Re: [Lsr] Enhancement related to Area Leader Sub-TLV

2019-05-28 Thread Tony Li
Hi Huaimo, > It seems that it is OK for only the leader advertises Area Leader sub-TLV. I disagree. Again, without other advertisements, the entire domain is at risk of losing the Area Leader and having an uncomfortable transition. > After the old/current leader is down, a new leader wi

Re: [Lsr] Enhancement related to Area Leader Sub-TLV

2019-05-28 Thread Huaimo Chen
Hi Tony, After moving, it seems OK for only the leader advertises a (Updated) Area Leader Sub-TLV. After the old/current leader dies, a new leader will be elected and the new leader will advertises a (Updated) Area Leader Sub-TLV. Since the other nodes do not advertise any Area Leader

Re: [Lsr] Enhancement related to Area Leader Sub-TLV

2019-05-28 Thread Huaimo Chen
y 27, 2019 7:50 PM To: tony...@tony.li Cc: lsr@ietf.org Subject: Re: [Lsr] Enhancement related to Area Leader Sub-TLV Hi Tony, Thank you for your explanations. After moving one byte for the priority from Area Leader Sub-TLV to Dynamic Flooding Sub-TLV, only one Area Leader Sub-TLV

Re: [Lsr] Enhancement related to Area Leader Sub-TLV

2019-05-28 Thread tony . li
Hi Huaimo, > Before moving, each of N nodes may advertise an Area Leader Sub-TLV and a > Dynamic Flooding Sub-TLV. After moving, only the leader node advertises a > (Updated) Area Leader Sub-TLV. The Area Leader sub-TLV should be advertised by all nodes that are candidates to being Area

Re: [Lsr] Enhancement related to Area Leader Sub-TLV

2019-05-28 Thread Les Ginsberg (ginsberg)
o not expect ALL nodes to advertise Area Leader Sub-TLV - which means the savings you calculate below isn't real. Les From: Lsr On Behalf Of Huaimo Chen Sent: Monday, May 27, 2019 7:50 PM To: tony...@tony.li Cc: lsr@ietf.org Subject: Re: [Lsr] Enhancement related to Area Leader Sub-TLV

Re: [Lsr] Enhancement related to Area Leader Sub-TLV

2019-05-27 Thread Huaimo Chen
Hi Tony, Thank you for your explanations. After moving one byte for the priority from Area Leader Sub-TLV to Dynamic Flooding Sub-TLV, only one Area Leader Sub-TLV is advertised. For an area with N nodes supporting both centralized and distributed mode, my understanding is below.

Re: [Lsr] Enhancement related to Area Leader Sub-TLV

2019-05-24 Thread tony . li
Hi Huaimo, Thank you for your proposal. The area leader sub-tlv is only advertised by systems that are willing to be area leader. Presumably, that’s not necessarily all of the ones who support dynamic flooding. Thus, what you’re proposing moves one byte from one TLV into another TLV that wi