[LUTE] New Baroque lute/Meantone

2008-06-18 Thread Stewart McCoy
Dear David, I am sure you are anything but crazy. :-) The craziness I had in mind, was someone with a modern Neapolitan mandoline tuned in fifths, fixing unmovable metal frets into the fingerboard, unequally spaced, thus limiting the number of notes available for modern music. Your baroque

[LUTE] New Baroque lute/Meantone

2008-06-17 Thread Anthony Hind
Dear lutists Another very basic question about Meantone tuning. As we have taken on board the idea that the 'old ones' first tuned the top string to breaking point and then tuned up the other strings in relation to that (I know this is probably not necessarily true, in particular for

[LUTE] New Baroque lute/Meantone

2008-06-17 Thread Stewart McCoy
Dear Mathias, Funny you should produce this chart. I did one of my own earlier today, much simpler, but with the same conclusion. I ignored the 7th to 11th courses, which present less of a problem, because they are usually played open. This was my chart for the first three courses of a baroque