Remember "Don't be evil"?

------------------------------------------------------------------------

"By settling a lawsuit with book authors and publishers this week, 
Google <http://www.pcworld.com/tags/Google+Inc..html> is looking out for 
itself and has avoided fighting for and possibly establishing a positive 
legal precedent for copyright fair use on the Internet...

"As an academic and a fair use advocate, I was somewhat disappointed the 
case got settled. I had been hoping to see it as a test of the 
boundaries of fair use, as a chance for the court to describe more 
specifically the scope of fair use here," said Wendy Seltzer, a fellow 
at Harvard University's Berkman Center for Internet and Society 
<http://www.pcworld.com/tags/Berkman+Centre+for+Internet+%26+Society.html>...

"Google has quite effectively solidified with this settlement its 
position as a leading search company and effectively excluded lots of 
others from following in its footsteps. A court judgement in favor of 
fair use would have let anyone else go in and make similar fair uses," 
Seltzer said. "This settlement sets a pretty high fee on making those uses."

In other words, Google saw the opportunity to settle in these terms as a 
key move for its business strategy, one valuable enough to sacrifice a 
greater good for Internet companies everywhere.


http://www.pcworld.com/businesscenter/article/153085/in_google_book_settlement_business_trumps_ideals.html
  


Reply via email to