RE: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-09-04 Thread Michel Py
Michel Py wrote: In other words: as of today a large part of the bandwidth is allocated to building everyone's collection of files. This might gradually change to become bandwidth being used only for incremental updates as huge local file libraries become common place. Peter Galbavy

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-09-03 Thread Peter Galbavy
Michel Py wrote: In other words: as of today a large part of the bandwidth is allocated to building everyone's collection of files. This might gradually change to become bandwidth being used only for incremental updates as huge local file libraries become common place. But this possible assumes

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-09-03 Thread Petri Helenius
Peter Galbavy wrote: But this possible assumes that production of new media will either slow or stay at a constant rate. The never-yet-realised side effect of all this distribution capacity is that possible many more artists will have access to the listeners / viewers and in more narrow niches

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-09-02 Thread Petri Helenius
Erik Parker wrote: Speaking of which.. I wish P2P had been a little bit more organized when 9/11 happened.. Trying to watch the news online, download clips, or images for those few days following.. was nearly impossible. CNN/TimeWarner should recall that their entire cluster was destroyed and

re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-09-01 Thread Roland Perry
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Brian Battle [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes Akamai or not, microsoft is overwhelmed by the demand for SP2, and today is giving the message listed below on windowsupdate: Download and install it now - Currently not available We are currently experiencing a high level of

re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-09-01 Thread David A. Ulevitch
quote who=Roland Perry I have a solution, but it's expensive. A url for the whole 266MB download (and not the smaller selective download that Windows Update would provide). If anyone's that desperate, email me. I only used it after waiting a week with the Automatic Updates switched on, and

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-09-01 Thread Roland Perry
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], David A. Ulevitch [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes Microsoft isn't hiding the link: http://download.microsoft.com/download/1/6/5/165b076b-aaa9-443d-84f0-73cf11fdcdf8/WindowsXP-KB835935-SP2-ENU.exe linked from:

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-09-01 Thread Peter Galbavy
Michel Py wrote: 2) Make audio CD's unreadable in a computer so nobody can rip the .wav tracks to .mp3. Totally stupid: 2.a) Remember the last ones that tried (namely Sony)? Their protection scheme could be defeated in 2 seconds with a sharpie. I'm still laughing at it. Hara-kiri comes to mind.

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-09-01 Thread Jeff Wheeler
Not that I'm trying to put words in your mouth, but I believe you meant suprnova.org which is a BitTorrent site (supernova.org is not a bittorrent site). Check out this link for a list of other BitTorrent sites and applications: http://kevinrose.typepad.com/kr/2004/07/darktip_the_bes.html

RE: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-09-01 Thread Michel Py
Peter Galbavy wrote: My personal reasons for any downloading of audio, specifically, in it's unavailability through retail channels. I keep picking up references to older stuff that has been dumped by the pop-bods many years ago and cannot be bought for love nor money. I may be breaking

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-31 Thread Petri Helenius
Owen DeLong wrote: In general, I think attempts to legislate the behavior of the internet are unlikely to have much effect on it's operation other than to make certain US companies less competitive and to make certain basic activities more difficult for the average user. However, there is going

RE: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-31 Thread Ted Fischer
Big Snip ... At 07:03 PM 8/30/2004, Sean Donlan postualted: Is the problem P2P? Or is the problem copyright infringement? Thank you, Sean. What does Peer-to-Peer mean, anyway. Unfortunately, lots of things. One could argue (I've seen a few replies re this subject hinting around this

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-31 Thread Erik Parker
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Surely the big benefits of peer to peer is it takes control way from the center - which will never go down well in Washington when the big Digital Publishers are being so successful at pushing through legislation via WIPO etc. If they want to start

RE: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-31 Thread Dave Hilton
To those of authority, single-point-of-failure equates to centralized control. With the word control in large neon capital letters. Dave Hilton Staff System Administrator entelos(r) Foster City, CA Notice: I tend to become apprehensive when my position in the food chain becomes

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-31 Thread Niels Bakker
* [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Sean Donelan) [Tue 31 Aug 2004, 01:06 CEST]: Is the problem P2P? Or is the problem copyright infringement? Is traffic the problem? Whose anyway? Isn't the point of building a network to facilitate the exchange of data? -- Niels. -- Today's subliminal thought

RE: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-31 Thread Michel Py
Christopher L. Morrow wrote: because legislating in the 'USA' something that is clearly 'global' has worked so well? politicians looking to get: 1) votes 2) 'political bang for the buck' 3) useless hot air blown up someone's rear really need to stop trying to legislate behaviour in places

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On 30-aug-04, at 20:27, Henry Linneweh wrote: So I would like some professional expert opinion to give her on this issue since it will effect the copyright inducement bill. Real benefits for production and professional usage of this technology. Peer to peer technology has the potential to allow

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread David A. Ulevitch
quote who=Byron L. Hicks In fact, I would be very reluctant to trust a Windows update downloaded via P2P. why? Not only were there many sources all showing the same MD5 hash (and for the time being, we can still trust MD5...) BUT it was also digitally signed by Microsoft which was easily

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Petri Helenius
Byron L. Hicks wrote: Not true. For those of us who host Akamai servers, we could download SP2 with no problems. We did not need P2P, or MSDN. In fact, I would be very reluctant to trust a Windows update downloaded via P2P. How is the p2p checksum different from any other checksum on the

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread james edwards
Not true. For those of us who host Akamai servers, we could download SP2 with no problems. We did not need P2P, or MSDN. In fact, I would be very reluctant to trust a Windows update downloaded via P2P. Have you heard of MD5 sum ? -- James H. Edwards Routing and Security Administrator At

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Dan Hollis
On Mon, 30 Aug 2004, Petri Helenius wrote: Byron L. Hicks wrote: Not true. For those of us who host Akamai servers, we could download SP2 with no problems. We did not need P2P, or MSDN. In fact, I would be very reluctant to trust a Windows update downloaded via P2P. How is the p2p

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Dan Hollis
On Mon, 30 Aug 2004, james edwards wrote: Not true. For those of us who host Akamai servers, we could download SP2 with no problems. We did not need P2P, or MSDN. In fact, I would be very reluctant to trust a Windows update downloaded via P2P. Have you heard of MD5 sum ? yep md5 made

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread james edwards
Thats SHA0. Still a checksum is a checksum, cracked or not. - Original Message - From: Dan Hollis [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: james edwards [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: Byron L. Hicks [EMAIL PROTECTED]; Jeff Wheeler [EMAIL PROTECTED]; Henry Linneweh [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent:

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On 30-aug-04, at 22:08, Dan Hollis wrote: recall that feinstein is one of the loudest anti-p2p legislators. i am not sure anyone should be helping her. Security by obscurity?

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Christopher L. Morrow
On Mon, 30 Aug 2004, Dan Hollis wrote: On Mon, 30 Aug 2004, Petri Helenius wrote: Byron L. Hicks wrote: Not true. For those of us who host Akamai servers, we could download SP2 with no problems. We did not need P2P, or MSDN. In fact, I would be very reluctant to trust a Windows update

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Scott A Crosby
On Mon, 30 Aug 2004 11:27:12 -0700 (PDT), Henry Linneweh [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: So I would like some professional expert opinion to give her on this issue since it will effect the copyright inducement bill. Real benefits for production and professional usage of this technology. In my

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Mike Tancsa
At 04:12 PM 30/08/2004, Dan Hollis wrote: yep md5 made the news recently because it's been cracked: http://techrepublic.com.com/5100-22-5314533.html http://www.rtfm.com/movabletype/archives/2004_08.html#001055 Thats a misleading over simplification. A collision being found implies something

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Eric Gauthier
Henry, So I would like some professional expert opinion to give her on this issue since it will effect the copyright inducement bill. Real benefits for production and professional usage of this technology. I'm sure you'll hear this from many other people, but one thing that I always try to

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Scott Call
On Mon, 30 Aug 2004, Mike Tancsa wrote: I recall even seeing posts about people claiming this meant original data being reconstructed from the checksum! That would be truly amazing since I could reconstruct a 680MB ISO from just 61d38fad42b4037970338636b5e72e5a. Wow! Technically, using an

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Mike Tancsa
At 05:10 PM 30/08/2004, Scott Call wrote: On Mon, 30 Aug 2004, Mike Tancsa wrote: I recall even seeing posts about people claiming this meant original data being reconstructed from the checksum! That would be truly amazing since I could reconstruct a 680MB ISO from just

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Jeff Wheeler
p2p is different due to its decentralization. in other words, what once required a server to do can now be done by anyone sitting in front of their home computer. it in a way revitalized the idea of every computer on the 'net being it's own host - capable of serving up whatever the user

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Gregory Hicks
Date: Mon, 30 Aug 2004 16:39:56 -0400 From: Mike Tancsa [EMAIL PROTECTED] At 04:12 PM 30/08/2004, Dan Hollis wrote: yep md5 made the news recently because it's been cracked: http://techrepublic.com.com/5100-22-5314533.html http://www.rtfm.com/movabletype/archives/2004_08.html#001055

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Crist Clark
Scott Call wrote: On Mon, 30 Aug 2004, Mike Tancsa wrote: I recall even seeing posts about people claiming this meant original data being reconstructed from the checksum! That would be truly amazing since I could reconstruct a 680MB ISO from just 61d38fad42b4037970338636b5e72e5a. Wow!

RE: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread David Schwartz
So I would like some professional expert opinion to give her on this issue since it will effect the copyright inducement bill. Real benefits for production and professional usage of this technology. We have no idea what the benefits of P2P are going to be or what the technology is

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On 30-aug-04, at 23:31, Jeff Wheeler wrote: the problem is that while in the 'real world' this wasn't a big issue (a user giving away copies of the latest CD they bought from their front porch wasn't likely able to distribute it to too many people, and it cost them money to do it) on the 'net

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Fred Baker
At 05:03 PM 08/30/04 -0400, Sean Donelan wrote: I've always wondered what really makes P2P different from anything else on the Internet? From the service provider's point of view, users accessing CNN.COM is a peer-to-peer activity between the user and CNN. From the service provider's point of

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Crist Clark
Gregory Hicks wrote: Date: Mon, 30 Aug 2004 16:39:56 -0400 From: Mike Tancsa [EMAIL PROTECTED] At 04:12 PM 30/08/2004, Dan Hollis wrote: yep md5 made the news recently because it's been cracked: http://techrepublic.com.com/5100-22-5314533.html

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Scott A Crosby
On Mon, 30 Aug 2004 17:31:12 -0400, Jeff Wheeler [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: p2p is different due to its decentralization. in other words, what once required a server to do can now be done by anyone sitting in front of their home computer. it in a way revitalized the idea of every computer

RE: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Bora Akyol
Traffic patterns is one thing for sure. P2P should be lopsided the other way around. More outbound, than inbound. or at best symetric. Regular browsing is asymmetric with more inbound than outbound. Have people been tracking changes in the traffic patterns since the advent of P2P. Bora

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Owen DeLong
While I agree with everything you said, Scott, I think that is exactly the kind of application that Feinstein is looking to quash. Her agenda has been very pro-corporate control anti-free speech, anti-individual since she took office. The only thing she seems more opposed to is anyone besides

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Scott A Crosby
On Mon, 30 Aug 2004 14:33:21 -0700 (PDT), Gregory Hicks [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I recall even seeing posts about people claiming this meant original data being reconstructed from the checksum! That would be truly amazing since I could reconstruct a 680MB ISO from just

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Erik Parker
A method like P2P (and BT's swarming in particular) allowed this file to spread without overtaxing the bandwidth of the person or organization distributing it. Frankly, in a day when news organizations are forced to think about any negative impacts of their reporting on their parent corp's

RE: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Sean Donelan
On Mon, 30 Aug 2004, Bora Akyol wrote: Traffic patterns is one thing for sure. P2P should be lopsided the other way around. More outbound, than inbound. or at best symetric. Regular browsing is asymmetric with more inbound than outbound. The Internet pre-dates the Web. In 1992, FTP was the

RE: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Martin J. Levy
Sean, There were lots of FTP mirrors around. Every Sun workstation could have a Anonymous FTP. Of course, the problem was every Sun workstation could be an Anonymous FTP :-) ... but you forgot to mention that filtering and firewalls and NAT were not in common use, hence everywhere was

Re: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Majdi Abbas
On Mon, Aug 30, 2004 at 02:33:21PM -0700, Gregory Hicks wrote: Actually... The collision problem discovered means that there might be MULTIPLE 680MB files that give the same checksum. Of course, the utility of most of these files would be an exercise left to the 'cracker' if you

RE: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Bora Akyol
I think we need to define what P2P is before we can address this. IMHO, P2P started with NAPSTER, yes before that there was WWW, gopher, ftp, files by email, bitnet, x/y/z modem, bbs (dating myself here), but the large scale bandwidth usage that is seen started with NAPSTER. P2P I would define

RE: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Dave Dennis
/dcc send nick filename peer to peer sharing, on irc, since 1991. Napster simply implemented the IRC protocol's DCC function, with a better command set / GUI. +- + Dave Dennis + Seattle, WA + [EMAIL PROTECTED] + http://www.dmdennis.com +- On

RE: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Owen DeLong
Is the problem P2P? Or is the problem copyright infringement? The problem is the U.S. Congress thinking it has control or authority to legislate anything on the Internet. At some point, the law is going to have to recognize that the Internet is an international phenomenon, and, that localized or

RE: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Michel Py
Matthew McGehrin wrote: Tell her to kiss my white ass. Be careful what you wish for. This is exactly what politicians do for a living, and some happen to have a strong enough tongue to rip you a new one. Michel.

RE: Senator Diane Feinstein Wants to know about the Benefits of P2P

2004-08-30 Thread Tom (UnitedLayer)
On Mon, 30 Aug 2004, Michel Py wrote: Matthew McGehrin wrote: Tell her to kiss my white ass. Be careful what you wish for. This is exactly what politicians do for a living, and some happen to have a strong enough tongue to rip you a new one. Remeber she's from the PRK too! A grade a