Re: Mersenne: Poaching and related issues...

2003-01-26 Thread Richard Woods
Steinar H. Gunderson wrote: Early GIMPS and the other project (Slowinski/Cray) had no common agreement or method for avoiding duplication. Umm, I've not been in this project _that_ long, but at least a year or two before Primenet got integrated into the main client. At least at that time,

Re: Mersenne: Poaching and related issues...

2003-01-25 Thread Richard Woods
Nathan Russell wrote: Okay, to start with, GIMPS lost the very first prime we ever found to a member of another project who beat George to finding the exponent by a matter of hours. This is simply the way math and other fields of research work. Darwin's theory of evolution was very nearly

Re: Mersenne: Poaching and related issues...

2003-01-25 Thread Steinar H. Gunderson
On Sat, Jan 25, 2003 at 03:38:14AM -0500, Richard Woods wrote: The cases of conflict you cite had no such method for avoiding duplication/overlap. Early GIMPS and the other project (Slowinski/Cray) had no common agreement or method for avoiding duplication. Umm, I've not been in this project

Re: Mersenne: Poaching and related issues...

2003-01-25 Thread Shane Sanford
Increasing the difficulty for a poacher to _find_ a tempting target would mean other participants could be less concerned about making themselves into such a target, and just concentrate on doing the work they considered most suitable within the rules. If the rules you are referring to

Re: Mersenne: Poaching and related issues...

2003-01-25 Thread Eric Hahn
At 09:50 AM 1/25/03 -0600, Shane Sanford wrote: Increasing the difficulty for a poacher to _find_ a tempting target would mean other participants could be less concerned about making themselves into such a target, and just concentrate on doing the work they considered most suitable within the

Mersenne: Poaching and related issues...

2003-01-24 Thread Nathan Russell
Okay, to start with, GIMPS lost the very first prime we ever found to a member of another project who beat George to finding the exponent by a matter of hours. This is simply the way math and other fields of research work. Darwin's theory of evolution was very nearly duplicated by another