Re: upgrade to osx 10.15 catalina

2020-01-12 Thread Ryan Schmidt
> On 09/01/2020 1:50 pm, joerg van den hoff wrote:
>> I had to upgrade to 10.15 (wanted to postpone this further but ...) and 
>> recall that there were many reports over the last months of problems with 
>> subsequent macports upgrade, recommendations to use previous xcode releases 
>> with catalina and assorted package specific problems simply not being 
>> solvable right now.
>> I have looked at the mail archive and macports webpage but have not found a 
>> clear recommendation or statement what the current situation (as of jan 
>> 2020) is.
>> so simple question: is it save/recommended to use current xcode (11.3) when 
>> doing the usual macports migration routine? are there guaranteed problems in 
>> certain packages/areas? or is everything back
>> to normal (most things will work, some might not...)?

There were some new features introduced in Xcode 11 which caused some problems 
for some ports. I believe most of these are resolved in Xcode 11.3 so you 
should use the latest version of Xcode 11 with Catalina. You cannot use Xcode 
versions earlier than 11 with Catalina.


On Jan 9, 2020, at 07:59, Chris Jones wrote:
> 
> At the end of the day though only you know which ports you really care about, 
> and cannot live without, so you need to do your homework yourself. Identified 
> those ports and then check their status at
> 
> https://ports.macports.org/

Note that the big green or red status boxes you see there do not necessarily 
correspond to the currently-available version of the port; see 
https://github.com/macports/macports-webapp/issues/135



Re: upgrade to osx 10.15 catalina

2020-01-09 Thread Chris Jones

Hi,

I would say the situation with 10.15 is now similar to other OSes. Some 
things work, some things do not. There are also some clear cases of 
things not working, and cannot/willnot be fixed, such as 32 bit support.


At the end of the day though only you know which ports you really care 
about, and cannot live without, so you need to do your homework 
yourself. Identified those ports and then check their status at


https://ports.macports.org/

Finally, as with any major OS update, I strongly recommend making a full 
bootable clone of your current system, before doing anything. Then, if 
worst comes to work, reverting back is trivial. I recommend this for any 
OS update, not at all specific to MacPorts...


Chris

On 09/01/2020 1:50 pm, joerg van den hoff wrote:
I had to upgrade to 10.15 (wanted to postpone this further but ...) and 
recall that there were many reports over the last months of problems 
with subsequent macports upgrade, recommendations to use previous xcode 
releases with catalina and assorted package specific problems simply not 
being solvable right now.


I have looked at the mail archive and macports webpage but have not 
found a clear recommendation or statement what the current situation (as 
of jan 2020) is.


so simple question: is it save/recommended to use current xcode (11.3) 
when doing the usual macports migration routine? are there guaranteed 
problems in certain packages/areas? or is everything back

to normal (most things will work, some might not...)?

thank you


upgrade to osx 10.15 catalina

2020-01-09 Thread joerg van den hoff
I had to upgrade to 10.15 (wanted to postpone this further but ...) and recall that there were many 
reports over the last months of problems with subsequent macports upgrade, recommendations to use 
previous xcode releases with catalina and assorted package specific problems simply not being 
solvable right now.


I have looked at the mail archive and macports webpage but have not found a clear recommendation or 
statement what the current situation (as of jan 2020) is.


so simple question: is it save/recommended to use current xcode (11.3) when doing the usual macports 
migration routine? are there guaranteed problems in certain packages/areas? or is everything back

to normal (most things will work, some might not...)?

thank you