[meteorite-list] Re: Rubble pile asteroids

2002-09-26 Thread Robert Verish
Original Message [meteorite-list] Re: Rubble pile asteroids Herbert Raab [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: On the other hand, the real border between a L5 and a L4 or L6 might be more blurry than the descriptions in the textbooks suggest. There is an interesting paper

[meteorite-list] Re: Rubble pile asteroids

2002-09-26 Thread Herbert Raab
Robert Verish writes: that shock and weathering grades were problematic for pairing purposes but they had no problem with petrologic class (or metamorphic grade). In fact, they used a noble gas isotope study to prove that all the L6 specimens were indeed, paired to the same fall! Of

[meteorite-list] Re: Rubble pile asteroids

2002-09-26 Thread Robert Verish
--- Herbert Raab lt;[EMAIL PROTECTED]gt; wrote: gt; gt; I still think that there might be fuzzy borders gt; between gt; metamorphic grades, or that a small thin section is gt; not representative for the whole specimen. gt; Once again, Herbert has hit the nail square on the head. It is a lot

[meteorite-list] Re: Rubble pile asteroids

2002-09-25 Thread Herbert Raab
Bob Verish writes: I have described it as being a loose rubble pile of L6, L5, and L4 meteoroids; held together by the most minimum of gravitational attraction. How else can you explain a strewn field of stony meteorites with such a variation in metamorphic grade, yet NO EVIDENCE of

Re: [meteorite-list] Re: Rubble pile asteroids

2002-09-25 Thread Maurizio Eltri
If possible, I would be pleased to get your opinions about my hypothesis concerning the possible structure of some asteroids. My idea is following : I formulated this hypothesis after observing a fireball which occurred during the 12th of August, 1998, during the maximum activity of perseids:

[meteorite-list] Re: Rubble pile asteroids

2002-09-25 Thread Robert Verish
- Original Message -- [meteorite-list] Re: Rubble pile asteroids Herbert Raab [EMAIL PROTECTED] mailto:herbert.raab%40utanet.at Wed, 25 Sep 2002 15:37:06 +0200 Bob Verish writes: I have described it as being a loose rubble pile of L6, L5, and L4 meteoroids; held