Re: can't ping CARP interfaces

2015-04-08 Thread Martin Pieuchot
On 07/04/15(Tue) 15:42, David Newman wrote: On 3/30/15 12:54 PM, Martin Pieuchot wrote: [...] Not OK for the carp interfaces. On the production machines I'm replicating here as VMs, it looks like the carp interfaces are bound to themselves -- note that the last column is carp21: #

Re: can't ping CARP interfaces -- SOLVED (VMware issue)

2015-04-08 Thread David Newman
On 4/8/15 2:42 AM, Martin Pieuchot wrote: On 07/04/15(Tue) 15:42, David Newman wrote: On 3/30/15 12:54 PM, Martin Pieuchot wrote: [...] Not OK for the carp interfaces. On the production machines I'm replicating here as VMs, it looks like the carp interfaces are bound to themselves -- note

Re: can't ping CARP interfaces

2015-04-07 Thread David Newman
On 3/30/15 12:54 PM, Martin Pieuchot wrote: On 30/03/15(Mon) 11:58, David Newman wrote: On 3/29/15 12:38 PM, mxb wrote: Probably your PF rules. put in ‘pass quick proto icmp’. No joy. This did not improve on the existing ICMP rule in pf.conf. I think the root problem is that on both

Re: can't ping CARP interfaces

2015-03-30 Thread Martin Pieuchot
On 30/03/15(Mon) 11:58, David Newman wrote: On 3/29/15 12:38 PM, mxb wrote: Probably your PF rules. put in ‘pass quick proto icmp’. No joy. This did not improve on the existing ICMP rule in pf.conf. I think the root problem is that on both firewalls the physical and CARP interface

Re: can't ping CARP interfaces

2015-03-30 Thread David Newman
On 3/29/15 12:38 PM, mxb wrote: Probably your PF rules. put in ‘pass quick proto icmp’. No joy. This did not improve on the existing ICMP rule in pf.conf. I think the root problem is that on both firewalls the physical and CARP interface addresses are bound to lo0 instead of vic1. Here both

Re: can't ping CARP interfaces

2015-03-29 Thread mxb
Probably your PF rules. put in ‘pass quick proto icmp’. On 28 mar 2015, at 00:59, David Newman dnew...@networktest.com wrote: Greetings. In preparation for upgrading two CARP+pfsync boxes to 5.6/i386, I put together a lab network to test new firewall rules. Topology is pretty simple:

can't ping CARP interfaces

2015-03-27 Thread David Newman
Greetings. In preparation for upgrading two CARP+pfsync boxes to 5.6/i386, I put together a lab network to test new firewall rules. Topology is pretty simple: outside box (vic0) - (vic1) two carp boxes (vic0) - inside box with a third interface on each firewall for pfsync traffic. I'm focused