Re: Trouble ftp'ing out of network, already running ftpproxy for internal ftp server, need to ftp out

2007-11-09 Thread knitti
On 11/9/07, Jake Conk [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: My question though is why did you give this rdr rule? rdr pass on $int_if proto tcp from any to !$ftp_server port ftp - 127.0.0.1 port 8022 What special feature does switching any to !$ftp_server add to the pf rules? Should I modify mine to

Re: Trouble ftp'ing out of network, already running ftpproxy for internal ftp server, need to ftp out

2007-11-08 Thread Richard Toohey
I've been having great fun with FTP - active and passive - and assumed it was the wrong port here or there or something strange in pf - my fault every time so far. Running with pf + ftp-proxy box, and proftpd or vsftpd on boxes behind that on two different networks, and then NAT clients on

Re: Trouble ftp'ing out of network, already running ftpproxy for internal ftp server, need to ftp out

2007-11-08 Thread knitti
On 11/8/07, Jake Conk [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hello, I have a computer running OpenBSD 4.2 which is acting as my router. Behind it I have a a ftp-server which is working fine thanks to ftp-proxy but one of the problems I am having is ftp'ing out of my network. I am able to connect and

Re: Trouble ftp'ing out of network, already running ftpproxy for internal ftp server, need to ftp out

2007-11-08 Thread knitti
On 11/8/07, Jake Conk [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Ok I understand I'm supposed to have another instance of ftp-proxy running so that it can open up ports on my router to allow data connections to be established from remote hosts but I'm not sure how I should configured ftp-proxy for that and my

Re: Trouble ftp'ing out of network, already running ftpproxy for internal ftp server, need to ftp out

2007-11-08 Thread Jake Conk
Ok I understand I'm supposed to have another instance of ftp-proxy running so that it can open up ports on my router to allow data connections to be established from remote hosts but I'm not sure how I should configured ftp-proxy for that and my pf... Lets start with ftp-proxy first then handle

Re: Trouble ftp'ing out of network, already running ftpproxy for internal ftp server, need to ftp out

2007-11-08 Thread Jake Conk
Knitti, Thanks, I created another instance of ftp-proxy with these options: -p 8021 127.0.0.1 ...and put in my rdr this rule: rdr on $int_if proto tcp from any to any port ftp - 127.0.0.1 port 8021 Everything seems to work now, I can ftp out and people can ftp in :) My question though is why

Trouble ftp'ing out of network, already running ftpproxy for internal ftp server, need to ftp out

2007-11-07 Thread Jake Conk
Hello, I have a computer running OpenBSD 4.2 which is acting as my router. Behind it I have a a ftp-server which is working fine thanks to ftp-proxy but one of the problems I am having is ftp'ing out of my network. I am able to connect and establish connections to outside servers but I am not