Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-25 Thread Spruell, Darren-Perot
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Har, har. :-) However, I don't think it would be a big deal to write a script that could be run after installation that walked you through your network setup. And a mention of it in afterboot; 'If you want to set up a network connection run blahblah script before

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-23 Thread Siju George
On 6/22/06, Theo de Raadt [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: | Wich device should be used for pppoe? [fxp0] : | pppoe protocol? [bla]: I can add ppooe to the floppy, but to make it fit I am going to have to remove the fxp driver. OK? Maybe you could tar.gz them in the floppy to fit them together

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-23 Thread Joachim Schipper
On Fri, Jun 23, 2006 at 02:19:54PM +0530, Siju George wrote: On 6/22/06, Theo de Raadt [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: | Wich device should be used for pppoe? [fxp0] : | pppoe protocol? [bla]: I can add ppooe to the floppy, but to make it fit I am going to have to remove the fxp driver. OK?

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-23 Thread Eric Furman
On Fri, 23 Jun 2006 14:19:54 +0530, Siju George [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: On 6/22/06, Theo de Raadt [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: | Wich device should be used for pppoe? [fxp0] : | pppoe protocol? [bla]: I can add ppooe to the floppy, but to make it fit I am going to have to remove the fxp

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-22 Thread Michael Lechtermann
Chris Zakelj schrieb: Sounds great in theory, but as Theo gently reminded me when I asked this a year or two ago, there's only so much space on a single 1.44M floppy. Including even rudimentary PPPoE would crowd out other drivers and tools that are much more useful during an install. Why not

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-22 Thread Falk Husemann
On 22.06.2006, at 10:06, Michael Lechtermann wrote: Hi! I doubt anyone would be totally angry when he needs to hit ENTER one more time to skip that question. No doubt my name is anyone. I'd be angry. It's not about hitting Return one more time, it's integrating something new into the

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-22 Thread Michael Lechtermann
Falk Husemann wrote: No doubt my name is anyone. I'd be angry. It's not about hitting Return one more time, it's integrating something new into the Installation Floppy. And you REALLY don't want to drop Floppy Installation support or favor CDs. If you had actually read what I have written

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-22 Thread Guido Tschakert
Michael Lechtermann schrieb: Falk Husemann wrote: No doubt my name is anyone. I'd be angry. It's not about hitting Return one more time, it's integrating something new into the Installation Floppy. And you REALLY don't want to drop Floppy Installation support or favor CDs. If you had

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-22 Thread Michael Lechtermann
Guido Tschakert wrote: You surely do not want to say no to dozens of network questions (and maybe a lot of other stuff) Thats why I suggested to make just one question that asks if you would like to to any optional setup. Default answer [n]. If you choose yes, only then you'll get the additional

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-22 Thread Falk Husemann
On 22.06.2006, at 12:04, Michael Lechtermann wrote: Hi! You surely do not want to say no to dozens of network questions (and maybe a lot of other stuff) Thats why I suggested to make just one question that asks if you would like to to any optional setup. Default answer [n]. If you choose yes,

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-22 Thread Stuart Henderson
On 2006/06/22 12:04, Michael Lechtermann wrote: Guido Tschakert wrote: You surely do not want to say no to dozens of network questions (and maybe a lot of other stuff) Thats why I suggested to make just one question that asks if you would like to to any optional setup. Default answer [n].

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-22 Thread Chris Zakelj
Michael Lechtermann wrote: Guido Tschakert wrote: You surely do not want to say no to dozens of network questions (and maybe a lot of other stuff) Thats why I suggested to make just one question that asks if you would like to to any optional setup. Default answer [n]. If you choose

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-22 Thread Martin Schröder
2006/6/22, Michael Lechtermann [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Why not just make it a special feature for people who buy the CD? Go ahead. Roll your own version of OpenBSD with your special installer and sell the CDs. Best Martin

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-22 Thread Joachim Schipper
On Thu, Jun 22, 2006 at 06:36:04PM +0200, Martin Schr?der wrote: 2006/6/22, Michael Lechtermann [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Why not just make it a special feature for people who buy the CD? Go ahead. Roll your own version of OpenBSD with your special installer and sell the CDs. Or, rather, don't. It

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-22 Thread Peter Hessler
On Thu, 22 Jun 2006 12:04:25 +0200 Michael Lechtermann [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: : Guido Tschakert wrote: : You surely do not want to say no to dozens of network questions (and : maybe a lot of other stuff) : Thats why I suggested to make just one question that asks if you would : like to to any

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-22 Thread Michael Lechtermann
Since some people are so nice and started bitching around like they were some 12 year olds, I feel the need to set something straight here. Personally, I really don't care if there is an additional, optional, setup routine for anything since I don't need it, would probably never use it and will

Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-21 Thread sebastian . rother
Would it be possible that the installer asks if you may wanna use the NIC for pppoe-Connections and then maybe also asks for User/PW for the connection-settings? :) In my oppinion this little change may would maybe bring more usebillity (or how that`s written...) and it would save some time wich

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-21 Thread Marco Peereboom
I don't like this idea. I think it is the wrong assumption that most machines run PPPoE. The folks that use this can easily update the appropriate files after the initial install is complete. On Wed, Jun 21, 2006 at 07:45:45PM +0200, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Would it be possible that the

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-21 Thread sebastian . rother
I don't like this idea. I think it is the wrong assumption that most machines run PPPoE. The folks that use this can easily update the appropriate files after the initial install is complete. It`s the same assumption like asking the guy who installs OpenBSd if he wanna use dhcp. :-) I wont

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-21 Thread Marco Peereboom
On Wed, Jun 21, 2006 at 09:03:43PM +0200, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I don't like this idea. I think it is the wrong assumption that most machines run PPPoE. The folks that use this can easily update the appropriate files after the initial install is complete. It`s the same assumption

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-21 Thread Chris Zakelj
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Would it be possible that the installer asks if you may wanna use the NIC for pppoe-Connections and then maybe also asks for User/PW for the connection-settings? :) In my oppinion this little change may would maybe bring more usebillity (or how that`s written...) and

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-21 Thread sebastian . rother
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Would it be possible that the installer asks if you may wanna use the NIC for pppoe-Connections and then maybe also asks for User/PW for the connection-settings? :) In my oppinion this little change may would maybe bring more usebillity (or how that`s written...)

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-21 Thread sebastian . rother
On Wed, Jun 21, 2006 at 09:03:43PM +0200, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I don't like this idea. I think it is the wrong assumption that most machines run PPPoE. The folks that use this can easily update the appropriate files after the initial install is complete. It`s the same assumption

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-21 Thread Ted Unangst
On 6/21/06, [EMAIL PROTECTED] [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Like: Wich device should be used for pppoe? [fxp0] : pppoe protocol? [bla]: User ID for pppoe: foo Password for pppoe: bar PPPOE-Successfully configured and useable after reboot Just like: Start sshd? [Yes]: how many people run sshd?

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-21 Thread Paul de Weerd
On Thu, Jun 22, 2006 at 01:03:33AM +0200, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: | I did nto asked to add the pppoe-Code but to add a little mask into the | installer to create the hostname.pppoe. | | Like: | | Wich device should be used for pppoe? [fxp0] : | pppoe protocol? [bla]: | User ID for pppoe: foo |

Re: Configuring pppoe during installation?

2006-06-21 Thread Theo de Raadt
| Wich device should be used for pppoe? [fxp0] : | pppoe protocol? [bla]: I can add ppooe to the floppy, but to make it fit I am going to have to remove the fxp driver. OK?