As 9 days has passed without further comment, and so I can know exactly how
to try to give guidance on a draft DVD wiki page, just a simple RFC to clear
though this one of the 2 outstanding questions, raised in this thread, which
I think are still pending determination as to how to handle them.
+1 for DVD-Audio and Blu-ray (as long as it's spelt correctly. ;)
I guess I'd like to hear that there are releases that MB should catalog
for HD-DVD before we add that type. I'm neutral on that one.
-Original Message-
From: Brian Schweitzer brian.brianschweit...@gmail.com
Reply-to:
Splitting off this as a true proposal, since there does seem at least one
other who sees it as beneficial. :)
Really simple proposal: ADd Blu-ray as a release type. (Thanks for the
spelling correction Paul.)
On Mon, Dec 22, 2008 at 1:46 PM, Paul C. Bryan em...@pbryan.net wrote:
+1 for
Again splitting as a real proposal, for the sake of clear discussion.
It does seem that some concerts were released on HD-DVD, so it's likely to
be needed at some point, else those get dumped into DVD. Just from a
quickie google search:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000VDDEQ8
Okay, a really begrudging +1 for HD-DVD (it just feels like voting +1
for Betamax!)
But this does get me thinking...
I note we have media type of Vinyl but don't distinguish between disc
sizes, speed, constant linear vs. angular velocity, stereo/mono, RIAA
equalization, and so on. We just say
perhaps this has already come up, but is there any particular reason
why i can't see CD-ID additions in a release's edit history? only i
think if we had access to that things would be a lot easier - eg a
dodgy looking CD-ID addition could be retrospectively checked by
leaving an edit note on the
On 22-Dec-08, at 9:54 PM, Mustaqil Ali wrote:
From a technical aspect, adding DVD-Audio to the list of media
types isn't all that needs doing.
The current DVD media that exists will need renaming; either to DVD-
Video or to the proposed DVD-Audio and then the DVD-Video media type
Well, the standards are called DVD and DVD-Audio, right? I guess it
depends on if we're aiming more for correctness in titling, or clarity to
the users...
Brian
On Mon, Dec 22, 2008 at 9:54 PM, Mustaqil Ali mustaq...@yahoo.co.uk wrote:
From a technical aspect, adding DVD-Audio to the list of
DVD simply stands for Digital Versatile Disc. DVD-Video is a standard for
storing video content on DVDs, and DVD-Audio a standard for storing audio
content.
Much like how you have a CD which can be burnt with whatever on it, however
there are standards like the Red Book Audio CD and that for
