RE: When will the next version be released?

2009-04-06 Thread Wayne Bradney
You know you've been working too long when it takes a minute or so to realize that the intent of "PIA" was "pain in the ass" rather than "Primary Interop Assembly"... Wayne M. Bradney  Chief Application Architect, Derivatives & Structured Products  Wall Street Systems, 1290 Avenue of the A

RE: When will the next version be released?

2009-04-06 Thread Neil Haughton
Sounds like a good compromise. Strong naming can be a real PIA if you don't actually want the "benefits" it brings. Regards,   Neil Haughton BSc MIET IEng(CEI) Development Manager   Autoscribe Limited Wellington House Riseley Business Park Basingstoke Road, Riseley Berkshire RG7 1NW   Office: +44

RE: When will the next version be released?

2009-04-06 Thread Walden H. Leverich
> A strong name includes the version number as well as the key. And that's the problem. Any change that results in a new version # (even a trivial build # jump) means you need to fix the references. I actually find the GAC not very useful. Sure, core .NET files should be there, but I can drop th

RE: When will the next version be released?

2009-04-06 Thread daniel . nitecki
A strong name includes the version number as well as the key. Strong naming is also required for installation in to the GAC, which I find useful for utilities such as loggers. 2 cents, Dan

RE: When will the next version be released?

2009-04-06 Thread Simon Tamman
Wouldn't they use the same private key across upgrades? I would assume they would. The strong naming afaik is to ensure that people can't create "unoffial" releases with the claim that they're official releases. I figured it was for legal and integrity reasons. Simon

RE: When will the next version be released?

2009-04-06 Thread Walden H. Leverich
> Because if you don't, surely you risk breaking existing applications when you upgrade log4net? You might. But that's a decision and assessment that I can make when I choose to do the upgrade. I can (somewhat) see the point on two DLLs (or DLL and EXE) that are part of the same package. Say t

RE: When will the next version be released?

2009-04-06 Thread Neil Haughton
Because if you don't, surely you risk breaking existing applications when you upgrade log4net? Regards, Neil Haughton BSc MIET IEng(CEI) Development Manager Autoscribe Limited Wellington House Riseley Business Park Basingstoke Road, Riseley Berkshire RG7 1NW Office: +44 (0) 118 984

RE: When will the next version be released?

2009-04-06 Thread Walden H. Leverich
I forget, is the "official" release strongly named? And if so, did those other components reference it by strong name? I tend to hate strong naming! It's a logging component, if there's an upgrade I should be able to use it, why should I be tied to an older version just because you built against th