Re: [Marxism] The Victim's Words: Samantha Geimer

2009-10-03 Thread Tom Cod
...@yahoo.com Subject: Re: [Marxism] The Victim's Words: Samantha Geimer To: t...@hotmail.com I am stunned that someone on this list would defend the rape Have I defended a rape? I have given the right of the victim of the crime to speak. You apparently disagree with her conclusions to have her

Re: [Marxism] The Victim's Words: Samantha Geimer

2009-10-03 Thread Adam Richmond
Much of this discussion...if you can call it that.. has focused on the specific individuals in the case.   The difference here is that the victim is discussing the case decades after the incident.  She puts into a perspective no one else can.  The domestic violence victims often are

Re: [Marxism] The Victim's Words: Samantha Geimer

2009-09-30 Thread Pat Costello
I am stunned that someone on this list would defend the rape of a child (or any woman) simply because the rapist is an elite movie director who has suffered some tragic events. The victim does not get to decide that rape is something that we can just let slide. At no age is rape acceptable. If

Re: [Marxism] The Victim's Words: Samantha Geimer

2009-09-30 Thread Ian Pace
From: Pat Costello pt_coste...@yahoo.com I am stunned that someone on this list would defend the rape of a child (or any woman) simply because the rapist is an elite movie director who has suffered some tragic events. I don't know who is doing that. Solidarity, Ian

Re: [Marxism] The Victim's Words: Samantha Geimer

2009-09-30 Thread Adam Richmond
I am stunned that someone on this list would defend the rape Have I defended a rape?  I have given the right of the victim of the crime to speak.  You apparently disagree with her conclusions to have her own say in the matter for the greater good of the bourgeois courts. The judge proved