[LUTE] Re: Corelli sonata for violin and lute

2014-01-24 Thread arebh
When I bought my archlute, Lynda Sayce told that the archlute was first and foremost used in Rome, or by musicians trained in Rome. Are Dear Gary , Here are the links to the first editions, on IMSLP. Both are published in Roma, and mention arcileuto. The publications you cited are

[LUTE] Re: Say love and Queen Elizabeth

2014-01-24 Thread Ron Andrico
Dear Ralf: Perhaps one is a bit hasty to pass judgement from afar on the sharpness of another person's tools without seeing the larger context of the work. I observe here and on other comment forums that it is easy to throw a good idea off-track by distracting with humorous

[LUTE] archlute/theorbo in Corelli's Op. 1

2014-01-24 Thread Gary R. Boye
Dear Jean Michel, Yes; interesting! We are only talking about Corelli's Op. 1 (Opp. 2-4 all call for archlute according to surviving editions--no mention of theorbo there). I suppose this could either reflect common practice in a city (Rome vs. Bologna/Venice) or publisher preference. Or just

[LUTE] Re: archlute/theorbo in Corelli's Op. 1

2014-01-24 Thread jean-michel Catherinot
great, Gary!Thank you for this sum up. I searched some weeks ago on RISM with the key arciliuto and so on. Apart for its use in Roma (and +?), it's outstanding that you find arciliuto obligato in Dresden 's opera (Hasse's Cleofide for instance) at the time of Weiss (and not

[LUTE] Re: archlute/theorbo in Corelli's Op. 1

2014-01-24 Thread Geoff Gaherty
On 24/01/14 9:19 AM, Gary R. Boye wrote: Yes; interesting! We are only talking about Corelli's Op. 1 (Opp. 2-4 all call for archlute according to surviving editions--no mention of theorbo there). I suppose this could either reflect common practice in a city (Rome vs. Bologna/Venice) or publisher

[LUTE] Re: archlute/theorbo in Corelli's Op. 1

2014-01-24 Thread Arthur Ness
Yes, and some of those archiliuto opera orchestral parts from Dresden have notations that have been identified as being in S.L. Weiss's handwriting! Some were displayed at the Freiburg Weiss Conference in 1984(??). Andre Bourget (liuto forte guy) gathered all kinds of interesting things for that

[LUTE] Re: archlute/theorbo in Corelli's Op. 1

2014-01-24 Thread David Tayler
The terms arciliuto and tiorba are high-degree interchangeable. That is, they are not low or medium, and they are also not completely interchangeable (since they are sometimes used together). One could argue that they are medium instead of high, but it would be difficult to show

[LUTE] Re: archlute/theorbo in Corelli's Op. 1

2014-01-24 Thread Ralf Bachmann
Hello dear Arthur, 1984 I was living in Karlsruhe and working on my PhD-Thesis in Chemistry. Ah, those pre-Internet times, FORTRAN computer programming with punch cards, text only monitors, etc. My contact with the lute-world was through the Gitarre Laute magazin and the only

[LUTE] Say love and Queen Elizabeth

2014-01-24 Thread Stewart McCoy
Dear Ron, The reactions to my email about a possible connection between Dowland's Say love and Queen Elizabeth's Galliard has drawn some predictable responses, including a welcome and encouraging Fascinating. Bravo! from Arthur. I can understand the reticence of Ralf and Howard in accepting

[LUTE] Re: Say love and Queen Elizabeth

2014-01-24 Thread Stephan Olbertz
Dear Stewart and all, I also think your points are fascinating, to say the least. On the case of the Susanna allusion in Unquiet Thoughts, it seems to refer to the most catchy phrase in the madrigal, which is the reason why it caught my ear also. I recall to have heard it elsewhere in lute