[LUTE] Re: tuner

2007-12-19 Thread Daniel Winheld
As an infidel heretic myself with a tin ear I salute and welcome you and thanks very much for a heads up on this tuner. Between my Baroque lute of a mere 24 strings and my wife's harpsichord any good tuner will not be bored or underemployed here. Before the batteries wear out on the Violab

[LUTE] Re: Continuo is the king/queen!

2007-12-19 Thread Daniel Winheld
Singers are the best, because normally they don't know anything of the rhythm and pulse; you normally will be the boss with the singers... My experience has been that when playing with someone who has the lead role and has to breathe, you are most definitely NOT the boss- merely an at-will

[LUTE] Re: Wikiality

2007-12-18 Thread Daniel Winheld
Andrew, It is hard to read between the tears. ray Read further: Lutenist: The lutenist is simply an instrument plucker without a neck. He considers himself a much more dignified plucker than the guitarist, although he is similar in construction to the guitarist with the exclusion of his

[LUTE] Re: Wikiality

2007-12-18 Thread Daniel Winheld
Without a neck? He couldn't be a violinist either, - he'd never get it under his chin! Where do you think treble viol players come from? Wickedpedia- a never ending resource! -- To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

[LUTE] Re: Personal Awesomeness Index

2007-12-17 Thread Daniel Winheld
The Parnassus of Awesomeness- going beyond the merely personal- would then have to be Thomas Mace's Lute Diphone - a 12 course double-head head lute mated to an English Theorbo; an idea that he put into Musicke's Monument to help with his growing deafness. Happy Christmas to you too. Dan I

[LUTE] Re: Funny string story

2007-12-16 Thread Daniel Winheld
Is it a Baroque or a Renaissance string? Is it a thumb under or a thumb out string? Does it warble? Does it sing? We need no lute, It's the whole damn thing! The person at the postal window had a difficult time finding the proper code, so I sincerely hope it gets there. I clearly marked on the

[LUTE] Re: standing position for playing

2007-12-11 Thread Daniel Winheld
Sorry Martin, I can only recall that I did read it in a friend's copy many years ago. Although I don't have an eidetic memory (I have the other kind) it did strike me very strongly. I hope someone else on the list can jump in, verify my recollection and pin down the quote. The most spectacular

[LUTE] Re: Swanneck + loaded strings

2007-12-10 Thread Daniel Winheld
Go for a lesson with Nigel North. The first thing that happened when he didn't like my sound was to grab my right hand, check the finger tips, and start sanding! He comes equipped, no doubt expecting more of us to be blue collar lutenists than blue blood. Thank God he doesn't travel with a

[LUTE] Re: baroque lute pitch

2007-12-10 Thread Daniel Winheld
If you take g' at a'=440 as a reasonable pitch for a 60cm string length - and I find a good gut string is fine at that pitch - then the equivalent for f' is about 67cm and for e' about 71cm. So I have no problem tuning a baroque lute to f' at a'=415, as long as the string length is less than

[LUTE] Re: standing position for playing

2007-12-10 Thread Daniel Winheld
Sorry- try this: http://polyhymnion.org/torban/torban3b.html -- -- To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

[LUTE] Re: Old lutes...

2007-12-08 Thread Daniel Winheld
Some historic builders had their own problems- if I remember my secondary sources correctly, the Thirty Years War wiped out the lute building center of Füssen and all lute building traditions associated with it; consequently some of the German 18th century lute building standards were just

[LUTE] LUTE Swanneck Weiss?

2007-12-02 Thread Daniel Winheld
One thing I haven't seen anyone address re the swanneck- fingered accidentals on courses 9 - 11. How are you folks dealing with these situations? Up an octave, or eliminate those pieces from your repertoire? Dan -- To get on or off this list see list information at

[LUTE] Re: In A Garden So Green

2007-12-01 Thread Daniel Winheld
Very nice, indeed. You've still got it. My front lawn should be half as green. Piazzola has its place; but not on the theorbo. Paper plates work just fine. I like mine with anchovy and eggplant. The def is still higher than my perceptual ability at this hour of the morning In a Garden So Green

[LUTE] Re: 13 course rider/swan

2007-12-01 Thread Daniel Winheld
Absolute, bottom line for me- in Weiss's music the 9th-E/Eflat course is just fingered too damn many times to be put on an extension. The 10th and even the 11th also get their share of accidentals- there is at least one fugue that for me loses it all at a very important spot if the fingered

[LUTE] Re: Is 8c really the standard?

2007-11-29 Thread Daniel Winheld
This slow you down aspect is one that I am finally able to address personally after over 35 years of lute playing. I finally got my first 7 course lute last year; an Andreas Holst, 62 cm. SL. All my previous R lutes- 57 to 72 cm- had all been 8 course. (I'm not counting the 10 course and

[LUTE] Re: Specialization (was: 8-course?)

2007-11-29 Thread Daniel Winheld
In this somewhat nihilistically arcane vein I recall Dmitri Shostakovich's instructions on playing his 15th string quartet: I want you to play it so that flies drop dead in midair, and that by the end of the first movement the entire audience has gotten up and left the building. -as best as I

[LUTE] Re: New cittern painting! NOW Caravaggio

2007-11-28 Thread Daniel Winheld
David, I know- it took hours of work with a floor sander for Mel to get all your years of topsoil off the lute (7 course, of course!) I have that you once owned. It was beyond green. My turn to come with something that anagrams nicely on it. I treat mine with dirt. It turns green after a

[LUTE] Re: Is 8c really the standard?

2007-11-28 Thread Daniel Winheld
One of the first lute books I got when I was a wee grasshopper at this lute business (young classical guitarist, late 60's) was a printout of a microfilm of the English version of Adrien LeRoy's book. All the old pass'e mezzi and other dances, for 6 courses. Clearly visible in old handwriting

[LUTE] Re: Is 8c really the standard?

2007-11-26 Thread Daniel Winheld
Right on, Ed! The lute that I call a double 7 (It's NOT an 8 course!). A great majority of the music for which I use that instrument is for 7 course, but it is so very convenient to have both a low F _and_ D, so I do not have to re-tune the 7th course. I also sometimes put octaves on both

[LUTE] Re: Is 8c really the standard?

2007-11-25 Thread Daniel Winheld
Just a passing fancy on the way to 14 course Hell. -- To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

[LUTE] Re: Frets

2007-11-23 Thread Daniel Winheld
Happy hour down at Schroedinger's- Killer martinis. I source all my quantagut from Schroedinger's Gut Hut. It's the real thing. I think. Or at least it might have been. You should google the address; I can't recall what state it will be in. dt -- To get on or off this list see list

[LUTE] Re: Frets

2007-11-22 Thread Daniel Winheld
I'm holding out for quantum frets, that change temperament when you look at them. dt You need a special mechanic for that type of fret- and spectacles of tempered glass. Now we know why the blind lutenist Giacomo Gorzanis favored ET. I used to change temperament whenever my first wife looked

[LUTE] Re: Tuning blues

2007-11-20 Thread Daniel Winheld
In case someone doesn't know it, there's an enjoyable paper by Ross Duffin online: Why I hate Valotti (or is it Young?): http://music.cwru.edu/duffin/ Regards, Stephan How nice to be validated! Thank you so much for the above reference- great article. When I was actively messing around with

[LUTE] Re: Tuning blues

2007-11-20 Thread Daniel Winheld
Not me- keep the gimps; and if the Korg keeps giving you trouble tell it you're taking it out for coffee again... Any ideas about this. Yes I know you are going to tell me to swap my gimped for wirewounds!!! and that the Korg is telling me that the string has gone false One big problem with

[LUTE] Re: Tuning Blues

2007-11-19 Thread Daniel Winheld
Hi Rebecca- love to help, but we need to know the string length. I don't know the extreme limit for a D [EMAIL PROTECTED], but when I had a short scale bass for solo work, I could get up to E @A=440 on 72 cm. w/nylon before the instrument's response pooped out. I usually kept it at 415 to 420

[LUTE] Re: Double Meantone ... 'not in his practice'

2007-11-13 Thread Daniel Winheld
In theory, there is no difference between theory and practice. But in practice, there is. - Yogi Berra Sorry all, couldn't resist. Not quite Lord Copper: the whole point is that he doesn't actually 'do it in practice' as you put it. He ignores (or is ignorant of) the different

[LUTE] Re: vivaldi

2007-11-13 Thread Daniel Winheld
On Nov 13, 2007, at 6:47 AM, Nigel Solomon wrote: Everything about it screams guitar to me: the sound, the nails, the general approach. Yes, a guitar that looks a bit like a lute! To me, everything about it screams liuto attiorbato, like a good many historical instruments in museums with

[LUTE] Re: Renaissance consonance and dissonance

2007-11-13 Thread Daniel Winheld
... I recommend first people learn hexachord theory and play bicinia from Josquin, Lassus Isaac. I assume the Morley can be found reprinted and for sale at any of the usual sources; but is there a good anthology of Bicinia? Funny thing, I was just thinking of them recently as I wanted to get

[LUTE] Re: capo on third fret guitar

2007-11-13 Thread Daniel Winheld
And why wouldn't it work without the capo? Ed Martin has addressed the lute size (and the ever elusive but false Geeness obsession of 20 -21st century lutenists) succinctly and completely. I would only add that one reason for the use of tabulature is precisely BECAUSE the G pitch was but one

[LUTE] Re: is it true?

2007-11-12 Thread Daniel Winheld
The music will sound much more lute-like at that pitch. This statement is misleading. Why would a Terz guitar (guitars scaled to G, built in the early 19th century and also sometimes seen in Mariachi bands) or a capoed E instrument sound more lute- like than my old E bass lute? Even a G lute

[LUTE] Re: is it true?

2007-11-12 Thread Daniel Winheld
I don't mean to be unduly negative here, but that remark hit an old sore spot- I started out on a classical guitar back in the 1960's and people used to tell me- Put a capo on your guitar- NOW you have a lute! Sorry, but I sure as hell did not. And then it took years just to get a bad lute,

[LUTE] Re: Neck section thumb over

2007-11-07 Thread Daniel Winheld
Suggestive of a social reason to change? I think that would be well after the fact of wider necks for easier polyphonic chordal playing as well as extra courses. Perhaps similar to RH thumb style changes in that the thumb-out playing was already well established for technical and sound

[LUTE] Re: Lute spotting

2007-11-07 Thread Daniel Winheld
Surprisingly good sound and playing level- visually pure Monty Python. Doesn't get better than that. -Dan From the Guardian (UK) 13 October: ..if you want a good laugh at the expense of the early-music movement, there is on YouTube an excellent early film of Arnold Dolmetsch playing the

[LUTE] Re: Neck section thumb over

2007-11-07 Thread Daniel Winheld
Too late! Capirola's 2¢ has been accumulating with compound interest for about 500 years just read Capirola! 'Alla volte el si puo accomodarsi su la corde contrabassa su ogni tasto' (Sometimes one can use it to play the contrabass string on any fret). Silvestro Ganassi also writes of

[LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute

2007-11-06 Thread Daniel Winheld
Some of the old Martin OOO and Washburn parlor guitars also had the V-neck. I absolutely hated it. Only on sweaters and undershirts for me.-Dan I prefer a thick neck and even a V neck on a 6 course. If the V (rounded V) is done properly, it fits right into the hand, and you can hang your

[LUTE] Re: historical lute stringings

2007-11-06 Thread Daniel Winheld
interchangeable fingerboards for different temperaments- and there is an Iranian guitarist (forget her name) who has jusdiciously placed tastini on her guitar for Persian microtonal work. Lily Afshar? YES. -- To get on or off this list see list information at

[LUTE] Re: Double Meantone

2007-11-06 Thread Daniel Winheld
... please excuse my ignorance. I don't know about any excusing, but ignorance is not an issue here except my own. I just came up from the lab, where I did a feasibility study for fingering purposes only. 7 string, steel-string guitar; dropped the 4th 5th as per G tuning (which of course it

[LUTE] Re: was historical lute stringings--double first course

2007-11-05 Thread Daniel Winheld
I played for some time an instrument with doubled first course, the spacing was very important and the sound was not good above an F. Exactly my experience- Barber-Harris vihuela, 64.5 cm sl, doubles worked at f, no higher- (instrument as a whole craps out down at e, sounds best somewhere

[LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute

2007-11-05 Thread Daniel Winheld
Interesting- my experience has been the exact opposite. My hybrid 6 course (Arnault de Zwolle body mated to a typical late 15th/early 16th century 8 fret 6 course fingerboard) originally had a very thin neck; extremely uncomfortable (hand cramped up) but only after about 20 minutes or so of

[LUTE] Re: historical lute stringings

2007-11-04 Thread Daniel Winheld
I think Mimmo Peruffo may not reply because he may not want to appear to be advertising his wares on this list. It is a difficult situation for string makers and lute makers whenever they communicate, it could be considered that indirectly they are trying to sell their wares. Couple of

[LUTE] Re: historical lute stringings /Re: marker at 7th fret

2007-11-04 Thread Daniel Winheld
stick something close tothe 7th fret... Alan - Original Message - From: Daniel Winheld [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Sunday, November 04, 2007 6:15 PM Subject: [LUTE] Re: historical lute stringings I think Mimmo Peruffo may not reply because he may not want to appear

[LUTE] Re: historical lute stringings /Re: marker at 7th fret

2007-11-04 Thread Daniel Winheld
Top of the afternoon to you too, Ed- Not against markers, just don't like the appearance. On my 72 cm. 8 course, (that's a LONG highway for these old fingers) Barber put a very discreet little white dot at the seventh, on the neck near the neck/fingerboard junction, worked very well anytime I

[LUTE] Re: was gut now nut

2007-10-26 Thread Daniel Winheld
Alright, this thread has finally bitten me- Where can I get TUSQ? My 7-course badly needs a new nut anyway. Are blanks available? Thanks, Dan W. Compared to standard materials, you'll hear crystal clear bell-like high end, big open lows, and a noticeable increase in overall sustain.TUSQ

[LUTE] Re: String Question

2007-10-18 Thread Daniel Winheld
Craig, I think your friend would be much better off to simply trade for a very cheap, 6-string guitar set up for nylon and just dive right into the Renaissance lute repertoire as is. As was pointed out somewhere, the Barley lute book came out in 1597 for a 6 course lute. As a beginner it will

[LUTE] Re: longbows lutes

2007-10-13 Thread Daniel Winheld
Hi honey I'm home time for some answers- Yep. Archery-derived lutestring hooking would produce deliciously funky sound. Hooking of lute strings would have to be learned independently of archery. At one's very first archery lesson it becomes manifest that the shot cannot come off unless the

[LUTE] Re: Lute Methods

2007-10-13 Thread Daniel Winheld
Some confusion may be due to the works of Allan Alexander, who has composed or arranged and published easy beginner's pieces for Renaissance lute. For what it' worth here is his website: http://home.earthlink.net/~guitarandlute/ dw I believe the Alexander Method is one of

[LUTE] Re: longbows lutes

2007-10-12 Thread Daniel Winheld
A shame that Henry and Liz were not privy to your wisdom. The great target scores of English SPORTING archery, set by A. Horace Ford in the 1850's -unmatched until the 20th century- were accomplished after the advent, flowering, and hegemony of the lute. Are you saying that Howard Posner, Ben

[LUTE] Re: longbows lutes

2007-10-12 Thread Daniel Winheld
Obviously a situation calling for using the mighty Yew tree in its military form. Shakespeare, of course, understood the need for preparing the venue before a concert could proceed- First, we kill all the lawyers... and the longbow, even more than other bows, is a silent weapon well suited

<    1   2   3   4   5