[MBZ] Was California, now Auto Workers Retirement

2008-06-22 Thread Tom Hargrave
The American automotive industry is supporting an increasing retiree force with revenue from decreasing production. And this would be the case regardless of who is funding retiree health benefits. Toyota, Honda and the other imports who manufacture in this country would be facing the exact same

Re: [MBZ] Was California, now Auto Workers Retirement

2008-06-22 Thread Gary Hurst
i'm a little confused as to this logic. don't they take money out at any given point to be paying for future retirees? On Sun, Jun 22, 2008 at 12:03 PM, Tom Hargrave [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The American automotive industry is supporting an increasing retiree force with revenue from

Re: [MBZ] Was California, now Auto Workers Retirement

2008-06-22 Thread Tom Hargrave
22, 2008 11:48 AM To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] Was California, now Auto Workers Retirement i'm a little confused as to this logic. don't they take money out at any given point to be paying for future retirees? On Sun, Jun 22, 2008 at 12:03 PM, Tom Hargrave [EMAIL PROTECTED

Re: [MBZ] Was California, now Auto Workers Retirement and health costs

2008-06-22 Thread Bill R
But there is something else you need to consider with nationalized health care. Would you want the same organization that runs the most inefficient, uncaring collection agency in the world (the IRS) managing your health care plan At least the current health care systems are motivated to save

Re: [MBZ] Was California, now Auto Workers Retirement

2008-06-22 Thread Peter Frederick
They don't need a bailout, they need a national pension plan (like the one torpedoed by the Republicans in 1936) similar to Canada's or any European company. They work well, and none of them are in the kind of trouble Social Security is. A universal system keeps older companies from being

Re: [MBZ] Was California, now Auto Workers Retirement

2008-06-22 Thread Peter Frederick
Well, they've been spending that money on other things -- all the major retirement plans are way behind in set-asides, and most companies have been cooking the books to make their obligations look smaller. Keeps the industrial stockholders happy, I suppose. Doesn't do much for anyone

Re: [MBZ] Was California, now Auto Workers Retirement and health costs

2008-06-22 Thread Peter Frederick
Someone is always driving -- the matter under consideration is WHO is in charge of allocating resources. Currently it is the people who profit the most (insurance companies and hospitals), not the public. Canada's system works pretty well, although it's not a national system and some

Re: [MBZ] Was California, now Auto Workers Retirement and health costs

2008-06-22 Thread Jim Cathey
I don't think anyone wants the federal government to be running the system - especially not modeled after the IRS. I believe a 'single payer' system is what is proposed by most, and we spend [or did back when I knew about such things] about the same amount to figure out who is going to

Re: [MBZ] Was California, now Auto Workers Retirement and health costs

2008-06-22 Thread Bill R
professionals?? BillR -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Jim Cathey Sent: Sunday, June 22, 2008 4:28 PM To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] Was California, now Auto Workers Retirement and health costs I don't think anyone wants

Re: [MBZ] Was California, now Auto Workers Retirement

2008-06-22 Thread mlh
Chrysler made the right decision during their last negotiation rounds with the union. They gave the retiree plan to UAW along with a pile of cash and made the cost the responsibility of UAW. But now union membership will contribute more to the cost as the long term cost of health care

Re: [MBZ] Was California, now Auto Workers Retirement

2008-06-22 Thread Tom Hargrave
rather have? Thanks, Tom Hargrave www.kegkits.com 256-656-1924 -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Sunday, June 22, 2008 9:32 PM To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] Was California, now Auto Workers