Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-16 Thread Jon Murphy
Martin, We seem to have said a similar thing at about the same time, I saw your message after I sent mine, and I'm sure you did the same. You expressed it more briefly, and probably better. I do tend to ramble on on the topic based on my BA in Psych from 1957, which gives me no more knowledge than

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-16 Thread Jon Murphy
> You're confusing Steinbeck's tales told about two idiots, if I can > paraphrase Shakespeare. Lenny in "Of Mice and Men" has enormous physical > strength. The ursine Johnny Bear in "The Voice of Johnny Bear" can > reproduce overheard conversations, exactly imitating the speakers' voices. And t

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-16 Thread Jon Murphy
s more to recall. We are good, but Google we ain't. Best, Jon - Original Message - From: "Arthur Ness (boston)" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "LUTE NET" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Wednesday, October 15, 2003 9:18 AM Subject: Re: The cost of lute music > Hello

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-15 Thread Arthur Ness (boston)
. The Columbus catalogue is p=ublished in an article by Catherine Weeks Chapman in Journal of the American Musicological Society 21 (1968): 34-84. I don't know if this gets us any nearer establishing the "cost of lute music" back then. arthur.

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-15 Thread Howard Posner
Arthur Ness (boston) at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > There's an > idiot savant in one of Steinbeck's short stories, Oh yes. Of Mice and Men. > Wasn't he called "Bear"? You're confusing Steinbeck's tales told about two idiots, if I can paraphrase Shakespeare. Lenny in "Of Mice and Men" has enormou

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-15 Thread Martin Shepherd
- Original Message - From: Stewart McCoy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Lute Net <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: 15 October 2003 00:17 Subject: The cost of lute music > "Boone was musical successor to the dichotic phenomenon Blind Tom, > who, though said to be semi-idi

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-15 Thread Arthur Ness (boston)
Hello Rainer, Sorry, I'm just a layman. But I know the feeling. Sometimes I just can't resist too. Dr. K. told me how he made the calculations in his head. So unlike others who can do such things without thinking, he had trained himself. It was a matter of adding and subtracting numbers from

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-14 Thread Roman Turovsky
Another comparison: A Russian nanny in NYC for a week costs 50 sheets of cheapish printmaking paper. A Polish nanny costs 70. A Trinidadian nanny with a Green Card costs 100+. RT __ Roman M. Turovsky http://turovsky.org http://polyhymnion.org > Roman commented: >> I once looked >>

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-14 Thread adS
Arthur Ness (boston) wrote: snip > > There are some remarkable musical minds. One was a colleague from Holland, > a Dr. K. He had a photographic memory and perfect pitch, and was somewhat > of a whiz at mathematics (he could add up 30 or 40 numbers in a few > seconds, and then give the average)

The cost of lute music

2003-10-14 Thread Stewart McCoy
iginal Message - From: "Howard Posner" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Stewart McCoy" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Tuesday, October 14, 2003 12:48 AM Subject: Re: The cost of lute music > Stewart McCoy at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > > > I have read (if I re

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-14 Thread Arthur Ness (boston)
Patrick wrote <>><<>I was thinking this question of what lute music may have cost in past is somewhat accademic. If I am not mistaken, people could remember a lot more than they care to now. Not that we cannot, it is just that we do not have to. There was a program with James Burke (Connections

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-14 Thread Arthur Ness (boston)
Roman commented: >>> >> I once looked >> into the price of high quality paper in 16th century Augsburg, paper of the >> kind one would use to copy lute music. A ream of folio sized paper (about >> 9x12) in Augsburg cost the equivalent of a kitchen servant's monthly >> salary. Today a ream of hi

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-14 Thread Doctor Oakroot
Patrick H wrote: > > So, is it not possible that many musicians just watched someone play a > piece, and could then remember it? > Outside of overly academic classical (in the broad sense) music, that's almost exactly how we do it. Only difference is we listen to someone play it :o) -- Rough

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-13 Thread Roman Turovsky
>> I once looked >> into the price of high quality paper in 16th century Augsburg, paper of the >> kind one would use to copy lute music. A ream of folio sized paper (about >> 9x12) in Augsburg cost the equivalent of a kitchen servant's monthly >> salary. Today a ream of highest quality paper cou

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-13 Thread Howard Posner
Patrick H at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > So, is it not possible that many musicians just watched someone play a piece, > and could then remember it? Possible, but not likely. How much of a Dowland fantasy could you play back after seeing it once? Could you play it back reliably if your memory we

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-13 Thread Howard Posner
Arthur Ness writes: > I once looked > into the price of high quality paper in 16th century Augsburg, paper of the > kind one would use to copy lute music. A ream of folio sized paper (about > 9x12) in Augsburg cost the equivalent of a kitchen servant's monthly > salary. Today a ream of highest q

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-13 Thread Stewart McCoy
read, that it is tempting not to make the effort to memorise a piece of lute music. Best wishes, Stewart McCoy. - Original Message - From: "Patrick H" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Lute List" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Monday, October 13, 2003 7:14 PM Subject

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-13 Thread Stewart McCoy
Dear Arthur, Please could you tell us which manuscript you have in mind. Best wishes, Stewart McCoy. - Original Message - From: "Arthur Ness (boston)" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "LUTE NET" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Monday, October 13, 2003 6:18 PM Sub

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-13 Thread Donatella Galletti
boy or a cleaner ( woman) earned 6 soldi a day, an adult ( man) about 10-15 soldi a day according to the kind of job ( ="mestiere " -craft). I don't know about Rome, but according to this the cost of lute music described was equivalent to two days work of a craftsman. Before Gutemb

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-13 Thread archlute
>I think if one were to investigate the price of score in the 16th century, >you would find that their high price made them accessible only to wealthy >persons. Just wanted to echo Arthur's comment above. I was recently rereading Gustavson's dissertation on Formschneider (Nuremburg) and was supr

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-13 Thread Patrick H
I was thinking this question of what lute music may have cost in past is somewhat accademic. If I am not mistaken, people could remember a lot more than they care to now. Not that we cannot, it is just that we do not have to. There was a program with James Burke (Connections or one of those)

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-13 Thread Arthur Ness (boston)
I think if one were to investigate the price of score in the 16th century, you would find that their high price made them accessible only to wealthy persons. (And many professional lutenists were wealthy.) I once looked into the price of high quality paper in 16th century Augsburg, paper of the ki

Re: The cost of lute music/quattrini

2003-10-13 Thread Donatella Galletti
ot;), although it sounds a bit old fashioned. The reason is that being of copper the value of the coin was not high. Donatella http://spazioinwind.libero.it/donatella_galletti/index.htm - Original Message - From: "Howard Posner" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "lute net"

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-13 Thread Roman Turovsky
> Yes, I know of all of these places and they're wonderful. But, there is > nothing > quite like http://www.sourceforge.net which is a place to find free/shareware > software that is being written by groups all over the world. The current > approach in the lute community is analagous to the "lute b

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-13 Thread Chris Schaub
Yes, I know of all of these places and they're wonderful. But, there is nothing quite like http://www.sourceforge.net which is a place to find free/shareware software that is being written by groups all over the world. The current approach in the lute community is analagous to the "lute book" appro

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-12 Thread Howard Posner
Denys Stephens at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > "Costo en Roma 110 quatrines por Setiembre de 1512." > > I am neither a linguist nor a numismatist, but I guess this refers to > the cost of the book? Can anyone throw any light on what this means, > and if it is the cost, how it relates to the present

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-12 Thread Roman Turovsky
> Of course my homepage :-) I can offer space too, if needed. I am working on a page for Gabriel Schebor's collection of vihuela songs, we could house them together. RT Don't forget to join Lute-Ring. > just an offer! And I would contact Albert Reyermann of Tree editions > for a printed version.

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-12 Thread Roman Turovsky
> Of course my homepage :-) I can offer space too, if needed. I am working on a page for Gabriel Schebor's collection of vihuela songs, we could house them together. RT Don't forget to join Lute-Ring. > just an offer! And I would contact Albert Reyermann of Tree editions > for a printed version.

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-12 Thread arielabramovich
I'll add in a couple of months couple of vihuela songs in which I've been working. You can tell me what's the best place for them to be. Best, A

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-12 Thread Roman Turovsky
> At 13:28 12-10-2003 -0400, Roman Turovsky wrote: >>> I've wondered if it would be possible to make a shareware style > repository of >>> lute tab files such that they could be downloaded and used for free. A >>> donation >>> could be made to the compiler/editor/composer via a simple PayPal > inte

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-12 Thread Arne Keller
At 13:28 12-10-2003 -0400, Roman Turovsky wrote: >> I've wondered if it would be possible to make a shareware style repository of >> lute tab files such that they could be downloaded and used for free. A >> donation >> could be made to the compiler/editor/composer via a simple PayPal interface. >Th

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-12 Thread Matanya Ophee
At 11:52 AM 10/12/2003 +0100, Denys Stephens <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >"Costo en Roma 110 quatrines por Setiembre de 1512." > >I am neither a linguist nor a numismatist, but I guess this refers to >the cost of the book? Can anyone throw any light on what this means, >and if it is the cost, how i

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-12 Thread Roman Turovsky
> I've wondered if it would be possible to make a shareware style repository of > lute tab files such that they could be downloaded and used for free. A > donation > could be made to the compiler/editor/composer via a simple PayPal interface. There are places on the web that do just that: Alain Vey

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-12 Thread Dr. Gordon J. Callon
> I've wondered if it would be possible to make a shareware style > repository of lute tab files such that they could be downloaded and used > for free. Of course, there already is Wayne's very useful collection at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/tab-serv/tab-serv.cgi GJC

Re: The cost of lute music

2003-10-12 Thread Chris Schaub
Denys Stephens <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Dear All, > Recent mailings to the list have set me thinking about the cost of lute = > music. > In my experience it's always been expensive - my copy of Diana Poulton's > Dowland edition cost the equivalent of my two weeks wa

The cost of lute music

2003-10-12 Thread Denys Stephens
Dear All, Recent mailings to the list have set me thinking about the cost of lute = music. In my experience it's always been expensive - my copy of Diana Poulton's Dowland edition cost the equivalent of my two weeks wages when it was published. I didn't resent it at the time - it wa