Re: [MBZ] Clunky ball joint 86 W201

2008-05-27 Thread Jim Cathey
None of the supplied sleeves will fit the top of the old ball joint to press it out the bottom of the control arm (this is assuming it's the same as the W124, you need to check). Any bit of pipe that will seat in the tool and fit inside the hole in the control arm will work, as you don't

Re: [MBZ] Clunky ball joint 86 W201

2008-04-29 Thread Peter Frederick
None of the supplied sleeves will fit the top of the old ball joint to press it out the bottom of the control arm (this is assuming it's the same as the W124, you need to check). Any bit of pipe that will seat in the tool and fit inside the hole in the control arm will work, as you don't care

Re: [MBZ] Clunky ball joint 86 W201

2008-04-29 Thread Hendrik Fay
The 86 201 does not have a McPherson strut, it uses a shock absorber strut next to the spring. How do I know this? Because I used an internal spring compressor to remove the springs yesterday and I will be using an internal spring compressor to re-install the springs today. Unfortunately the

Re: [MBZ] Clunky ball joint 86 W201

2008-04-28 Thread Rich Thomas
Does that car have a brake rod support? THe connector that goes from the firewall to the control arm? The ball joint in those on the 123 wear out and give that clunk. --R Hendrik Fay wrote: The dramas never stop, got the engine and box back in the car and after adjusting the control

Re: [MBZ] Clunky ball joint 86 W201

2008-04-28 Thread Jim Cathey
The only thing I could find was the ball joint had up down movement of about 5mm (the right one only has about 2mm) and I am thinking if that is bouncing it could cause a clunking noise. Anyone have any input? Is there supposed to be up/down movement? I don't think there is supposed to be any

Re: [MBZ] Clunky ball joint 86 W201

2008-04-28 Thread Peter Frederick
That's pretty much the repair limit. Not a terrible job, the tool from Harbor Freight will work if you make and adapter to push the old one out. Jack car and support with a jackstand under the control arm (this is absolutely necessary unless you want to remove the spring). Remove strut

Re: [MBZ] Clunky ball joint 86 W201

2008-04-28 Thread Hendrik Fay
I have a spring compressor tool, the rubber bushings still seem to be pretty good. More than likely I'll take the control arm out and take it to a shop to get the ball joint replaced. Hendrik Peter Frederick wrote: That's pretty much the repair limit. Not a terrible job, the tool from

Re: [MBZ] Clunky ball joint 86 W201

2008-04-28 Thread Rich Thomas
On the TD I took the knuckle to a shop, an old Benz mech (I think he was Italian, go figure) put the thing in a vise and put a ball peen hammer round end on the BJ, then took a BFH and beat on that thing like a rented mule until the BJ popped out. Steel on steel, a bit scary. But it came out

Re: [MBZ] Clunky ball joint 86 W201

2008-04-28 Thread Mitch Haley
Hendrik Fay wrote: I have a spring compressor tool, What kind of spring compressor tool? Mitch ___ http://www.okiebenz.com For new parts see official list sponsor: http://www.buymbparts.com/ For used parts email [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Unsubscribe or

Re: [MBZ] Clunky ball joint 86 W201

2008-04-28 Thread Hendrik Fay
Internal type, which is a copy of the Klann but mucho cheapero. Bought it off ebay in the states. The aftermarket manual I have for the 201 chassis shows them using an external set of spring compressors, guess that would work if they are heavy duty enough but the way I figure it, by the time I

Re: [MBZ] Clunky ball joint 86 W201

2008-04-28 Thread Peter Frederick
The W201/W124 ball joint is MUCH easier to replace, as it's in the control arm and not the steering knuckle. The ones on W126s are a real pain, although my brother's came out fairly easily and pressed in without major problems. Not easy, though. Peter

Re: [MBZ] Clunky ball joint 86 W201

2008-04-28 Thread Hendrik Fay
Yes the pressing in of the ball joint is a job for an experienced person, from what I understand if they go in crooked the only way to get them out is with a gas axe. Also you wanna be careful bashing things with a BFH, sometimes things end up bent or otherwise broken. Just about every decent

[MBZ] Clunky ball joint 86 W201

2008-04-27 Thread Hendrik Fay
The dramas never stop, got the engine and box back in the car and after adjusting the control pressure that seems all good. There was a scrapping noise after reinstalling the rear wheel carrier but that was a simple adjustment with a hammer on the dust shield. However there is still a clunking