Re: [Lsr] [Idr] IGP Monitoring Protocol

2022-07-19 Thread Jeffrey Haas
Chris, > On Jul 16, 2022, at 6:19 PM, Christian Hopps wrote: > > > Robert Raszuk writes: > >> Btw this independent attempt by two WG groups to normalize link state >> data is a clear proof that the YANG model has failed here. > > I'm not sure which "YANG model" you are referring to here

Re: [Lsr] [Idr] IGP Monitoring Protocol

2022-07-11 Thread Jeffrey Haas
Jeff, > On Jul 10, 2022, at 5:14 PM, Jeff Tantsura wrote: > > Thanks Sue! > > We don’t have to always reinvent the wheel (at least not every time ) > I’m aware of at least 1 implementation streaming LSDB for TE consumers (gRPC) > There are most probably some other vendor specific

Re: [Lsr] [Idr] IGP Monitoring Protocol

2022-07-10 Thread Jeff Tantsura
Thanks Sue!We don’t have to always reinvent the wheel (at least not every time )I’m aware of at least 1 implementation streaming LSDB for TE consumers (gRPC)There are most probably some other vendor specific encodings/methods to steam to do that I believe – there has been some work around Kafka. 

Re: [Lsr] [Idr] IGP Monitoring Protocol

2022-07-09 Thread Susan Hares
Jeff: An interim sounds like a good plan. [IDR-chair hat] Alvaro has indicated that since all of the proposal received on the IDR list are new protocol proposals, * Capturing IDR’s input on BGP-LS problems and potential solutions is appropriate for IDR as BGP-LS home. * Refining any

Re: [Lsr] [Idr] IGP Monitoring Protocol

2022-07-09 Thread Robert Raszuk
Thx Jeff ! Also I welcome more reviews and suggestions for additions or deletions of parts of it. For now I tried to keep it very simple for routers - essentially setup new p2p TCP or QUIC sessions and send over exactly what you put in BGP today. In the same time I see use cases beyond that so

Re: [Lsr] [Idr] IGP Monitoring Protocol

2022-07-09 Thread Jeff Tantsura
Speaking as RTGWG chair: Robert - I don’t think we’d have enough time to accommodate a good discussion during IETF114 (we got only 1 slot), however would be happy to provide a platform for an interim. The topic is important and personally (being a very large BGP-LS user) I’d like to see it