Re: VIRGIL: Aeenid Trans Recommendation

1998-06-17 Thread Scott Pierce
I forgot to add that, mandelbaum's Aeneid struck me so vividly 20 yrs. ago, that I re-read it again before I read his California Dante. Currently, I can't get enough of his Odyssey of Homer. Don't know if he has an Iliad, but hope one is planned. Fitzgerald hasn't done anything for me, nor as I

Re: VIRGIL: Mystery

1998-06-17 Thread JaneGC
In a message dated 98-06-16 22:08:02 EDT, you write: Received the Statius lines from the Thebaid, Book 2, did anyone furnish Jane with an english translation? luv, bodywhomp98 I can translate it. I just didn't know where it came from. Thanks, Jane Is it a good read (in any language)?

Re: VIRGIL: Aeenid Trans Recommendation

1998-06-17 Thread WRHare
Used to be? Apparently you've never studied or taught in the Southeastern United States. lol --- To leave the Mantovano mailing list at any time, do NOT hit reply. Instead, send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with the message

VIRGIL: Re: translations of the Thebaid of Statius

1998-06-17 Thread Peter Bryant
Scott Pierce wrote: I loved receiving Statius, in Latin no less! When I tried to special order the Thebaid from a bookstore a yr. or so ago, I got a WHO? And it's Statius, not STASHIUS. Dear Scott, I know of

VIRGIL: Virgil's Underworld

1998-06-17 Thread Richard A. Schwartz
Did Virgil's notion of an Underworld that contained a Hell-like section originate with him, or was it already an accepted or current notion in Roman society? --- To leave the Mantovano mailing list at any time, do NOT hit reply.

Re: VIRGIL: Re: translations of the Thebaid of Statius

1998-06-17 Thread Scott Pierce
Thank you, Peter Bryant for the excellent advice and the citations. Although I do already own the Loeb edition of Statius, I enjoyed your insight and recommendations. Will rush out and pick up Melville's splendid translation. Enjoyed your including excerpts of each work. Yours etc.,

Re: Thebaid (was: VIRGIL: Mystery)

1998-06-17 Thread Leofranc Holford-Strevens
In message [EMAIL PROTECTED], John Geyssen [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Is it a good read (in any language)? The Thebaid is a great read. But, like everything else, it suffers in translation, although Melville's is good (there's a review of it in BMCR). The main problem