Re: Disambiguation [was RE: "uid" microformats? (was Re: [uf-discuss] ISBN mark-up)]

2006-04-29 Thread Scott Reynen
On Apr 29, 2006, at 5:32 PM, Benjamin Carlyle wrote: It is not clear to me at this time that microformats need profiles. hcard seems to have several profiles: http://microformats.org/wiki/hcard-profile http://www.w3.org/2006/03/hcard hcalendar seems to have none. Has this harmed adoption or made

Re: [uf-discuss] Microformats vs XML

2006-04-29 Thread Benjamin Carlyle
Phil, On Wed, 2006-04-26 at 17:35 -0700, Phil Haack wrote: > I am writing an article for an online development magazine on Microformats > and I'm looking for some good online discussions on the benefits of > Microformats over XML. > > So far I have: > Reduced Redundancy (ex. RSS) > Browser Suppor

Re: Disambiguation [was RE: "uid" microformats? (was Re: [uf-discuss] ISBN mark-up)]

2006-04-29 Thread Benjamin Carlyle
On Wed, 2006-04-26 at 11:53 -0700, Joe Andrieu wrote: > Tantek wrote: > >> Who is the registrar? > >Currently we have profile URLs at http://gmpg.org/ and http://w3.org/ > Scott wrote: > >> Alternatively, who is to say which version of hCoupon is valid? > >Mark Pilgrim. Rather, Mark is working o

Re: [uf-discuss] Citation Straw Proposal II

2006-04-29 Thread Bruce D'Arcus
On 4/29/06, Ross Singer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Author/Editor/Translator should be a priority. I realize this is more important in the computer vs. human continuum, but it doesn't seem /that/ difficult to make it an easy win for both camps. I agree. Books, for example, can have all three,

Re: [uf-discuss] Citation Straw Proposal II

2006-04-29 Thread Bruce D'Arcus
On 4/29/06, Brian Suda <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: - IsPartOf is another property that has been discussed which is not represented. Bringing this together with the "publication" and "journal" proprties: Are these relations, or simple properties (strings)? They need to be the former, and I thi

Re: [uf-discuss] Citation Straw Proposal II

2006-04-29 Thread Ross Singer
Brian, this is quite impressive. I particularly like the use of hCard in this context (although I think it's critical that we use more granular n attributes -- there are just too many ways to mark up a citation). Going into your "unresolved items" -- I see URL being pretty darned important. It'

[uf-discuss] Citation Straw Proposal II

2006-04-29 Thread Brian Suda
I have spent some time reviewing the examples and the formats on the wiki. Here is the list of the implied schemas. These are the common fields amongst the examples. I then looked at the cross over between the real-world examples and the formats and have created a straw proposal from that. At the

Re: [uf-discuss] nested hatom feeds?

2006-04-29 Thread David Janes -- BlogMatrix
Chris Casciano wrote: A somewhat silly, but practical question on hatom parsing rules and opaqueness... Can you nest hatom feeds... and if so will the inner feed be seen as a unique item or will it be hidden from parsers because its inside of the outer feed's content element? You can nest t