Re: [Mikrotik] have an ipsec issue (Mikrtotik to Netgear)

2016-10-16 Thread Muhammad Yousuf Khan
Thanks Guys for sharing your experience. actually in my case the other end had a firewall which denying my LAN traffic. although IPsec policy has to be smart enough to bypass the firewall rule however at the end i had to create manual routes in the firewall and things start to work again. Thanks f

Re: [Mikrotik] have an ipsec issue (Mikrtotik to Netgear)

2016-10-13 Thread Benoit Panizzon
Hi Muhammad I do consider the ipsec implementation on mikrotik to be broken. Most other firewalls do implement ipsec on interface level. So all traffic out that specific interface you define is being encrypted. Not so Mikrotik. There ipsec is defined on routing level. This works fine as long as

Re: [Mikrotik] have an ipsec issue (Mikrtotik to Netgear)

2016-10-12 Thread Terri Kelley
Not sure if this is what you are looking for but here’s what I had to do. NAT caused issues with ipsec so I had to not use it on the router with the tunnel. In the ip ipsec policy I had to create an action rule for each subnet on the lan, i.e. src-address=192.168.1.0/24 . That also applied for ea