Re: Detection of design defects

2006-02-27 Thread Yann-Gaël Guéhéneuc
Dear Elias, Thanks for the ref.! Sincerely, Yann-Gaël Elias Ross a écrit : On Sat, 2006-02-25 at 22:48 -0500, Yoav Shapira wrote: And it'd be interesting to see a comparison of your tool to checkstyle and PMD, both fairly well-established and good tools for t

Re: Detection of design defects

2006-02-27 Thread Yann-Gaël Guéhéneuc
Dear all, That's a very interesting idea! Especially because checkstyle, PMD, and SAD (for Software Architectural Defect, the name of our framework) do not work at the same level of "abstraction". If I am not mistaked, checkstyle checks coding standards at the source code line level,

Re: Detection of design defects

2006-02-27 Thread Elias Ross
On Sat, 2006-02-25 at 22:48 -0500, Yoav Shapira wrote: > And it'd be interesting to see a comparison of your tool to checkstyle > and PMD, both fairly well-established and good tools for the same > purpose... The "findbugs" tool is another possible tool to use and also catches possible locking and

Re: Detection of design defects

2006-02-26 Thread Mladen Adamovic
Yann-Gaël Guéhéneuc wrote: We develop a framework to describe design defects synthetically and to detect these in program source code automatically. We are currently performing experiments to assess our detection algorithms. If anybody is considering using that reverse engineering

Re: Detection of design defects

2006-02-25 Thread Yoav Shapira
And it'd be interesting to see a comparison of your tool to checkstyle and PMD, both fairly well-established and good tools for the same purpose... On 2/25/06, Scott Deboy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > That is a very old version of log4j. Feel free to analyze a recent release > (or the current re

RE: Detection of design defects

2006-02-25 Thread Scott Deboy
That is a very old version of log4j. Feel free to analyze a recent release (or the current release), we'd be happy to hear your results. Thanks Scott Deboy COMOTIV SYSTEMS 111 SW Columbia Street Ste. 950 Portland, OR 97201 Telephone: 503.224.7496 Cell: 503.997.1367 Fax: