Re: M-TH: Re: dialectical materialism/activist materialism

1999-08-13 Thread J.WALKER, ILL
Why should we, as socialists or Marxists, adopt such a perspective? In what way does it contribute to the struggle for socialism? Lew Lew, The importance of dialectical materialism to the struggle for socialism is in my opinion twofold. First, people like Engles wanted to appeal to the

Re: M-TH: Re: dialectical materialism/activist materialism

1999-08-10 Thread Charles Brown
From Reason and Revolt: Marxism and Science by Alan Woods and Ted Grant online @ http://easyweb.easynet.co.uk/~zac/maindex.htm Marxism and Darwinism Darwins Gradualism No Progress? Marxism and Darwinism Darwin and Malthus Social Darwinism "It is sometimes said that the standpoint of

Re: M-TH: Re: dialectical materialism/activist materialism

1999-08-09 Thread Charles Brown
Comrade Harry, I would say that part of the answer to your question is that an overall scientific worldview among the masses of workers is necessary for working class and socialist consciousness. A scientific worldview cannot be instilled based on consideration of the history of human society

Re: M-TH: Re: dialectical materialism/activist materialism

1999-08-08 Thread Lew
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Harry Feldman [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes Evolutionary (punctuated equilibrium), geological and astronomical phenomena seem to me to unfold in a dialectical way and if we can understand such things dialectically, why should we hold back, whether or not the giants from

Re: M-TH: Re: dialectical materialism/activist materialism

1999-08-07 Thread Rob Schaap
G'day Chas, I reckon you sound like a good historical materialist in this post - especially here: "Marx says that the chief defect of all hitherto existing materialism, Feuerbach included, is that it is contemplative and not active. " here: "History is made by active classes" here:

Re: M-TH: Re: dialectical materialism/activist materialism

1999-08-07 Thread Harry Feldman
Comrades, I'm not too sure what this argument is about. In my view, it doesn't matter whether we call the kind of reasoning marxists apply in understanding what's going on around us and how to intervene most effectively is called 'dialectical materialism', 'materialist dialectics', 'historical

M-TH: Re: dialectical materialism/activist materialism

1999-08-06 Thread Charles Brown
Rob Schaap [EMAIL PROTECTED] 08/06/99 10:14AM G'day Thaxists, Look, I know we've been through all this before, but it is my conviction that politics is like a computer. You make an apparently small mistake with what you put in, and you get an absolute disaster coming out. To the diamat

M-TH: Re: dialectical materialism/activist materialism

1999-08-06 Thread Charles Brown
Just to follow up , the error of the claims that Engels and Lenin , etc. deviate from Marx's own method into "ideology" is the exact error that Marx criticizes in the Theses on Feuerbach. What is being termed "ideology" is actually the activist component , the "PRACTICAL-critical ACTIVITY"