[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Susan Fishman-Armstrong
A couple of conservation questions: Our laboratory director came to me last week. He is starting to digitize his old maps on DVDs. He ran across some information that said that the lifetime of DVDs is only 5 years. Is that true? If so, what is the estimated lifespan of the gold plated

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Ari Davidow
There is _no_ assured lifetime for optical media (DVD, CD). There are claims that archival quality media last for 100 years. There is also experiential evidence that this is not so. Optical media may fail catastrophically at any time (although the odds are that a given platter will last for many

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Ray Shah
HI Susan, Ari, et al, This may be a little out of date (2004), I seem to remember this issue being raised before: Journal of Research of the National Institute of Standards and Technology 517 [J. Res. Natl. Inst. Stand. Technol. 109, 517-524 (2004)] Stability Comparison of Recordable

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Jeffrey Evans
Susan, Yes, media can fail anytime so it is always a good idea to have two copies (preferably on two types of media.) Lifespan beyond 10 years is pointless anyway because you will most likely want to take advantage of bigger and speedier and cheaper storage devices. Don't sweat it, keep

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Gaby Torres
Dear Susan, The lifespan of polycarbonate discs, with silver/silver alloy data layer, and commercial dye (aka CDs, DVDs, etc). is on real practice, with much luck 17 -20 years. Oxidizing processes of silver and/or alloy and dye is very fast. It has been theoretical predicted that with proper and

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Barbara Stokes
Another interesting viewpoint. Barbara Stokes Curator of Archives and Collections Museum of South Texas History 121 E. McIntyre Edinburg, TX 78541 bstokes at mosthistory.org 956/383-6911 -Original Message- From: mcn-l-bounces at mcn.edu [mailto:mcn-l-boun...@mcn.edu] On Behalf Of Gaby

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Han, Yan
DVD/CDs are never good choices for preservation. See the following research In 2002, National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) directed a study of high density magnetic tapes life expectancy and revealed tapes can have a life expectancy of 100 years. (