[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Gaby Torres
Another vote for Ari and Paul. If you want to store digital files, go with RAID storage. Kodak has an interesting approach using "analog devices"!!! I might find the reference for you, if one of our colleagues does not come up with it earlier. Best, Gabriela Torres UDLAP On 2/12/07, Paul Marty wr

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Paul Marty
I would like to second Ari's point as well. There is almost no reason to use optical media for storage anymore. Go with the live RAID storage. If you cannot afford that, you can buy several external HDs for pennies a GB. The important point is to keep your data live. If you are storing your

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Jeffrey Evans
Susan, Yes, media can fail anytime so it is always a good idea to have two copies (preferably on two types of media.) Lifespan beyond 10 years is pointless anyway because you will most likely want to take advantage of bigger and speedier and cheaper storage devices. Don't sweat it, keep moving.

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Ray Shah
HI Susan, Ari, et al, This may be a little out of date (2004), I seem to remember this issue being raised before: Journal of Research of the National Institute of Standards and Technology 517 [J. Res. Natl. Inst. Stand. Technol. 109, 517-524 (2004)] Stability Comparison of Recordable Optical

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Ari Davidow
There is _no_ assured lifetime for optical media (DVD, CD). There are claims that "archival quality" media last for 100 years. There is also experiential evidence that this is not so. Optical media may fail catastrophically at any time (although the odds are that a given platter will last for many

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Han, Yan
mcn.edu [mailto:mcn-l-boun...@mcn.edu] On Behalf Of Paul Marty Sent: Monday, February 12, 2007 9:51 AM To: Museum Computer Network Listserv Subject: Re: [MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?) I would like to second Ari's point as well. There is almost no reason to use optical media for stora

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Barbara Stokes
Torres Sent: Monday, February 12, 2007 10:05 AM To: Museum Computer Network Listserv Subject: Re: [MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?) Dear Susan, The lifespan of polycarbonate discs, with silver/silver alloy data layer, and "commercial" dye (aka CDs, DVDs, etc). is "on real

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Gaby Torres
Dear Susan, The lifespan of polycarbonate discs, with silver/silver alloy data layer, and "commercial" dye (aka CDs, DVDs, etc). is "on real practice", with much luck 17 -20 years. Oxidizing processes of silver and/or alloy and dye is very fast. It has been theoretical predicted that with proper an

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Susan Fishman-Armstrong
A couple of conservation questions: Our laboratory director came to me last week. He is starting to digitize his old maps on DVDs. He ran across some information that said that the lifetime of DVDs is only 5 years. Is that true? If so, what is the estimated lifespan of the gold plated DVDs?

[MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?)

2007-02-12 Thread Robert Weiner
rk Listserv' Subject: [MCN-L] DVD's (5 year lifetime true?) A couple of conservation questions: Our laboratory director came to me last week. He is starting to digitize his old maps on DVDs. He ran across some information that said that the lifetime of DVDs is only 5 years. Is t