Rosa sent me the following response:
I am sorry to say that but I guess she does not know what dialectic is
about.
In which case, I'm in good company, since no one knows what it
'is about' -- or if they do, they have kept that secret well hidden for
200 years.
Thanks
Rosa!
In response to this:
http://www.marxmail.org/msg66028.html
It is worth adding that Donald Davidson was a socialist, too, as were
Gilbert Ryle and John Austin. Wittgenstein himself declared he was a
'communist at heart', wanted to move to Russia (since he was in agreement
with the gains made
Jim,
do you think it is worth to think about this:
If anything, it's dialecticians who are the conservatives, since they are
quite happy to ape the dogmatic and a priori thought-forms of traditional
philosophy.
I am sorry to say tha but I guess she does not know what dialectic is about.
---
On Fri, 14 Aug 2009 03:45:17 +0300 Dogan Gocmen dgn.g...@googlemail.com
writes:
Jim,
do you think it is worth to think about this:
If anything, it's dialecticians who are the conservatives, since
they are
quite happy to ape the dogmatic and a priori thought-forms of
traditional
On Aug 13, 2009, at 8:27 PM, Jim Farmelant wrote:
In response to this:
http://www.marxmail.org/msg66028.html
It is worth adding that Donald Davidson was a socialist, too, as were
Gilbert Ryle and John Austin.
So were Pigou and Marshall. J.S. Mill and F. von Menger were
communists.
