Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed

2002-10-26 Thread JC Dill
On 05:16 AM 10/24/02, Etaoin Shrdlu wrote: > >Alan Hannan wrote: >> >> > I don't understand how giving the US federal government management control >> > of key components of the Internet will make it more secure. >> >> It worked for airline security. > >Sure, searching Ray Charles makes me feel

Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed

2002-10-25 Thread Mathew Lodge
At 05:34 PM 10/24/2002 +0100, Chrisy Luke wrote: That said, in my limited experience (and it may entirely be superficial) countries with Government run airport security tend to be more thorough - and that means Govt. employed people doing the job, not some 2-bit company they found down the road t

Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed

2002-10-24 Thread Chris Adams
Once upon a time, Jeff Shultz <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> said: > I saw in a forum on ExtremeTech (where they had an article ranting > about how the internet was almost brought to it's > knees)http://www.extremetech.com/article2/0,3973,646157,00.asp that > after the root servers attack the gTLD's were att

Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed

2002-10-24 Thread Jeff Shultz
I saw in a forum on ExtremeTech (where they had an article ranting about how the internet was almost brought to it's knees)http://www.extremetech.com/article2/0,3973,646157,00.asp that after the root servers attack the gTLD's were attacked as well, taking out .biz, .info, and .gov ... can anyone v

Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed

2002-10-24 Thread Chrisy Luke
Etaoin Shrdlu wrote (on Oct 24): > There is not one single thing that goes on in airport "security" that > contributes one whit to actual security. Having, on more than one occasion been allowed to board an aircraft in the US whilst accidentally carrying a Leatherman tool (complete with locking b

Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed

2002-10-24 Thread Etaoin Shrdlu
Alan Hannan wrote: > > > I don't understand how giving the US federal government management control > > of key components of the Internet will make it more secure. > > It worked for airline security. Sure, searching Ray Charles makes me feel much safer. Asking me whether any one helped me pac

Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed

2002-10-24 Thread Vadim Antonov
On Wed, 23 Oct 2002, Alan Hannan wrote: > > I don't understand how giving the US federal government management control > > of key components of the Internet will make it more secure. > > It worked for airline security. Yeah... removing shoes and "randomly" searching peace activists while a

Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed

2002-10-24 Thread Michael . Dillon
> Hardly. They have a hard enough time passing information from one squad to > another within the FBI, they're never going to be able to survive and > interoperate in the Information Age against high-tech threats that move at > packet speed. And donĀ¹t get me started about Infragard.ugh...

Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed

2002-10-23 Thread Daniel Karrenberg
At 07:05 AM 10/24/2002, Alan Hannan wrote: > It worked for airline security. Oh, did it now? Just to paraphrase Seans very professional language: Before the US government proposes to unilaterally take responsibility for a particular service it should consider its track record of providing pa

Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed

2002-10-23 Thread Alan Hannan
> I don't understand how giving the US federal government management control > of key components of the Internet will make it more secure. It worked for airline security.

Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed

2002-10-23 Thread Christopher L. Morrow
On Wed, 23 Oct 2002, Sean Donelan wrote: > > Should root servers be located in the "middle" of backbones, instead of stub > networks? Or do networks naturally "grow" towards root servers? > > http://www.idg.net/ic_958962_1793_1-1681.html > "More federal management of key components of the Int

Re: More federal management of key components of the Internet needed

2002-10-23 Thread Rick Irving
Hey, Sean, if it is against the law to yell FIRE in a crowded movie theatre in America... Why isn't it against the law to (s)Yell "FUD" at Congress ? :\ Sean Donelan wrote: > > It's starting already. It started with the USA Patriot Act, the beginning paroxysms of rigor mortis of the Ame

More federal management of key components of the Internet needed

2002-10-23 Thread Sean Donelan
Its starting already. I don't mean to diss any of the root server operators, they all do a great job. But in the past it seemed the federal agency sysadmins had the most difficult job getting the budget approval for upgrades, and seemed to always be behind the performance curve. I don't unders