Re: rtl8192ee currently supported?

2022-12-02 Thread Jonathan Matthew
On Fri, Dec 02, 2022 at 10:05:12AM -, Stuart Henderson wrote:
> On 2022-12-02, Heppler, J. Scott  wrote:
> > I'm shopping for a faster (300mbps +) PCIe wireless card.  Although I'm
> > leaning intel, realtek's base firmware is an advantage.
> > V2 of the TP-LINK TL-WN881ND uses rtl8192ee chipset which was in the
> > separate sysutils/firmware builds:
> >
> > @comment $OpenBSD: PLIST,v 1.2 2018/09/21 09:49:45 sthen Exp $
> > firmware/rtwn-license
> > firmware/rtwn-rtl8188efw
> > firmware/rtwn-rtl8192cfwU
> > firmware/rtwn-rtl8192cfwU_B
> > firmware/rtwn-rtl8192eefw
> > firmware/rtwn-rtl8723befw_36
> > firmware/rtwn-rtl8723fw
> > firmware/rtwn-rtl8723fw_B
> >
> >
> > Recent current ls /etc/firwmare | grep rtwn:
> >
> > rtwn-licensertwn-rtl8192cU  rtwn-rtl8723
> > rtwn-rtl8188e   rtwn-rtl8192cU_Brtwn-rtl8723_B
> >
> > Would a rtl8192ee chipset be supported?
> 
> It's not clear. Though it's listed in rtwn(4), the actual driver didn't
> use the rtl8192eefw file (probably hitting a fallback case and using
> rtl8192cU_B). 8192ee doesn't show up in the dm...@openbsd.org logs.
> I wouldn't buy one and expect it to definitely work.

It doesn't work, and the driver won't attach to it.
I have a diff somewhere that gets some signs of life out of it,
but nothing useful at all.



Re: rtl8192ee currently supported?

2022-12-02 Thread Stuart Henderson
On 2022-12-02, Heppler, J. Scott  wrote:
> I'm shopping for a faster (300mbps +) PCIe wireless card.  Although I'm
> leaning intel, realtek's base firmware is an advantage.
> V2 of the TP-LINK TL-WN881ND uses rtl8192ee chipset which was in the
> separate sysutils/firmware builds:
>
> @comment $OpenBSD: PLIST,v 1.2 2018/09/21 09:49:45 sthen Exp $
> firmware/rtwn-license
> firmware/rtwn-rtl8188efw
> firmware/rtwn-rtl8192cfwU
> firmware/rtwn-rtl8192cfwU_B
> firmware/rtwn-rtl8192eefw
> firmware/rtwn-rtl8723befw_36
> firmware/rtwn-rtl8723fw
> firmware/rtwn-rtl8723fw_B
>
>
> Recent current ls /etc/firwmare | grep rtwn:
>
> rtwn-licensertwn-rtl8192cU  rtwn-rtl8723
> rtwn-rtl8188e   rtwn-rtl8192cU_Brtwn-rtl8723_B
>
> Would a rtl8192ee chipset be supported?

It's not clear. Though it's listed in rtwn(4), the actual driver didn't
use the rtl8192eefw file (probably hitting a fallback case and using
rtl8192cU_B). 8192ee doesn't show up in the dm...@openbsd.org logs.
I wouldn't buy one and expect it to definitely work.

Also note the caveats section of rtwn(4), if it _does_ work it will
not be particularly quick. 

If by 300mbps+ you mean you actually want to get 300Mb+ TCP throughput
then I think your options are the newer intel devices (iwm, iwx)
or 11ac bwfm, but iwm/iwx are likely much easier to find. athn is
likely to do better than rtwn but probably not 300+.

> There are a plethora a cheap 1200mbps cards with 8821ce chips.
> Is there inclinations/efforts to add support?

AFAIK the next main target for wifi is ath11k (in particular WCN6855
which is used in various recent laptops including X13s).

-- 
Please keep replies on the mailing list.



rtl8192ee currently supported?

2022-12-01 Thread Heppler, J. Scott

I'm shopping for a faster (300mbps +) PCIe wireless card.  Although I'm
leaning intel, realtek's base firmware is an advantage.
V2 of the TP-LINK TL-WN881ND uses rtl8192ee chipset which was in the
separate sysutils/firmware builds:

@comment $OpenBSD: PLIST,v 1.2 2018/09/21 09:49:45 sthen Exp $
firmware/rtwn-license
firmware/rtwn-rtl8188efw
firmware/rtwn-rtl8192cfwU
firmware/rtwn-rtl8192cfwU_B
firmware/rtwn-rtl8192eefw
firmware/rtwn-rtl8723befw_36
firmware/rtwn-rtl8723fw
firmware/rtwn-rtl8723fw_B


Recent current ls /etc/firwmare | grep rtwn:

rtwn-licensertwn-rtl8192cU  rtwn-rtl8723
rtwn-rtl8188e   rtwn-rtl8192cU_Brtwn-rtl8723_B

Would a rtl8192ee chipset be supported?

There are a plethora a cheap 1200mbps cards with 8821ce chips.
Is there inclinations/efforts to add support?

Thanks 



--
J. Scott Heppler