RE: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment)

2003-03-10 Thread E.B. Dreger
DJR Date: Mon, 10 Mar 2003 22:17:56 +0700 DJR From: Dr. Jeffrey Race DJR Please read the details in the text. It is all spelt out DJR there. I'm glad someone has spelt out how we can find our way out of the spam maize. Hopefully the details are explained with sufficient granularity, and

RE: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment)

2003-03-10 Thread Cutler, James R
To: Dr. Jeffrey Race Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment) quote: Well-managed, ethical members of the internet industry already conduct their businesses, successfully and profitably, according to the principles

Re: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice(please comment)

2003-03-07 Thread Andy Dills
On Fri, 7 Mar 2003, Dr. Jeffrey Race wrote: Whether it is implemented is not my business. I am the doctor diagnosing the illness and prescribing the scientifically validated cure, and warning the patient of the quack remedies on the market. My job is done now (almost, I just have to

RE: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment)

2003-03-07 Thread cproctor
I actually see several problems with this: 1.) Near as I can tell, Emergent Structures are observed phenomena. They are not tools for social engineering. 2.) You suggest pushing this at appropriate bodies. Near as I know... there is no such animal. 3.) You say in the header that you're

Re: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment)

2003-03-07 Thread Peter Galbavy
McBurnett, Jim wrote: To be blunt: It seems that your opinion is: If a company wants to dump trash in my email account and they are able to find an ISP who is so blindly just taking a payment and cares less about what who they provide service to, so be it, I don't care. I did not even

Re: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice(please comment)

2003-03-06 Thread Andy Dills
Some comments, after reading the draft: Under 2.1, Form of Practice, where you finally talk about what it is you're propsing: The withdrawal of IR (use of blocklists, cancellation of routing, withdrawal of IP addresses and domain names) may in its early months of adoption split the Internet

Re: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment)

2003-03-06 Thread Dr. Jeffrey Race
Thank you Andy for making my points so clearly. See inline comments On Thu, 6 Mar 2003 12:30:11 -0500 (EST), Andy Dills wrote: Some comments, after reading the draft: Under 2.1, Form of Practice, where you finally talk about what it is you're propsing: The withdrawal of IR (use of blocklists,

Re: [Re: Abstract of proposed Internet Draft for Best Current Practice (please comment)]

2003-03-06 Thread Dr. Jeffrey Race
Thank you Josh, please see inline comments which let me clarify points On Thu, 06 Mar 2003 13:17:35 -0500, Joshua Smith wrote: is there a forthcoming section on criterium for demonstrating reformation by the sp and/or 'offending' user? The criterion is stated: no more complaints the