Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Sean Donelan
On Tue, 28 Jan 2003, Steven M. Bellovin wrote: They do have a lousy track record. I'm convinced, though, that they're sincere about wanting to improve, and they're really trying very hard. In fact, I hope that some other vendors follow their lead. Of course we need to be honest with

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Richard A Steenbergen
On Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 03:32:41AM -0500, Sean Donelan wrote: FORTRAN/COBOL array bounds checking. Bell Labs answer: C. Who wants the computer to check array lengths or pointers. Programmers know what they are doing, and don't need to be constrained by the programming language. Everyone

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-29 Thread Michael . Dillon
His main thesis was basically that every OS in common use today, from Windows to UNIX variants, has a fundamental flaw in the way privileges and permissions are handled - the concept of superuser/administrator. He argued instead that OSes should be redesigned to implement the principle of

Arbor Networks

2003-01-29 Thread c johnson
Has anyone had experiences with Arbor Networks Peakflow DOS and Traffic products? If so could you share your experiences, whitepapers, evaluations, etc. off list? I am interested in the generalized view of the effectiveness of the product as well as any enhancement requests that operators

Mono Culture - was Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Joseph T. Klein
On Wednesday, January 29, 2003, at 02:32 AM, Sean Donelan wrote: On Tue, 28 Jan 2003, Steven M. Bellovin wrote: They do have a lousy track record. I'm convinced, though, that they're sincere about wanting to improve, and they're really trying very hard. In fact, I hope that some other

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Marshall Eubanks
A world before buffer overflow exploits ? The first (Fortran) programming course I ever took at MIT on the first day of lab they said 1.) If you set an array index to a sufficiently large negative number you would overwrite the operating system and crash the system (requiring a reboot from

Re: Mono Culture - was Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Peter Salus
Though it was written nearly two years ago, John Quarterman's Monoculture Considered Harmful remains the very best exposition of this issue. //www.firstmonday.org/issues/issue7_2/quarterman/ Peter

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Alif The Terrible
On Wed, 29 Jan 2003, Richard A Steenbergen wrote: On Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 03:32:41AM -0500, Sean Donelan wrote: FORTRAN/COBOL array bounds checking. Bell Labs answer: C. Who wants the computer to check array lengths or pointers. Programmers know what they are doing, and don't need

Re: Aggregate traffic management

2003-01-29 Thread Mike Lloyd
Hopefully I can stay within the bounds of NANOG's traditions against marketing material if I limit myself to thanking Kyle for his comments, and encourage anyone attending NANOG 27 who would like more info on automated control of routing for load objectives to come find me at the meeting.

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Leo Bicknell
In a message written on Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 03:32:41AM -0500, Sean Donelan wrote: Multics security. Bell Labs answer: Unix. Who needs all that extra security junk in Multics. We don't need to protect /etc/passwd because we use DES crypt and users always choose strong passwords. We'll make

RE: Banc of America Article

2003-01-29 Thread Al Rowland
Or, IIRC, the ATM system is similar to CC transactions. A best effort is made to authorize against your account (Credit Card or Banking) but if it fails and the transaction is within a normal range (your daily card limit) the CC/ATM completes the transaction. I'd be willing to bet the failure

RE: Dropouts since Saturday 1/25/03 only affecting web traffic?

2003-01-29 Thread Al Rowland
A single point of consumer data. I haven't checked by home router logs since Monday night but I was seeing a pattern of significant incoming port 80 traffic (I'm not running any services) over the last week or so, similar to increased 1433/1434 traffic before Saturday's flurry. Best regards,

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Richard A Steenbergen
On Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 08:50:56AM -0500, Marshall Eubanks wrote: A world before buffer overflow exploits ? The first (Fortran) programming course I ever took at MIT on the first day of lab they said 1.) If you set an array index to a sufficiently large negative number you would

RE: Dropouts since Saturday 1/25/03 only affecting web traffic?

2003-01-29 Thread Todd A. Blank
I am seeing this as well, but only from a few hosts on a single network. I have contacted their NOC and asked them to knock it off - no pun intended... Could be some nimda infected boxes or whatever. Firewalls are stopping it, but it is annoying to wade through the logs. Todd -Original

RE: Dropouts since Saturday 1/25/03 only affecting web traffic?

2003-01-29 Thread Jim Popovitch
One thing that I see remaining since this past weekend is massive timeouts and latencies in mail delivery to very popular addresses (@hotmail, @rr.com, and @earthlink) @att.net seems to be accepting email without any major issues, hopefully all these issues will continue to slowly return to

RE: Aggregate traffic management

2003-01-29 Thread Todd A. Blank
We are a RouteScience customer. We are using this box and it rules. We have been extremely happy with the results. We have multiple OC-x circuits that we are engineering traffic over, and this box gives us the ability to see things that we could not see before. It also really allows us to

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-29 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On Tue, 28 Jan 2003, Scott Francis wrote: I'm still looking for a copy of the presentation, but I was able to find a slightly older rant he wrote that contains many of the same points: http://www.bsdatwork.com/reviews.php?op=showcontentid=2 Good reading, even if it's not very much practical

RE: Banc of America Article

2003-01-29 Thread E.B. Dreger
AR Date: Wed, 29 Jan 2003 07:20:35 -0800 AR From: Al Rowland AR IIRC, the ATM system is similar to CC transactions. A best AR effort is made to authorize against your account (Credit Card AR or Banking) but if it fails and the transaction is within a AR normal range (your daily card limit) the

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Richard A Steenbergen
On Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 05:26:06PM +, E.B. Dreger wrote: If you check before each byte. Checking for sufficient space first (is there room for a 245-byte string?) is much faster. Besides, looking at all the bloated code using indirect function calls[*] and crappy code using poor

RE: Banc of America Article

2003-01-29 Thread alex
IIRC, the ATM system is similar to CC transactions. A best effort is made to authorize against your account (Credit Card or Banking) but if it fails and the transaction is within a normal range (your daily card limit) the CC/ATM completes the transaction. Too bad it is not the case,

Re: .org whois

2003-01-29 Thread Richard A Steenbergen
On Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 12:40:00PM -0500, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Is there a new top-level whois server or did shared registry whois stop providing references to the appropriate whois servers for .org? At least a pair of domain registars cannot adjust any .org records claiming that the

Re: .org whois

2003-01-29 Thread Adam McKenna
On Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 12:40:00PM -0500, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Is there a new top-level whois server or did shared registry whois stop providing references to the appropriate whois servers for .org? At least a pair of domain registars cannot adjust any .org records claiming that the

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread E.B. Dreger
RAS Date: Wed, 29 Jan 2003 12:36:22 -0500 RAS From: Richard A Steenbergen RAS Note I'm making a distinction between fixing the string RAS libraries to handle overflow situations better, and changing RAS the entire OS to do array bounds checking. One is good, the RAS other is not. Okay. I'll

Re: .org whois

2003-01-29 Thread E.B. Dreger
TY Date: Wed, 29 Jan 2003 12:53:20 -0500 TY From: Tim Yocum TY One can only speculate why the whois servers have vanished, TY however it should be noted that as of about an hour ago, all TY sorts of odd whois output was being served - including TY incorrect contact information for domains

Re: .org whois

2003-01-29 Thread E.B. Dreger
AM Date: Wed, 29 Jan 2003 09:44:05 -0800 AM From: Adam McKenna AM The root servers aren't providing referrals to the gtld-servers for .org AM anymore.. Instead they're referring to here: [ snip new .org glue RRs that point to nstld.com ] AM Anyone know anything about this? I can't find

Re: .org whois

2003-01-29 Thread Rob Thomas
Hi, Adam. ] Anyone know anything about this? I can't find anything on ICANN's web site ] regarding a switch. I noticed it on 8 Jan, and adjusted my monitoring accordingly. http://www.cymru.com/DNS/gtlddns-o.html Thanks, Rob. -- Rob Thomas http://www.cymru.com ASSERT(coffee != empty);

RE: Banc of America Article

2003-01-29 Thread Daniel Senie
At 12:46 PM 1/29/2003, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: IIRC, the ATM system is similar to CC transactions. A best effort is made to authorize against your account (Credit Card or Banking) but if it fails and the transaction is within a normal range (your daily card limit) the CC/ATM completes the

RE: Banc of America Article

2003-01-29 Thread Charles Sprickman
On Wed, 29 Jan 2003, Al Rowland wrote: Or, IIRC, the ATM system is similar to CC transactions. A best effort is made to authorize against your account (Credit Card or Banking) but if it fails and the transaction is within a normal range (your daily card limit) the CC/ATM completes the

Re: .org whois

2003-01-29 Thread Jeff Godin
On Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 12:40:00PM -0500, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Is there a new top-level whois server or did shared registry whois stop providing references to the appropriate whois servers for .org? Alex -- Alex- The new whois server for the .ORG TLD can be found at

OT: Banc of America Article

2003-01-29 Thread Al Rowland
I believe specific account data is not kept on the local machine. I may be wrong, not to mention the data strip on the card... Nothing new. Look at what happened to the Chicago Board of Trade a few years back. I wonder how WCOM reported the out-of-court settlement for that one their books. ;0

Re: .org whois

2003-01-29 Thread Jared Mauch
On Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 12:11:07PM -0600, Rob Thomas wrote: ] Anyone know anything about this? I can't find anything on ICANN's web site ] regarding a switch. I noticed it on 8 Jan, and adjusted my monitoring accordingly. http://www.cymru.com/DNS/gtlddns-o.html Jan 2, 2003

Re: .org whois

2003-01-29 Thread Joe Abley
On Wednesday, Jan 29, 2003, at 12:53 Canada/Eastern, Tim Yocum wrote: on the 31st of December, 02, VeriSign was no longer the registry operator for .org. The new registrar is called Public Interest Registry One can only speculate why the whois servers have vanished, whois.crsnic.net was

OT: Banc of America Article

2003-01-29 Thread Al Rowland
Just for grins, The PIN is on your card, likely encrypted, this based on the fact that most ATMs will reject your card at the initial PIN prompt before you try to execute any transaction, as is likely your balance and daily withdrawal limit but the Kwik-E-Mart system might not have a way to see

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Steven M. Bellovin
In message [EMAIL PROTECTED], Sean Donelan writes: On Tue, 28 Jan 2003, Steven M. Bellovin wrote: They do have a lousy track record. I'm convinced, though, that they're sincere about wanting to improve, and they're really trying very hard. In fact, I hope that some other vendors follow

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-29 Thread just me
On Tue, 28 Jan 2003, Scott Francis wrote: He argued instead that OSes should be redesigned to implement the principle of least privilege from the ground up, down to the architecture they run on. [...] The problem there is the same as with windowsupdate - if one can spoof the central

routing between provider edge and CPE routers

2003-01-29 Thread Mike Bernico
Hi, I apologize if this has been asked before. I work for an ISP that started very small (hundreds of T1 and 56k customers) and has grown very large in the last few years (thousands of T1 customers, as well as DS3 customers and OC3 customers). We currently use an IGP to route between our

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Mathew Lodge
At 08:27 AM 1/29/2003 -0600, Alif The Terrible wrote: FORTRAN/COBOL array bounds checking. Bell Labs answer: C. Who wants the computer to check array lengths or pointers. Programmers know what they are doing, and don't need to be constrained by the programming language. Everyone knows

Re: routing between provider edge and CPE routers

2003-01-29 Thread Bruce Robertson
We switched to BGP just recently, before things got out of hand. I highly recommend that you do so. It really does work better. It's very nice seeing your OSPF config carry essentially just the loopback interfaces. In particular I'm wondering about the thousands of lines of configuration

Re: .org whois

2003-01-29 Thread just me
On Wed, 29 Jan 2003, Jeff Godin wrote: The new whois server for the .ORG TLD can be found at whois.publicinterestregistry.net. Web interface for .ORG WHOIS can be found at URI:http://www.pir.org/whois/. Wed Jan 29 11:08:09 matt@pants:~$ whois -h whois.publicinterestregistry.net

Re: OT: Banc of America Article

2003-01-29 Thread Brett Frankenberger
On Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 10:35:37AM -0800, Al Rowland wrote: The PIN is on your card, likely encrypted, We're off-topic now, so I won't go into detail, but the PIN is sometimes on the card and sometimes not. There are different ways of doing it. (If the sampling of cards in my wallet is

Re: Banc of America Article

2003-01-29 Thread Joel Baker
On Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 01:19:08PM -0500, Charles Sprickman wrote: On Wed, 29 Jan 2003, Al Rowland wrote: Or, IIRC, the ATM system is similar to CC transactions. A best effort is made to authorize against your account (Credit Card or Banking) but if it fails and the transaction is

RE: Dropouts since Saturday 1/25/03 only affecting web traffic?

2003-01-29 Thread Al Rowland
I've also seen a few 25/110/111 requests in my logs but it didn't seem higher than 'normal.' Best regards, __ Al Rowland -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] On Behalf Of Jim Popovitch Sent: Wednesday, January 29, 2003

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread E.B. Dreger
ML Date: Wed, 29 Jan 2003 11:07:59 -0800 ML From: Mathew Lodge ML It doesn't have to be, if your compiler is worth its salt. ML Take a look at the GNU Ada compiler implementation of bound ML checking -- incredibly efficient. s/compiler/programmer/ How about: struct buf_t {

Re: routing between provider edge and CPE routers

2003-01-29 Thread Christopher L. Morrow
On Wed, 29 Jan 2003, Mike Bernico wrote: Hi, I apologize if this has been asked before. I work for an ISP that started very small (hundreds of T1 and 56k customers) and has grown very large in the last few years (thousands of T1 customers, as well as DS3 customers and OC3 customers).

Re: .org whois

2003-01-29 Thread william
.org is being moved into new Public Internet Registry away from NSI Their whois server can be found at http://www.orgtransition.info And if you prefer to get all info at once, I run recursive server at completewhois.com. It can be used from command-line (unlike PIR's server) - whois -h

OT: Banc of America Article

2003-01-29 Thread Al Rowland
Your assumption is my account is at my local branch. Neither is my safe deposit box. It's at a different, larger branch in the adjacent suburb. My 'account' is likely in one of their corporate monoliths downtown, hence the network connection. That's why my card works as well in Virginia (my most

Re: routing between provider edge and CPE routers

2003-01-29 Thread Serge Maskalik
My recommendation would be for you to: o redistribute directly connected interfaces via a strict filter into BGP and use iBGP to carry it around the local AS or o use passive interfaces in IGPs to do the same Avoid having to run a topology computation everytime a

Re: .org whois

2003-01-29 Thread just me
I tried an nslookup about 20 minutes after I sent that mail, and it succeeded as well. Probably a pbi.net barf near my end as all three auth nameservers returned me the correct info. Of course, there's still the issue of the whois returning complete garbage, aside from the two nameserver

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-29 Thread Scott Francis
On Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 10:47:30AM -0800, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: On Tue, 28 Jan 2003, Scott Francis wrote: He argued instead that OSes should be redesigned to implement the principle of least privilege from the ground up, down to the architecture they run on. [...] The problem

Re: routing between provider edge and CPE routers

2003-01-29 Thread Vadim Antonov
On Wed, 29 Jan 2003, Christopher L. Morrow wrote: On Wed, 29 Jan 2003, Mike Bernico wrote: We currently use an IGP to route between our distribution routers and the CPE routers we manage. So, if customers bounce your IGP churns away? And customers have access to your IGP data

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-29 Thread Scott Francis
On Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 12:21:50PM -0800, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: [snip] So far, the closest thing I've seen to this concept is the ssh administrative host model: adminhost:~root/.ssh/id_dsa.pub is copied to every targethost:~root/.ssh/authorized_keys2, such that commands

RE: routing between provider edge and CPE routers

2003-01-29 Thread Mike Bernico
Thanks so much for all the feedback. All your input has been extremely helpful. Just to clarify: In our network core all customer routes are summarized and carried in iBGP. That was a recent change of mine. We use EIGRP to carry loopback and next hop information. I'm working on migrating

Re: OT: Banc of America Article

2003-01-29 Thread David Charlap
Al Rowland wrote: The PIN is on your card ... Not for any card I've ever owned. I've changed my PIN several times over the years, and the bank has never re-encoded my card or sent me a new card as a result of doing so. Maybe some banks do store the PIN on the card, but I'm certain that

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Florian Weimer
Richard A Steenbergen [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: (pointers ARE your friend god damnit :P) Most C programmers have no clue about the C pointer semantics, I'm afraid, so this powerful feature is often abused. -- Florian Weimer[EMAIL PROTECTED] University of Stuttgart

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Florian Weimer
Richard A Steenbergen [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I said exploits, not ways to get outside your proper address space and crash the OS. Any sufficiently powerful language presents an opportunity to do bad things to an ill prepared OS, but the answer isn't to make the language less powerful.

Re: OT: Banc of America Article

2003-01-29 Thread Sharif Torpis
Halleluljah. A voice of knowledge as opposed to conjecture. Different bank ATMs operate differently. There are online and offline modes. The PIN may or may not be recorded on the card. Some of these differences are due to the fact that not all financial institutions were connected to interbank

Re: Blocked by msn.com MX, contact for MSN.COM postmaster ?

2003-01-29 Thread Mark E. Mallett
On Tue, Jan 28, 2003 at 11:49:16AM +, Miquel van Smoorenburg wrote: I found out that our outgoing SMTP servers have been blocked by the msn.com MXes. In a nasty way, too -- no SMTP error, the TCP connection is simply closed by them immidiately after establishing it. We're not listed on

RE: routing between provider edge and CPE routers

2003-01-29 Thread Mike Bernico
So, by accepting routes from CPE you create a huge security vulnerability for your customers, and other parties. This practice was understood as a very bad network engineering for decades. Is there someplace I can find tidbits of information like this? I haven't been alive decades so I

RE: Blocked by msn.com MX, contact for MSN.COM postmaster ?

2003-01-29 Thread Mark Segal
Have you tried [EMAIL PROTECTED] maybe [EMAIL PROTECTED] (they could forward you).. They are quite responsive (hotmail, abuse), at least from a hotmail address :). mark -- Mark Segal Director, Data Services Futureway Communications Inc. Tel: (905)326-1570 -Original Message- From:

RE: Blocked by msn.com MX, contact for MSN.COM postmaster ?

2003-01-29 Thread Todd Mitchell
I'm actually dealing with the same issue as we speak. Out of racks of web servers doing shared hosting, MSN decided to block the eth0 on one of our Linux boxes. I called a friend and was given a direct number to level 3 MSN technical support; they are the last tier of support you can speak to

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread E.B. Dreger
ML Date: Wed, 29 Jan 2003 12:58:58 -0800 ML From: Mathew Lodge ML No, it isn't, as is doing buf_t[x] rather than pointer True. I just like having a struct so I may pass a single variable in function calls instead of a whole mess of them. ML arithmetic, but the *practical* problem is that

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Daniel Karrenberg
On 29.01 03:32, Sean Donelan wrote: ... Multics security. Bell Labs answer: Unix. Who needs all that extra security junk in Multics. . [reader warning: diatribe following] Gee, there once were a handflul of people; their principle goal was to make an OS for their own use. They

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-29 Thread bdragon
Not to sound to pro-MS, but if they are going to sue, they should be able to sue ALL software makers. And what does that do to open source? Apache, MySQL, OpenSSH, etc have all had their problems. Should we sue the nail gun vendor because some moron shoots himself in the head with it? No.

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-29 Thread Mike Hogsett
Similarly, you _pay_ MS for a product. A product which is repeatedly vulnerable. I think this is key. People (individuals/corporations) keep buying crappy software. As long as people keep paying the software vendors for these broken products what incentives do they have to actually fix

RE: routing between provider edge and CPE routers

2003-01-29 Thread Vadim Antonov
On Wed, 29 Jan 2003, Mike Bernico wrote: Is there someplace I can find tidbits of information like this? I haven't been alive decades so I must have missed that memo. Other than this list I don't know where to find anyone with lots of experience working for a service provider. Well, this

RE: routing between provider edge and CPE routers

2003-01-29 Thread Ray Burkholder
A few I've found but not tried out yet: OpenSource: http://www.freeipdb.org/ http://www.brownkid.net/NorthStar/ Windows: http://myips.dzoul.com/main.asp http://www.enterpriseip.net/ I make no promises as to applicability or suitability. www.sourceforge.net www.freshmeat.net These two sites

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-29 Thread Scott Francis
On Tue, Jan 28, 2003 at 11:13:19AM -0200, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: [snip] But this worm required external access to an internal server (SQL Servers are not front-end ones); even with a bad or no patch management system, this simply wouldn't happen on a properly configured network. Whoever got

Re: Bell Labs or Microsoft security?

2003-01-29 Thread Rubens Kuhl Jr.
Any opinion on Inferno ? It seems more suited to build a packet-eating-machine (router, firewall, vpn, choose your favorite flavour)... Rubens Kuhl Jr. - Original Message - From: Vadim Antonov [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, January 30,