Re: Multiple instances of OSPFD in different RDomains - rcctl behavior
Thanks Stuart. I did some more digging and found that salt itself was the culprit. In my formula, I had a state to write out /etc/rc.conf.local followed by a state to start the ospf2d service. I created the state for /etc/rc.conf.local, as a file.managed state, not understanding that the service.running state was responsible for the modification of /etc/rc.conf.local in the first place. The state that starts the ospf2d service uses the results of '/usr/sbin/rcctl getdef ospf2d flags' in order to set the flags, unless additional arguments are fed via **kwargs. Here is my resultant working state: enable_ospf2_service: service.running: - name: ospf2d - enable: True - kwarg: flags: '-f /etc/ospf2d.conf' This should be helpful for anyone else running Saltstack in an OpenBSD environment and needing to feed custom flags to a process in the future. On Wed, Feb 20, 2019 at 5:07 AM Stuart Henderson wrote: > > On 2019-02-19, Henry Bonath wrote: > > --- /var/backups/etc_rc.conf.local.current Wed Jan 16 01:30:06 2019 > > +++ /etc/rc.conf.local Fri Feb 15 13:05:17 2019 > > @@ -1,9 +1,7 @@ > > bgpd_flags= > > ldpd_flags= > > -ospf2d_flags=-f /etc/ospf2d.conf > > ospf2d_rtable=2 > > ospfd_flags= > > pf=NO > > pkg_scripts=salt_minion ospf2d > > salt_minion_rtable=3 > > > > Is my syntax incorrect? Would /etc/daily be doing something here to my > > configuration? > > > > Why would this line keep being automatically removed? > > It's unlikely to be /etc/daily at 13:05:17. Check system logs for around > that time, consider turning on process accounting to see if it gives any > clues? > >
Re: Multiple instances of OSPFD in different RDomains - rcctl behavior
On 2019-02-19, Henry Bonath wrote: > --- /var/backups/etc_rc.conf.local.current Wed Jan 16 01:30:06 2019 > +++ /etc/rc.conf.local Fri Feb 15 13:05:17 2019 > @@ -1,9 +1,7 @@ > bgpd_flags= > ldpd_flags= > -ospf2d_flags=-f /etc/ospf2d.conf > ospf2d_rtable=2 > ospfd_flags= > pf=NO > pkg_scripts=salt_minion ospf2d > salt_minion_rtable=3 > > Is my syntax incorrect? Would /etc/daily be doing something here to my > configuration? > > Why would this line keep being automatically removed? It's unlikely to be /etc/daily at 13:05:17. Check system logs for around that time, consider turning on process accounting to see if it gives any clues?
Re: Multiple instances of OSPFD in different RDomains - rcctl behavior
That was actually how I noticed it in the first place. I was running a highstate and it kept wanting to change my rc.conf.local and put the ospf2d_flags line back in. I do not run any salt states automatically, that would be an obvious workaround. I was just hoping to get some clarification as to my approach, and if I wasn’t doing something correctly in regards to working with multiple rdomains. This is on OpenBSD 6.4 btw... Thanks! -Henry > On Feb 19, 2019, at 9:47 PM, Scott Reese wrote: > > - Original Message - >> From: "Henry Bonath" >> To: "misc" >> Sent: Tuesday, February 19, 2019 2:03:31 PM >> Subject: Multiple instances of OSPFD in different RDomains - rcctl behavior > >> Hello, I am seeing some strange behavior with my /etc/rc.conf.local >> regarding my configuration for running two instances of OSPFD in >> different RDomains. >> >> The way I have this configured, is I have a symlink: /etc/rc.d/ospf2d >> -> /etc/rc.d/ospfd so that the ospfd that runs in rdomain 2 has its >> own entry in rc.conf.local, pointing to its own config file. >> >> In my /etc/rc.conf.local I have the following: >> # >> bgpd_flags= >> ldpd_flags= >> ospf2d_flags=-f /etc/ospf2d.conf >> ospf2d_rtable=2 >> ospfd_flags= >> pf=NO >> pkg_scripts=salt_minion ospf2d >> salt_minion_rtable=3 >> # >> >> However I notice that something is removing the "ospf2d_flags=..." >> line as output from daily insecurity mail: >> >> == >> /etc/rc.conf.local diffs (-OLD +NEW) >> == >> --- /var/backups/etc_rc.conf.local.current Wed Jan 16 01:30:06 2019 >> +++ /etc/rc.conf.local Fri Feb 15 13:05:17 2019 >> @@ -1,9 +1,7 @@ >> bgpd_flags= >> ldpd_flags= >> -ospf2d_flags=-f /etc/ospf2d.conf >> ospf2d_rtable=2 >> ospfd_flags= >> pf=NO >> pkg_scripts=salt_minion ospf2d >> salt_minion_rtable=3 >> >> Is my syntax incorrect? Would /etc/daily be doing something here to my >> configuration? >> Why would this line keep being automatically removed? >> >> Thanks in advance! > > Greetings Henry: > > Looks like you're running Saltstack. Any chance that your Salt master > has a copy of the rc.conf.local that doesn't have the ospf2d_flags line > and is resetting the file back to its "correct" values? > > -Scott >
Re: Multiple instances of OSPFD in different RDomains - rcctl behavior
- Original Message - > From: "Henry Bonath" > To: "misc" > Sent: Tuesday, February 19, 2019 2:03:31 PM > Subject: Multiple instances of OSPFD in different RDomains - rcctl behavior > Hello, I am seeing some strange behavior with my /etc/rc.conf.local > regarding my configuration for running two instances of OSPFD in > different RDomains. > > The way I have this configured, is I have a symlink: /etc/rc.d/ospf2d > -> /etc/rc.d/ospfd so that the ospfd that runs in rdomain 2 has its > own entry in rc.conf.local, pointing to its own config file. > > In my /etc/rc.conf.local I have the following: > # > bgpd_flags= > ldpd_flags= > ospf2d_flags=-f /etc/ospf2d.conf > ospf2d_rtable=2 > ospfd_flags= > pf=NO > pkg_scripts=salt_minion ospf2d > salt_minion_rtable=3 > # > > However I notice that something is removing the "ospf2d_flags=..." > line as output from daily insecurity mail: > > == > /etc/rc.conf.local diffs (-OLD +NEW) > == > --- /var/backups/etc_rc.conf.local.current Wed Jan 16 01:30:06 2019 > +++ /etc/rc.conf.local Fri Feb 15 13:05:17 2019 > @@ -1,9 +1,7 @@ > bgpd_flags= > ldpd_flags= > -ospf2d_flags=-f /etc/ospf2d.conf > ospf2d_rtable=2 > ospfd_flags= > pf=NO > pkg_scripts=salt_minion ospf2d > salt_minion_rtable=3 > > Is my syntax incorrect? Would /etc/daily be doing something here to my > configuration? > Why would this line keep being automatically removed? > > Thanks in advance! Greetings Henry: Looks like you're running Saltstack. Any chance that your Salt master has a copy of the rc.conf.local that doesn't have the ospf2d_flags line and is resetting the file back to its "correct" values? -Scott
Multiple instances of OSPFD in different RDomains - rcctl behavior
Hello, I am seeing some strange behavior with my /etc/rc.conf.local regarding my configuration for running two instances of OSPFD in different RDomains. The way I have this configured, is I have a symlink: /etc/rc.d/ospf2d -> /etc/rc.d/ospfd so that the ospfd that runs in rdomain 2 has its own entry in rc.conf.local, pointing to its own config file. In my /etc/rc.conf.local I have the following: # bgpd_flags= ldpd_flags= ospf2d_flags=-f /etc/ospf2d.conf ospf2d_rtable=2 ospfd_flags= pf=NO pkg_scripts=salt_minion ospf2d salt_minion_rtable=3 # However I notice that something is removing the "ospf2d_flags=..." line as output from daily insecurity mail: == /etc/rc.conf.local diffs (-OLD +NEW) == --- /var/backups/etc_rc.conf.local.current Wed Jan 16 01:30:06 2019 +++ /etc/rc.conf.local Fri Feb 15 13:05:17 2019 @@ -1,9 +1,7 @@ bgpd_flags= ldpd_flags= -ospf2d_flags=-f /etc/ospf2d.conf ospf2d_rtable=2 ospfd_flags= pf=NO pkg_scripts=salt_minion ospf2d salt_minion_rtable=3 Is my syntax incorrect? Would /etc/daily be doing something here to my configuration? Why would this line keep being automatically removed? Thanks in advance!
