Re: [Marxism] District 9

2009-08-18 Thread Bhaskar Sunkara
The Bourne Supremacy drove me insane with it, but it didn't too bother me during District 9. On Tue, Aug 18, 2009 at 3:02 PM, Louis Proyect l...@panix.com wrote: gregoryabut...@aol.com wrote: Apparently, I saw a different District 9 than Prarie Miller and Armond White did! After seeing

[Marxism] District 9

2009-08-18 Thread David McDonald
Behold, you anti-shaky camera fucks, and weep: http://www.strimoo.com/video/15601236/Chimes-at-Midnight-1965-by-Orson-Welles-Veoh.html YOU MUST clip all extraneous text when replying to a message. Send list submissions to:

Re: [Marxism] District 9

2009-08-18 Thread Les Schaffer
David McDonald wrote: Behold, you anti-shaky camera fucks, and weep: http://www.strimoo.com/video/15601236/Chimes-at-Midnight-1965-by-Orson-Welles-Veoh.html big deal, so Orson Welles watched Eisenstein's Alexander Nevsky one day and decided to try a battle scene himself (a guess)...

Re: [Marxism] District 9

2009-08-18 Thread Mark Lause
Personally, I'm afraid I'll never see another medieval battle scene without waiting to see Peter Cook as Richard III wandering around like he did in Black Adder. ML YOU MUST clip all extraneous text when replying to a message. Send list

[Marxism] District 9

2009-08-17 Thread Louis Proyect
I have not seen this movie yet, but two of my colleagues in NYFCO did not care for it very much. Prairie Miller, a hard-core leftist like me, wrote: Relentlessly clunky and grating in the extreme, District 9 takes its cue from Cloverfield's contrived artsy vertigo to situate the futuristic

Re: [Marxism] District 9

2009-08-17 Thread Les Schaffer
Louis Proyect wrote: I have not seen this movie yet, but two of my colleagues in NYFCO did not care for it very much. went to see it yesterday, it's the first movie i have walked out on since i walked out on Cujo in 1983. District 9 is a very very evocative film ... see it if you want

Re: [Marxism] District 9

2009-08-17 Thread Les Schaffer
Louis Proyect wrote: full: http://newsblaze.com/story/20090807123235mill.nb/topstory.html Meanwhile, Armond White, an African-American reviewer who does not suffer foolish movies lightly, wrote wow, great review there were several deeply disturbing scenes in the first half of the

Re: [Marxism] District 9

2009-08-17 Thread Bhaskar Sunkara
As an allegory to apartheid the film for me was a complete failure.But compared to other mainstream films, it was a rather entertaining sci-fi movie. Les-- that was an unusual point to walk out on a film. I didn't see the overt Nazi comparison, but even if I did I still don't quite understand

Re: [Marxism] District 9

2009-08-17 Thread nada
I saw the whole movie. I have mixed feelings about it. I agree with the comment that the person who wrote/produced this was immature politically. The very obvious comparison with Apartheid was the main comparison, combined with a sort of faux-Nazi approach as a Final Solution to the Alien

Re: [Marxism] District 9

2009-08-17 Thread Adrian Bankhead
: [Marxism] District 9 To: Adrian Bankhead invisibleman...@yahoo.com Date: Monday, 17 August, 2009, 9:08 AM I have not seen this movie yet, but two of my colleagues in NYFCO did not care for it very much. Prairie Miller, a hard-core leftist like me, wrote: Relentlessly clunky and grating

Re: [Marxism] District 9

2009-08-17 Thread Les Schaffer
Adrian Bankhead wrote: Despite their bizarre appearance, the prawns are immediately anthomorphized, so we are made to feel pity for C.J. - the child prawn, and we come to identify with the wise and smart Christopher. We feel no such pity for the Nigerians all well said, i am glad someone

Re: [Marxism] District 9

2009-08-17 Thread gregoryabutler
] District 9 To: Activists and scholars in Marxist tradition marxism@lists.econ.utah.edu Message-ID: 4a898083.2050...@panix.com Content-Type: text/plain; charset=windows-1252; format=flowed I have not seen this movie yet, but two of my colleagues in NYFCO did not care for it very much. Prairie Miller