Re: Sonos and OpenBSD PF - anyone on-list with experience ?

2019-11-23 Thread Rachel Roch
Thanks all for your ideas.  I'll spend a little time on it over the next few days and see how far I can get. 22 Nov 2019, 16:34 by s...@spacehopper.org: > On 2019-11-22, Peter N. M. Hansteen wrote: > >> On Fri, Nov 22, 2019 at 12:56:51PM +0100, Rachel Roch wrote: >> >> >>> They sent me

Re: Sonos and OpenBSD PF - anyone on-list with experience ?

2019-11-22 Thread Stuart Henderson
On 2019-11-22, Peter N. M. Hansteen wrote: > On Fri, Nov 22, 2019 at 12:56:51PM +0100, Rachel Roch wrote: > >> They sent me the following long email, it does mention inbound access but >> seems like a bit of a generic answer if all those ports really need to be >> opened inbound via PAT ? 

Re: Sonos and OpenBSD PF - anyone on-list with experience ?

2019-11-22 Thread Peter N. M. Hansteen
On Fri, Nov 22, 2019 at 12:56:51PM +0100, Rachel Roch wrote: > They sent me the following long email, it does mention inbound access but > seems like a bit of a generic answer if all those ports really need to be > opened inbound via PAT ?  I've asked Sonos to clarify exactly what is >

Re: Sonos and OpenBSD PF - anyone on-list with experience ?

2019-11-22 Thread Stuart Henderson
On 2019-11-22, Rachel Roch wrote: > Refuse to use Sonos myself, but am helping (or trying to) out a friend who > has a Sonos try to get things working wtih OpenBSD PF. > > I've simplified their PF rulese to a simple swiss cheese (i.e. stateful NAT'd > allow any out to any). What exactly are

Re: Sonos and OpenBSD PF - anyone on-list with experience ?

2019-11-22 Thread Rachel Roch
Hi Tom, They sent me the following long email, it does mention inbound access but seems like a bit of a generic answer if all those ports really need to be opened inbound via PAT ?  I've asked Sonos to clarify exactly what is required inbound (as opposed to stateful outbound), and am still

Re: Sonos and OpenBSD PF - anyone on-list with experience ?

2019-11-22 Thread Peter N. M. Hansteen
On Fri, Nov 22, 2019 at 12:16:49PM +0100, Rachel Roch wrote: > Refuse to use Sonos myself, but am helping (or trying to) out a friend who > has a Sonos try to get things working wtih OpenBSD PF. > > I've simplified their PF rulese to a simple swiss cheese (i.e. stateful NAT'd > allow any out

Re: Sonos and OpenBSD PF - anyone on-list with experience ?

2019-11-22 Thread Tom Smyth
Hi Rachel, I does Sonos Require uPnP support ? (does Sonos require a few ports to be forwarded from your internet interface back into the Sonos device on the LAN) is there a manual port forwarding that you can do to get around the uPNP requirement ? On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 at 11:26, Rachel

Sonos and OpenBSD PF - anyone on-list with experience ?

2019-11-22 Thread Rachel Roch
Hi, Refuse to use Sonos myself, but am helping (or trying to) out a friend who has a Sonos try to get things working wtih OpenBSD PF. I've simplified their PF rulese to a simple swiss cheese (i.e. stateful NAT'd allow any out to any). Everything else they care to run on their network is