Re: pf outbound nat load balancing issue

2008-10-20 Thread gm_sjo
It would appear not as I tried to sign up to the openbsd-pf list today and it failed. Just as pf is doing, failing. And now I am failing by talking to myself :-) 2008/10/18 gm_sjo [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Is there a more suitable mailing list for this kind of query? Thanks

Re: pf outbound nat load balancing issue

2008-10-18 Thread gm_sjo
Is there a more suitable mailing list for this kind of query? Thanks 2008/10/16 gm_sjo [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Forgot to mention, i'm running 4.3 release. 2008/10/16 gm_sjo [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Hi all, I have a very basic pf NAT setup for testing on my new firewall. The firewall has two PPPoE

pf outbound nat load balancing issue

2008-10-16 Thread gm_sjo
Hi all, I have a very basic pf NAT setup for testing on my new firewall. The firewall has two PPPoE connections which are using multipath default routes to load balance. Load balancing works for non-NAT traffic, but NAT traffic is only going out via one link, not both. I am wondering what the

Re: pf outbound nat load balancing issue

2008-10-16 Thread gm_sjo
Forgot to mention, i'm running 4.3 release. 2008/10/16 gm_sjo [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Hi all, I have a very basic pf NAT setup for testing on my new firewall. The firewall has two PPPoE connections which are using multipath default routes to load balance. Load balancing works for non-NAT traffic

Re: PPPoE(4) Two ADSL modems (identical LCP session issue)

2008-10-15 Thread gm_sjo
2008/10/15 Can Erkin Acar [EMAIL PROTECTED]: I have previously used two PPPoE links succesfully. The sys/net/if_pppoe.c:pppoe_find_softc_by_session() is correct as long as the devices are attached to different ethernet devices. Someone kindly wrote me this patch:- --- if_pppoe.c.orig

PPPoE(4) Two ADSL modems (identical LCP session issue)

2008-10-14 Thread gm_sjo
I am running 4.3 GENERIC.MP. I appear to have hit an issue whereby two adsl modems are presenting the same LCP session. I believe this is confusing pppoe(4). I am unable to reconfigure the session presented by the modem (which I believe likely to be the case on most devices). Scenario:- - Two

Re: dmesg IBM x3650 OpenBSD 4.3

2008-10-10 Thread gm_sjo
2008/10/10 Theo de Raadt [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Wow. Good luck. Can't you see we've been down that road before with those bastards? But really. Good luck. You really are too optimistic, but sure, learn the reality for yourself. I'm sure calling vendors 'bastards' on a public mailing list is

Re: dmesg IBM x3650 OpenBSD 4.3

2008-10-10 Thread gm_sjo
2008/10/10 Breen Ouellette [EMAIL PROTECTED]: When you have proven yourself even 10% as helpful to the cause of OpenBSD as Theo is, then maybe, just maybe, you are justified in criticizing his tactics. I look forward to that point in time, but until then I really have no reason to side with

Erratic NAT behaviour

2008-10-09 Thread gm_sjo
Hi all, I am testing my new OpenBSD router in a simple NAT configuration but I am getting some strange results. The client machine is a Windows XP laptop and the behaviour is that only a handful of websites render (google, for example), 99% that i've tried do not. FTP appears to be working fine.

Re: Erratic NAT behaviour

2008-10-09 Thread gm_sjo
Thanks all - reducing the MTU as above did fix the issue.

How to debug PPPOE(4)?

2008-10-06 Thread gm_sjo
Hi all, I'm in the process of setting up my new firewall. It's running OpenBSD 4.3 GENERIC. I have two PPPoA/PPPoE bridge modems attached to two NIC's (fxp0/1) and am struggling to get them connected to my ADSL. For now, I am just trying one (pppoe1) :- # cat /etc/hostname.pppoe1 inet 0.0.0.0

Re: How to debug PPPOE(4)?

2008-10-06 Thread gm_sjo
2008/10/6 Dominik Meister [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Try the 'debug' flag of ifconfig (8). AFAIR it logs to /var/log/messages. Thanks for that. Bizarrely it appeared to start working when I enabled debug, however I believe it is purely coincidence - most likely to do with me changing auth type from