[Marxism] On who won WWII?

2009-08-05 Thread nada
Nestor made a comment in passing on the Totalitarian thread (which seemed to calm down and drain away the Rivers of Blood discussion on Trotsky vs Stalin) about how WWII was won in Stalingrad and Kursk and not at Normandy etc. [It's funny because this is not the Soviet view. In fact, it's only

Re: [Marxism] On who won WWII?

2009-08-05 Thread Nestor Gorojovsky
nada escribió: Nestor made a comment in passing on the Totalitarian thread (which seemed to calm down and drain away the Rivers of Blood discussion on Trotsky vs Stalin) about how WWII was won in Stalingrad and Kursk and not at Normandy etc. [It's funny because this is not the Soviet

Re: [Marxism] On who won WWII?

2009-08-05 Thread Shane Mage
On Aug 5, 2009, at 7:44 PM, Nestor Gorojovsky wrote: nada escribió: Nestor made a comment in passing on the Totalitarian thread (which seemed to calm down and drain away the Rivers of Blood discussion on Trotsky vs Stalin) about how WWII was won in Stalingrad and Kursk and not at

Re: [Marxism] On who won WWII?

2009-08-05 Thread nada
Shane Mage: Though the war was not won in Stalingrad and Kursk, it was won (or, for the Wehrmacht, lost) in the sense of *decided* at Stalingrad and Kursk. Point taken. Probably more so that any *other* point. I actually think that the Stalingrad battle was decided before hand, by the Germans