[LUTE] Re: Re-entrant open basses

2018-10-23 Thread howard posner
> On Oct 23, 2018, at 12:44 AM, mjlh...@cs.dartmouth.edu wrote: > > Following on from the discussion about strings and perhaps a bit of a > non-sequitur, the well known painting by Antiveduto Grammatica shows a > lute-shaped instrument with 5 courses on the fingerboard and 9 open > basses.

[LUTE] Re: Different arciliuti

2018-10-23 Thread Mimmo - Aquila Corde Armoniche
Hello there, I would like to do a precisation in matter of the whole gut. Actually, what I have written in the past is that it is not possible to employ whole gut because the gauge that it is possible to obtain for example with 3 whole guts (i.e. the violin 1st) do not produce a gauge of about

[LUTE] Re: Different arciliuti

2018-10-23 Thread Martyn Hodgson
Dear Andreas, In fact I agree with some of your assessment of pitch limitations for particular string length: in particular when you now write 'it seems not impossible to have an archlute with a chanterelle in g' (340 Hz) with a string length of 73 cm' . This string length and

[LUTE] Re-entrant open basses

2018-10-23 Thread mjlh...@cs.dartmouth.edu
Following on from the discussion about strings and perhaps a bit of a non-sequitur, the well known painting by Antiveduto Grammatica shows a lute-shaped instrument with 5 courses on the fingerboard and 9 open basses. The two lowest bass courses i.e.8 and 9 appear to be thinner than the other

[LUTE] Re: Different arciliuti

2018-10-23 Thread Andreas Schlegel
Dear Martyn In my opinion, your argument takes the wrong way: Our modern gut strings are more and more reconstructions of the old ones - but we don’t have the experience of the old string makers. I remember that Mimmo said some years ago that it’s impossible to make strings from whole guts.