Re: [MD] Deciphering LILA

2012-03-27 Thread Ian Glendinning
Can't wait. Ian On Tue, Mar 27, 2012 at 12:24 AM, Ant McWatt antmcw...@hotmail.co.uk wrote: Mark Smith stated, yesterday and today: What I meant by cypher was an algorithm which can be used to decipher Lila.   Mathematics and language are one and the same... The use of an appropriate

Re: [MD] qualified relativists

2012-03-27 Thread Ian Glendinning
True Mark, but you did say Anthropocentrism means that the way we see things is the way they must be. Which is exactly what it isn't. What it really means is The way we see things is the way we must see them. Great fishing BTW ;-) Ian On Mon, Mar 26, 2012 at 11:49 PM, 118 ununocti...@gmail.com

Re: [MD] Deciphering LILA

2012-03-27 Thread Andre
Mark: What I meant by cypher was an algorithm which can be used to decipher Lila. Mathematics and language are one and the same... The use of an appropriate cypher is required to decrypt passages, which is the difficult part (and has occupied me for several years now). Andre:

Re: [MD] Why are things called patterns?

2012-03-27 Thread craigerb
[Mark] Anthropocentrism means that the way we see things is the way they must be. [Ian] [Anthropocentrism means that] the way we see things is the way we must see them. [Wikipedia] Anthropocentrism describes an analysis from the perspective that human beings are the central, only or most

Re: [MD] qualified relativists

2012-03-27 Thread craigerb
CORRECTED SUBJECT LINE: [Mark] Anthropocentrism means that the way we see things is the way they must be. [Ian] [Anthropocentrism means that] the way we see things is the way we must see them. [Wikipedia] Anthropocentrism describes an analysis from the perspective that human beings are

Re: [MD] Free will.

2012-03-27 Thread Ian Glendinning
My position ? It IS NOT illusory. How we perceive it IS full of illusions - from our subjective perspective (see anthropic). Science of the brain (and wider bodily systems) may explain more of the illusory perceptions of our minds - deciding to act based on what we know - but I don't believe it

Re: [MD] qualified relativists

2012-03-27 Thread Ian Glendinning
Hi Craig, Any idiot can look up wikipedia / dictionary definitions (even Platt) ;-) I was obviously choosing to create my sentence by re-arranging the same words Mark had used. (If we are going to discuss Anthropocentrism we need to bear in mind that there are 4 or 5 or maybe 6 different weak

Re: [MD] Platt

2012-03-27 Thread Horse
Hi Guys I received this from Mary so I thought I'd pass it on. Just thought I should let you know. Horse * From:* Platt Holden [mailto:platthol...@gmail.com] *Sent:* Friday, March 23, 2012 10:02 AM *To:* Mary *Subject:* Platt Dear Mary, My name is Judy Holden and I'm Platt's wife. I tried

Re: [MD] Platt

2012-03-27 Thread Ian Glendinning
Oh wow, and me just making a wise-crack at Platt's expense ... the first mention in years(!) ... spooky. Get well soon Platt. Ian On Tue, Mar 27, 2012 at 10:14 AM, Horse ho...@darkstar.uk.net wrote: Hi Guys I received this from Mary so I thought I'd pass it on. Just thought I should let you

[MD] Administrator announcement

2012-03-27 Thread Horse
All MD-ers This forum is rapidly descending into a pointless mess and I intend to do something about it. We have a list of rules which you can find at: http://www.moq.org/md/index.html please take the time to read what is there and adhere carefully to what it says - especially the 4 posts a

Re: [MD] Deciphering LILA

2012-03-27 Thread 118
Hi Andre, Thank you for your kind words an encouragement. Best regards, Mark Sent laboriously from an iPhone, Mark On Mar 27, 2012, at 1:04 AM, Andre andrebroer...@gmail.com wrote: Mark: What I meant by cypher was an algorithm which can be used to decipher Lila. Mathematics and language

Re: [MD] Why are things called patterns?

2012-03-27 Thread 118
Hi Craig, The Wiki quote makes sense to me. The Devil is in the details... Sent laboriously from an iPhone, Mark On Mar 27, 2012, at 1:07 AM, craig...@comcast.net wrote: [Mark] Anthropocentrism means that the way we see things is the way they must be. [Ian] [Anthropocentrism means that]

Re: [MD] qualified relativists

2012-03-27 Thread 118
Hi Ian, I think the question may be: How static do we make the human view? Sent laboriously from an iPhone, Mark On Mar 27, 2012, at 1:46 AM, Ian Glendinning ian.glendinn...@gmail.com wrote: Hi Craig, Any idiot can look up wikipedia / dictionary definitions (even Platt) ;-) I was obviously

Re: [MD] Administrator announcement

2012-03-27 Thread 118
Hi Horse, Thanks for the reminder. Sent laboriously from an iPhone, Mark On Mar 27, 2012, at 2:36 AM, Horse ho...@darkstar.uk.net wrote: All MD-ers This forum is rapidly descending into a pointless mess and I intend to do something about it. We have a list of rules which you can find

Re: [MD] Platt

2012-03-27 Thread craigerb
[Judy] Platt had triple by-pass and valve replacement surgery This should put to rest the rumor that Platt had no heart. Some one who is not liberal when young, has no heart. Some one who is liberal when old, has no head. Moq_Discuss mailing list Listinfo, Unsubscribing etc.

Re: [MD] Administrator announcement

2012-03-27 Thread Matt Kundert
Hi Horse, I'm confused by one of your remarks attending the Rules of the MD. You said, Also, don't try to play silly semantic games with the wording or answer 5 posts with one of your own etc. etc.. I'm just wondering about the last part. It's been a common practice of mine to respond to

Re: [MD] Dewey's Zen

2012-03-27 Thread Ant McWatt
On March 25th David Buchanan wrote: This might be fun but it's also a kind of experiment. I was reading a paper and saw many parallels to Pirsig, which wasn't very surprising because it's titled Dewey's Zen. But I wonder if others read it the same way I do. In certain passages it seems like

Re: [MD] Deciphering LILA

2012-03-27 Thread Andre
Mark to Andre: Thank you for your kind words an encouragement. Andre: No encouragement intended Mark, nor kindness for that matter. It's just that , for somebody who stresses the evils of static quality and proclaims himself living in DQ to resort to extracting some magical insights into LILA

Re: [MD] DMB's friends

2012-03-27 Thread Joseph Maurer
Hi Mark, A mathematical conception of DQ is ambivalent. Metaphysics follows a reality of perception prior to the logic of conception. There is a difference between the perception of metaphysics and the conception of mathematical logic. In MOQ there is no definition of DQ. IMHO DQ is the

[MD] FW: Dewey's Zen

2012-03-27 Thread david buchanan
Thanks for playing along, gents. Just about everyone seems to be reading it the same way I do. Ant totally nailed it, of course, and it seems safe to consider my hunch pretty well confirmed. I was fairly confident already but we always gotta watch out for the Cleveland Harbor Effect and other

[MD] lila's soliloquy

2012-03-27 Thread MarshaV
It's not whatever you like, but whatever you think. First with your question you create a world (and self) in time and space, and then you are bound to search and create answers containing causes and conditions and components to populate, explain and define it. Those causes, conditions and

Re: [MD] FW: Dewey's Zen

2012-03-27 Thread Carl Thames
It's been a while since I read Lila, so I didn't grasp the term Cleveland Harbor Effect when you used it. I did a search on it, and came up with: http://www.quantonics.com/Pirsigs_Lila_Quotes_on_Insanity.html This essay addresses many parts of this message. I'm going to have to read it a

Re: [MD] Contradiction and incoherence

2012-03-27 Thread 118
Hi Marsha, Do you concede this or does Pirsig? I am not quite sure who you are talking about, but it would seem that perhaps you are speaking for Pirsig. Are static values the same as value for you? Thanks, Sent laboriously from an iPhone, Mark On Mar 26, 2012, at 1:30 AM, MarshaV

Re: [MD] lila's soliloquy

2012-03-27 Thread 118
Hi Marsha, This makes sense to me. For you is thinking just static or does it have a dynamic component? For me, most of thinking is following DQ, it is only when we objectivize it for the purposes of exchange (words) that it is temporarily static. Our thinking is much more than words. An

Re: [MD] Deciphering LILA

2012-03-27 Thread 118
Hi Andre, What encourages me is that I ruffle your feathers. Getting you out of complacency is encouragement indeed! Every time you think I am doing something wrong, I must be doing something right. Just trying to break your spell, get you out of the static and into the dynamic. It is an

Re: [MD] FW: Dewey's Zen

2012-03-27 Thread 118
Hi Carl, I found that a while back as well, and based a number of my posts on that collection. I would be interested to get your take on the relationship between the insanity of Phaedrus and that of Lila. Cheers, Sent laboriously from an iPhone, Mark On Mar 27, 2012, at 7:50 PM, Carl Thames

Re: [MD] FW: Dewey's Zen

2012-03-27 Thread 118
Thanks guys, That was an interesting exercise in decrypting one message using the algorithm of another. I learned something. Cheers, Sent laboriously from an iPhone, Mark On Mar 27, 2012, at 2:39 PM, david buchanan dmbucha...@hotmail.com wrote: Thanks for playing along, gents. Just about