install5x.iso

2013-09-13 Thread Richard Thornton
I am curious - given that OpenBSD ships each RELEASE with X , but
applications like Firefox will not work without installing another DE, like
XFCE; why not ship OpenBSD with the basic X, but with the necessary
libraries to allow FireFox to run and other applications like R to output
graphics?  Also why not go ahead and ship with Firefox?  The disk would
still be within the size of a standard CD.



Re: install5x.iso

2013-09-13 Thread Richard Thornton
In general I really like and appreciate all that is done by developers with
OpenBSD.  The OS is stable and it works well, and shipping it with X
already functional is a big help, especially on older boxes.  Because to
compile xorg with this old sparc box under FreeBSD was taking  24 hours
and it still was not done.


On Fri, Sep 13, 2013 at 11:19 AM, Gregor Best g...@ring0.de wrote:

 On Fri, Sep 13, 2013 at 10:06:10AM -0400, Richard Thornton wrote:
  I am curious - given that OpenBSD ships each RELEASE with X , but
  applications like Firefox will not work without installing another DE,
  [...]

 That is not true. I ran Firefox and Chrome on a clean OpenBSD 4.9
 installation when it was released and I have been able to since then,
 and I find it hard to believe it was different before.

  [...]
  XFCE; why not ship OpenBSD with the basic X, but with the necessary
  libraries to allow FireFox to run and other applications like R to output
  graphics?  Also why not go ahead and ship with Firefox?  The disk would
  still be within the size of a standard CD.
  [...]

 Installing Firefox with pkg_add adds the required libraries
 automatically. If it does not, that's a bug in the port that should be
 reported.

 Adding Firefox to the base system would be a very bad idea. It is a huge
 load of code that needs to be maintained and not everyone uses Firefox.
 What if I want Chrome instead? Add that to base? What about dillo?
 netsurf? Why not add OpenOffice while we are at it?

 --
 Gregor Best



Re: install5x.iso

2013-09-13 Thread Gregor Best
On Fri, Sep 13, 2013 at 10:06:10AM -0400, Richard Thornton wrote:
 I am curious - given that OpenBSD ships each RELEASE with X , but
 applications like Firefox will not work without installing another DE,
 [...]

That is not true. I ran Firefox and Chrome on a clean OpenBSD 4.9
installation when it was released and I have been able to since then,
and I find it hard to believe it was different before.

 [...]
 XFCE; why not ship OpenBSD with the basic X, but with the necessary
 libraries to allow FireFox to run and other applications like R to output
 graphics?  Also why not go ahead and ship with Firefox?  The disk would
 still be within the size of a standard CD.
 [...]

Installing Firefox with pkg_add adds the required libraries
automatically. If it does not, that's a bug in the port that should be
reported.

Adding Firefox to the base system would be a very bad idea. It is a huge
load of code that needs to be maintained and not everyone uses Firefox.
What if I want Chrome instead? Add that to base? What about dillo?
netsurf? Why not add OpenOffice while we are at it?

-- 
Gregor Best



Re: install5x.iso

2013-09-13 Thread Fred Crowson
How much memory and disk does your SPARC have?

You might want to consider a lighter weight browser like midori or netsurf
- I've not bother powering up my old SPARC boxes for about five years - and
I always ran them headless, so my advice is a bit out of date ;~)

hth

Fred
On 13 Sep 2013 16:40, Richard Thornton thornton.rich...@gmail.com wrote:

 In general I really like and appreciate all that is done by developers with
 OpenBSD.  The OS is stable and it works well, and shipping it with X
 already functional is a big help, especially on older boxes.  Because to
 compile xorg with this old sparc box under FreeBSD was taking  24 hours
 and it still was not done.


 On Fri, Sep 13, 2013 at 11:19 AM, Gregor Best g...@ring0.de wrote:

  On Fri, Sep 13, 2013 at 10:06:10AM -0400, Richard Thornton wrote:
   I am curious - given that OpenBSD ships each RELEASE with X , but
   applications like Firefox will not work without installing another DE,
   [...]
 
  That is not true. I ran Firefox and Chrome on a clean OpenBSD 4.9
  installation when it was released and I have been able to since then,
  and I find it hard to believe it was different before.
 
   [...]
   XFCE; why not ship OpenBSD with the basic X, but with the necessary
   libraries to allow FireFox to run and other applications like R to
 output
   graphics?  Also why not go ahead and ship with Firefox?  The disk would
   still be within the size of a standard CD.
   [...]
 
  Installing Firefox with pkg_add adds the required libraries
  automatically. If it does not, that's a bug in the port that should be
  reported.
 
  Adding Firefox to the base system would be a very bad idea. It is a huge
  load of code that needs to be maintained and not everyone uses Firefox.
  What if I want Chrome instead? Add that to base? What about dillo?
  netsurf? Why not add OpenOffice while we are at it?
 
  --
  Gregor Best



Re: install5x.iso

2013-09-13 Thread Greg Thomas
I gave up on Firefox and Chrome on my low memory older laptops, found
midori, and using it everywhere now.  It has exactly what I need and no
more.


On Fri, Sep 13, 2013 at 10:21 AM, Fred Crowson fred.crow...@gmail.comwrote:

 How much memory and disk does your SPARC have?

 You might want to consider a lighter weight browser like midori or netsurf
 - I've not bother powering up my old SPARC boxes for about five years - and
 I always ran them headless, so my advice is a bit out of date ;~)

 hth

 Fred
 On 13 Sep 2013 16:40, Richard Thornton thornton.rich...@gmail.com
 wrote:

  In general I really like and appreciate all that is done by developers
 with
  OpenBSD.  The OS is stable and it works well, and shipping it with X
  already functional is a big help, especially on older boxes.  Because to
  compile xorg with this old sparc box under FreeBSD was taking  24 hours
  and it still was not done.
 
 
  On Fri, Sep 13, 2013 at 11:19 AM, Gregor Best g...@ring0.de wrote:
 
   On Fri, Sep 13, 2013 at 10:06:10AM -0400, Richard Thornton wrote:
I am curious - given that OpenBSD ships each RELEASE with X , but
applications like Firefox will not work without installing another
 DE,
[...]
  
   That is not true. I ran Firefox and Chrome on a clean OpenBSD 4.9
   installation when it was released and I have been able to since then,
   and I find it hard to believe it was different before.
  
[...]
XFCE; why not ship OpenBSD with the basic X, but with the necessary
libraries to allow FireFox to run and other applications like R to
  output
graphics?  Also why not go ahead and ship with Firefox?  The disk
 would
still be within the size of a standard CD.
[...]
  
   Installing Firefox with pkg_add adds the required libraries
   automatically. If it does not, that's a bug in the port that should be
   reported.
  
   Adding Firefox to the base system would be a very bad idea. It is a
 huge
   load of code that needs to be maintained and not everyone uses Firefox.
   What if I want Chrome instead? Add that to base? What about dillo?
   netsurf? Why not add OpenOffice while we are at it?
  
   --
   Gregor Best