6X8YVyMaevAHqTuyyTPzTH5
> nMdt8Yuvqh8AThRR9EjVCuXJdNPAnr+QLXqDta2lY3J+RwLxSfW6ypOh+YuX
> CMuqYvyra7btroosbYvQVLIPAVoTAvjqEV86Y1puNPx/Uw49pp0aWtgpp+Zi
> a233R+fm/W13NqvyPljEkD1EMunKpSA6kF2czN4GEV4vCfpK6Gr+vr8TiPz6
> h42Ke2fXNe6XbF3RJL3Jtjm1BGZv1qrIEXyuDyNBq3OA+5aetMYkXqhtv66x
> OEzfAJQRJFWVpIHdniTSdbV1Udmv2ALfeY2BAMbxY3qvHS/3DMKTafjdSRPv
> ikWxxBBD8r5ObLcbm/8Z1AMpzHWXpLercKzGoQARAQABzS9BbGV4YW5kcmUg
> UGFyYWRpcyA8YWxleGFuZHJlLnBhcmFkaXNAZ21haWwuY29tPsLBdQQQAQgA
> KQUCVm+XnwYLCQgHAwIJEIy6zwnSMMDIBBUIAgoDFgIBAhkBAhsDAh4BAABm
> fBAAn1CBuE15s53nNpgwO6XRW7xIP2HcZpkt5eAJCB5QqX3Y3+9JGRlLhNeZ
> 7kEvSnnLRghJ398GCpqYFgC5YndbEJAiFVNWddMr6SD7V+YFt6pZXD+daGWq
> leNnTpdvGaxoO0x57ljp0pQxylK4J1tJzun1182Ux9h2RJzXPmBU6WE86Lmv
> hKrxCEDf11QcbxGL9MzMXVNP6dzTjxB22xHlTjVYmwgbdOVE57bKnpvQujby
> lDW7WanGH5nMWynJlL6Tz81xjQyK8kmnNQ+l8Rh95vBwIaZ4l4xpD1breuwZ
> xat+LrQlfZ37frOYDgtFtWAooYhTquQgErVEzELZS66MbaKQcRTjosX8yp8P
> 4H5RCl1xPgYyK0lhpIMf0Wlyj12XqvC926ilmiF9ZkU+PtCgWmOHRtelD2r/
> mcjSCfqn4DbQ+xwiGwQco+nNZQrOaeRczwnXWQzN3tHlzRIS9NTvdQASW5WO
> sEfOhbBVjC9Xvs3KM5/DRcKqk5xmGTg2VpH8YJgM0XL2NbB3hihYCd1jflgF
> rn1wCA2QGJyxSBy9V5WZlUvgR4rzNz+wIeBH7VogMb8mvginyGugd5CnUAs+
> HL7gNaWK3CePDrzDd1WbbvgEg/s9yRFS7cJ7igP9F4asLRkJkCP8JKWP27bt
> 7lo6iz6zp1TwLgseqDE2X9PgibDOwU0EVm+XmwEQANeWM/KTDbY8MwN/Lti2
> i3UUDxY/ddIntDRPVvtZazZ0N//7X0TSobtIbptTtEsOeBtgeGCKLTKYqnRt
> 89I/3dv1QHS1YUdwk/MCRiXt/JKsZJxGs8oJLBbhHQBGtGzKZWFA3RP9WrCi
> 8zwZz/O75Id4JgkYk1KAmIAqxpukIrZfbo7k8in2cjr9M82/i5v60mO3ChGD
> mzf+Vs/FA/g7qDjmHYz12KdWOTdEMeKfjYwRpNkW3EYs6h2MfeOnsSHih1BR
> xh3tpFLki3nvGfIXUTCHpluyJFLeWZDpppfF76wLZdj18dQ7UEMXLByUL/ig
> BQCsqrCHQDcn31IEFkfe2kjVtr0wY4bPovuFIwUrcAD4msJg4G9xNtiRtr5C
> KBzO1BwKINybjw/eWiRkxpgYCrCsW49LtIdUc1Gz3KvLOTR9E2qPvwT5TlOm
> f0cHdkmoxB4xYFCkFz85Kg2pTtAvGSiRSgKHYZkEJBIgfnupLuciLyET4auN
> GYqrc9Hk6toithUQsN35pTN0s9jUU1g+5z/Wo4e6Wwj55Xu/ulZn7cd3XkCn
> u2TI9s+agUfvd4Zg9cQRFHclkuqd1FIX+KLdIvHdn9tMwf1bbPbo2aaYilpg
> YqBXmxQKSjXdcYOfNBc1e2+snpcmr2E60RA4VMYRJRhqKZtfm86XVqqn+5iu
> 4fUTABEBAAHCwV8EGAEIABMFAlZvl6IJEIy6zwnSMMDIAhsMAAA1rQ//bJmC
> F7S3fx5LyTAHd7jK/nNNAUfeEbsFaDHMts8uN4S0//E1qk1CW0an2kUoQBAX
> ATRd4agJeXX0IIxEgizyz0+xOSuetgXTeYtI/B1dg64/62V/hCkBZp3gYPOX
> k1jrOGUq4fMfkS4Vrm+Jf0fspPoDHj2WbA5/uxGTZWvcRqnfbPfwuMwJj/NS
> tNu8tkiC8ty4yXbiEYLHw0e1pDyHQ4hnFNr3l3/Cshj7CJjUIDNWYcNwYvRW
> Y+KZEVdE1a83ViwsSam5D1+qpXlhv52RAZ3zdm8KsPYshnL4zLqFz1eQFTk3
> x9sFJml482D0m5XK2qi5wlqljdeeLaNTa6QGoTnWGfW0zbH0ure/uiaFtO7H
> FOW+G1pP+9N2F4r7CgQAi/voxBzdOZUCwDDFYECWkQEaotPInv0YMbXtj/7Y
> zkWUpUHR5QCowODoqe8mcWDQfEOiLmot6c1lH4cZ7B3qwGCBE+MIhKewKxMD
> QZUdpetSGi1Yz8BmU61dRIuI6HwDCzuWd+dpp+YxUZgeoQN7eNtuVx8vcQOs
> sjoOGKnmNK82p3IEzewj4e5BgUW7W+rrpaHNFglYe0HKHMFGzz2An33gh/gt
> 7COGkOFYZmOEiUKhirIJ6DDhtbPk8wo1tElEaJZVAqk7Ob3DDppuluD+3VQR
> 0PVTVI2aJDUfB3Nkx4Q=
> =eaR0
> -END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-
> ___
> pfSense mailing list
>

Re: [pfSense] pfsense 2.4rc wirespeed?

2017-09-03 Thread Alexandre Paradis 
it might be your desktop cpu that is too weak.

not enough info here.

On Sun, Sep 3, 2017 at 4:59 AM, Eero Volotinen 
wrote:

> Hi,
>
> Is there any setting to optimize pfsense nat speed?
>
> Tried with speedtest and upload speed is abit slow?
>
> Retrieving speedtest.net configuration...
> Testing from Suomi Communications (77.246.193.181)...
> Retrieving speedtest.net server list...
> Selecting best server based on ping...
> Hosted by Elisa Oyj (Helsinki) [9.91 km]: 3.648 ms
> Testing download
> speed
> Download: 882.05 Mbit/s
> Testing upload
> speed...
> .
> Upload: 249.09 Mbit/s
>
> Link is symmetric gigabit carrier grade line. Just wondering why upload
> speed is so slow and download is much faster?
>
> --
> Eero
> ___
> pfSense mailing list
> https://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list
> Support the project with Gold! https://pfsense.org/gold
>



-- 
Alexandre



-BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-
Version: Mailvelope v1.3.2
Comment: https://www.mailvelope.com
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=eaR0
-END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-
___
pfSense mailing list
https://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list
Support the project with Gold! https://pfsense.org/gold

[pfSense] pfsense 2.4rc wirespeed?

2017-09-03 Thread Eero Volotinen 
Hi,

Is there any setting to optimize pfsense nat speed?

Tried with speedtest and upload speed is abit slow?

Retrieving speedtest.net configuration...
Testing from Suomi Communications (77.246.193.181)...
Retrieving speedtest.net server list...
Selecting best server based on ping...
Hosted by Elisa Oyj (Helsinki) [9.91 km]: 3.648 ms
Testing download
speed
Download: 882.05 Mbit/s
Testing upload
speed
Upload: 249.09 Mbit/s

Link is symmetric gigabit carrier grade line. Just wondering why upload
speed is so slow and download is much faster?

--
Eero
___
pfSense mailing list
https://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list
Support the project with Gold! https://pfsense.org/gold