Re: [meteorite-list] Re:Comet hit Britain in mid sixth, century, AD?

2006-07-23 Thread Sterling K. Webb
Sent: Saturday, July 22, 2006 5:54 AM Subject: [meteorite-list] Re:Comet hit Britain in mid sixth, century, AD? Sterling K. Webb wrote: The scientist you're referring to is Michael Baillie, an Irish dentrochronologist (not Bailey). Too many Bailey'/Baillie's around, sorry... And its

Re: [meteorite-list] Re:Comet hit Britain in mid sixth century, AD?

2006-07-23 Thread E.P. Grondine
: [meteorite-list] Re:Comet hit Britain in mid sixth century, AD? Baileys comet impact hypothesis is quite contested, it certainly is not an accepted main stream hypothesis. So I quite surprised by the tone of that newspaper clipping that suggested so. The astrophysicist supporting

[meteorite-list] Re:Comet hit Britain in mid sixth, century, AD?

2006-07-22 Thread Marco Langbroek
Sterling K. Webb wrote: The scientist you're referring to is Michael Baillie, an Irish dentrochronologist (not Bailey). Too many Bailey'/Baillie's around, sorry... And its dendrochronologist, not dentrochronologist. Their suggestion arose from uncovering a 19th century account of

Re: [meteorite-list] Re:Comet hit Britain in mid sixth, century, AD?

2006-07-22 Thread Darren Garrison
On Sat, 22 Jul 2006 12:54:04 +0200, you wrote: Large impact phenomena come with a suit of identifiable things. If there was such an event in Britain as recent as AD 540, then where are the ejecta layers, the dust layers, the spherule layers, the impact glasses, the shocked quartz, the impact

RE: [meteorite-list] Re:Comet hit Britain in mid sixth, century, AD?

2006-07-22 Thread tracy latimer
If you're talking about catastrophic events during the Dark Ages, wasn't there an episode where major outgassing from volcanoes (fluorine and other nasty volcanic gases) in Iceland poisoned most of the viable cropland there, and the effects were felt up to several hundred miles away? I vaguely

[meteorite-list] Re:Comet hit Britain in mid sixth century AD?

2006-07-21 Thread Dave Harris
Hi, .Just as follow-up to Paul's email re the 6th C. possible meteorite, can I just give you a couple of quotes from The Anglo-Saxon chronicles, which were contemporary notes compiled over a period starting about 800ad to 1100ad by the monastic population here in the UK. First thing that becomes

[meteorite-list] Re:Comet hit Britain in mid sixth century, AD?

2006-07-21 Thread Marco Langbroek
538(ad): Here 14 days before 1 March the sun grew dark from early morning until 9am. (Winchester Mss, Cambridge, Corpus Christie MS173, ff 1(v)32(r)) 540: Here on 20 June the sun grew dark and stars appeared for well-nigh half a hour after 9am (Winchester Mss, Cambridge, Corpus Christie

Re: [meteorite-list] Re:Comet hit Britain in mid sixth century, AD?

2006-07-21 Thread Paul Barford
Baileys comet impact hypothesis is quite contested, it certainly is not an accepted main stream hypothesis. So I was quite surprised by the tone of that newspaper clipping that suggested so. The astrophysicist supporting it are, by the way, astrophysicists with a known fetish for impacts as a

Re: [meteorite-list] Re:Comet hit Britain in mid sixth century, AD?

2006-07-21 Thread Chris Peterson
- Original Message - From: Paul Barford [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: meteorite-list@meteoritecentral.com Sent: Friday, July 21, 2006 10:59 AM Subject: Re: [meteorite-list] Re:Comet hit Britain in mid sixth century, AD? Thanks Marco, In general, I think the theory is very dubious. The guy

Re: [meteorite-list] Re:Comet hit Britain in mid sixth century, AD?

2006-07-21 Thread Paul Barford
And not be recorded historically except in the most obscure and oblique fashion? And not leave any apparent geological or botanical effects? I'd say the parameters you are looking for would be supernatural. I think it pretty obvious that if something this size had landed on Ireland in 530 AD,