Re: [Metamath] Re: More proof shortenings from OpenAI's models

2020-07-10 Thread 'Stanislas Polu' via Metamath
Thank you so much for looking into this. -stan On Fri, Jul 10, 2020 at 9:25 PM 'Alexander van der Vekens' via Metamath < metamath@googlegroups.com> wrote: > Hi Stan, > with PR #1715, the proofs of the following theorems are replaced by the > proofs shortened by OpenAI for the following theorems

Re: [Metamath] Re: More proof shortenings from OpenAI's models

2020-07-10 Thread 'Alexander van der Vekens' via Metamath
Hi Stan, with PR #1715, the proofs of the following theorems are replaced by the proofs shortened by OpenAI for the following theorems (taken from test.shortening): - ndmima - relcoi1 - cmntrcld - dvtanlem - dvdsabsmod0 - elmod2 - xphe el2fzo was removed (see my previous

Re: [Metamath] Re: More proof shortenings from OpenAI's models

2020-07-07 Thread 'Stanislas Polu' via Metamath
Hi Norm, That's extremely helpful. We will look into enforcing discourage uses in the future, to shorten the loop between our models and set.mm. Thank you very much. -stan On Tue, Jul 7, 2020 at 5:46 PM Norman Megill wrote: > > This is nice work Stanislas, thank you. > > On Friday, July 3,

[Metamath] Re: More proof shortenings from OpenAI's models

2020-07-07 Thread Norman Megill
This is nice work Stanislas, thank you. On Friday, July 3, 2020 at 5:09:55 AM UTC-4, Stanislas Polu wrote: - `1re` uses more axioms but is much simpler (how do we feel about > that given the comment there?). > A problem with this particular proof is that it uses df-1, which has the tag "(New

Re: [Metamath] Re: More proof shortenings from OpenAI's models

2020-07-06 Thread 'Stanislas Polu' via Metamath
Hi Alexander, Thanks a lot for looking into this! The test.shortening/train.shortening is a quite arbitrary split (shortenings coming from the training set vs the test set we use), both are to be considered. Best, -stan On Mon, Jul 6, 2020 at 12:40 PM 'Alexander van der Vekens' via Metamath

[Metamath] Re: More proof shortenings from OpenAI's models

2020-07-06 Thread 'Alexander van der Vekens' via Metamath
Hi Stan, very interesing results. I had a look at the theorems I contributed in test.shortening: - ~reuan: Additional distinct variable condition! This shortening must not be performed. - ~elmod2: This shortening is great! It should be done in set.mm - ~el2fzo: To be investigated if