Re: [music-dsp] To EE or not to EE (Was: Job at Waldorf and Possible Job Opportunity)

2012-05-30 Thread Stefan Stenzel
Sorry for the late reply, I rarely use this address anymore. I had some inquiries about the phrase where I stated my preference for candidates without formal degrees. My intention was not to discourage or discriminate academics here, but lacking a formal degree myself, I thought it might be a good

Re: [music-dsp] To EE or not to EE (Was: Job at Waldorf and Possible Job Opportunity)

2012-05-08 Thread Theo Verelst
Being "guilty" of rather promoting the EE idea of course I have feelings or thoughts about the subject: I'd think like with IT type of subjects, the danger exists that the well founded and theoretically usually strong (university) EE subjects should be guarded against mis-use somewhat, to pre

Re: [music-dsp] To EE or not to EE (Was: Job at Waldorf and Possible Job Opportunity)

2012-05-04 Thread Al Clark
On 5/4/2012 11:11 AM, robert bristow-johnson wrote: On 5/2/2012 10:47 PM, Ross Bencina wrote: Hi All, (but especially Stefan and Al) I'm wondering if I can draw you on what is it about Electrical Engineering qualifications that is important to these kind of jobs (I have some ideas, but not

Re: [music-dsp] To EE or not to EE (Was: Job at Waldorf and Possible Job Opportunity)

2012-05-04 Thread robert bristow-johnson
On 5/2/2012 10:47 PM, Ross Bencina wrote: Hi All, (but especially Stefan and Al) I'm wondering if I can draw you on what is it about Electrical Engineering qualifications that is important to these kind of jobs (I have some ideas, but not the full picture, since I'm not an EE). I was inte

Re: [music-dsp] To EE or not to EE (Was: Job at Waldorf and Possible Job Opportunity)

2012-05-03 Thread Nigel Redmon
I didn't have that experience, Michael. Having homework forced me to do homework. I had a US Government teacher as a senior in high school that made me think about how life works a bit, balanced by a math teacher in college that nearly crushed my interest in math...pretty much everything I use c

Re: [music-dsp] To EE or not to EE (Was: Job at Waldorf and Possible Job Opportunity)

2012-05-03 Thread Charles Henry
On 5/3/12, Nigel Redmon wrote: > Also, a formal education can lock you into a limiting mentality. For > instance, we all know the limitations of linear interpolation, but some know > it "too well". > > ;-) Allow me to share my interpolator polynomial analytic transform tables vis a vis desiginin

Re: [music-dsp] To EE or not to EE (Was: Job at Waldorf and Possible Job Opportunity)

2012-05-03 Thread Michael Gogins
I'm a an algorithmic composer and contributor to Csound. I have no academic qualification for this work. I was a music major in jazz peformance for a year, but my B.A. is in comparative religion. Nevertheless I profoundly believe that formal education can be enormously beneficial. It all depends o

Re: [music-dsp] To EE or not to EE (Was: Job at Waldorf and Possible Job Opportunity)

2012-05-03 Thread Nigel Redmon
A couple of ideas... First, note that "Given identical qualification" can imply that someone without a degree might have gotten to the same level as someone with a degree by a lot of digging and figuring on their own. Some call this getting one's "hands dirty"—implying that you didn't just read

Re: [music-dsp] To EE or not to EE (Was: Job at Waldorf and Possible Job Opportunity)

2012-05-03 Thread Al Clark
I think it's a hard question to articulate (especially if you are an engineer, since we can't write). I think Stefan & I have some of the same perspective. An electrical engineering or similar education is usually the starting point of an engineering career. During this process, you hopefully

[music-dsp] To EE or not to EE (Was: Job at Waldorf and Possible Job Opportunity)

2012-05-02 Thread Ross Bencina
Hi All, (but especially Stefan and Al) I'm wondering if I can draw you on what is it about Electrical Engineering qualifications that is important to these kind of jobs (I have some ideas, but not the full picture, since I'm not an EE). I was interested to see in Stefan's recently posted job: