Re: M-TH: Re: Meszaros article: Communism Is No Utopia

1999-12-10 Thread Charles Brown
But Engels upheld the main thesis. Only some programmatic particulars were out of date, not the main thesis of historical materialism, dictatorship of the proletariat, struggle up to and including barricades and revolutionary war. CB "The World Socialist movement (via The Socialist Party of

Re: M-TH: Re: Meszaros article: Communism Is No Utopia

1999-12-02 Thread Charles Brown
"The World Socialist movement (via The Socialist Party of Great Marx disavowed this 1848 solution a couple of decades later: already he considered the barricade/ dictatorship of the proletariat route to be past its sell by date in europe. ((( Charles: What is your evidence of this

Re: M-TH: Re: Meszaros article: Communism Is No Utopia

1999-11-26 Thread Hugh Rodwell
Dear Rob, Where I am with Simon is the sensibility that we're not at the planning stage until lots'n'lots of people are engaged. And then they'll be part of the planning, too, eh? I've never worn that 'saviours waving the programme at the masses' stuff. Don't reckon it gets you to

M-TH: Re: Meszaros article: Communism Is No Utopia

1999-11-25 Thread Rob Schaap
I enjoyed and appreciated the Meszaros article very much (as I seem to whenever he puts pen to paper). Thanks to Jim for the post. Writes John: It was not political control that was at the heart of Communism but the control of the means of poduction, short and simple. Communism is effectively