Re: [mb-style] Removal of homeburnt discIds

2008-11-24 Thread Philipp Wolfer
Hi, reopening an older discussion: Edit #9534224 ( http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=9534224) is a good example why it might be bad to remove disc IDs that just look suspicious. Obviously there are valid disc IDs that have those 2 seconds extra in every track which some people use to

Re: [mb-style] Removal of homeburnt discIds

2008-11-24 Thread david scotson
Couple of questions: Does the identification of (alleged) CD-R copies work in both directions? That is, if I put in a burnt CD, could my software (or the MB API) be smart enough to say that doesn't match any CD-Indexes of official releases, but I'm 99% sure that it's a burnt copy of album X. If

Re: [mb-style] Removal of homeburnt discIds

2008-11-24 Thread Philipp Wolfer
2008/11/24 david scotson [EMAIL PROTECTED] Couple of questions: Does the identification of (alleged) CD-R copies work in both directions? That is, if I put in a burnt CD, could my software (or the MB API) be smart enough to say that doesn't match any CD-Indexes of official releases, but I'm

Re: [mb-style] Audio Drama

2008-11-24 Thread Arturus Magi
On Thu, Oct 30, 2008 at 10:08 AM, Z [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Any idea on how to deal with artists on tracks that are audio drama, radio drama, radio theatre, etc.? Should it be the writer? What if it is a drama re-enacting a manga (comic)? Should it be the script writer or the poriginal manga