Re: Yahoo outage summary

2007-07-09 Thread Roland Dobbins
On Jul 9, 2007, at 8:56 AM, Marcus H. Sachs wrote: If we had routing registries that were accurate and authoritative Irrespective of the stat us of s*BGP deployment, following existing BCPs with currently-deployed techniques/functionality/features would have prevented the issue

Re: Yahoo outage summary

2007-07-09 Thread Andy Dills
On Mon, 9 Jul 2007, Cat Okita wrote: As far as needing a verification system, is there something deeply problematic about filtering your customers? It's a fine example of thinking globally and acting locally. That's what I'm curious about...this boils down to L3 not properly filtering

Re: Yahoo outage summary

2007-07-09 Thread Randy Bush
following existing BCPs with currently-deployed techniques/functionality/features would have prevented the issue described in the post. knowing that level(3) is one of the most serious deployments of irr-based route filters and other prudent practices, perhaps we should wait for a post mortem

Vericenter Denver Outtage

2007-07-09 Thread James Baldwin
Does anyone have further information on the Vericenter Denver outtage? Support is aware of the issue, however, they could not feed me a problem description at the time of ticket creation or an ETR? James Baldwin

Re: Vericenter Denver Outtage

2007-07-09 Thread James Baldwin
Outtage with the primary sprintlink connection. Still no ETR. James Baldwin On Jul 9, 2007, at 2:09 AM, James Baldwin wrote: Does anyone have further information on the Vericenter Denver outtage? Support is aware of the issue, however, they could not feed me a problem description at the

Re: Yahoo outage summary

2007-07-09 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Mon, 09 Jul 2007 02:18:25 -, Chris L. Morrow said: While S*BGP seem like they may offer additional protections and additional knobs to be used for protecting 'us' from 'them', the very basics are obviously not being done so added complexity is not going to really help :( Or, perhaps

Re: Yahoo outage summary

2007-07-09 Thread Chris L. Morrow
On Mon, 9 Jul 2007 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Mon, 09 Jul 2007 02:18:25 -, Chris L. Morrow said: While S*BGP seem like they may offer additional protections and additional knobs to be used for protecting 'us' from 'them', the very basics are obviously not being done so added

Re: Yahoo outage summary

2007-07-09 Thread jared mauch
On Jul 9, 2007, at 10:47 AM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Mon, 09 Jul 2007 02:18:25 -, Chris L. Morrow said: While S*BGP seem like they may offer additional protections and additional knobs to be used for protecting 'us' from 'them', the very basics are obviously not being done so

Re: Yahoo outage summary

2007-07-09 Thread Tony Tauber
On Mon, Jul 09, 2007 at 02:31:10PM +0800, Randy Bush wrote: following existing BCPs with currently-deployed techniques/functionality/features would have prevented the issue described in the post. knowing that level(3) is one of the most serious deployments of irr-based route filters

Re: Yahoo outage summary

2007-07-09 Thread Randy Bush
Tony Tauber wrote: On Mon, Jul 09, 2007 at 02:31:10PM +0800, Randy Bush wrote: following existing BCPs with currently-deployed techniques/functionality/features would have prevented the issue described in the post. knowing that level(3) is one of the most serious deployments of irr-based

Re: Yahoo outage summary

2007-07-09 Thread Sean Donelan
On Tue, 10 Jul 2007, Randy Bush wrote: the space of routing data validation is large, we can explore it at our leisure, and we have been for some years. but my point was that it is silly to indulge in conjecturbation on the cause of the recent event and excoriate l(3), hanaro, or john curran's

Re: Yahoo outage summary

2007-07-09 Thread Jared Mauch
On Mon, Jul 09, 2007 at 01:23:46PM -0500, Borchers, Mark M. wrote: Jared Mauch wrote: The simple truth is that prefix lists ARE hard to manage. Medium-hard IMHO. Adding prefixes is relatively easy to implement. Tracking and removing outdated information significantly more challenging.

Re: Yahoo outage summary

2007-07-09 Thread Joe Abley
On 9-Jul-2007, at 16:13, Jared Mauch wrote: Some have automated systems, but they're dependent on IRR data being correct. There are even tools to automate population of IRR data. Building customer filters from the IRR seems like it should fall in the easy bucket, given how long

Re: Yahoo outage summary

2007-07-09 Thread Jared Mauch
On Mon, Jul 09, 2007 at 04:50:56PM -0400, Joe Abley wrote: On 9-Jul-2007, at 16:13, Jared Mauch wrote: Some have automated systems, but they're dependent on IRR data being correct. There are even tools to automate population of IRR data. Building customer filters from the IRR

Re: Yahoo outage summary

2007-07-09 Thread Tony Tauber
On Mon, Jul 09, 2007 at 04:50:56PM -0400, Joe Abley wrote: SIDR is only of any widespread use if it is coupled with policy/ procedures at the RIRs to provide certificates for resources that are assigned/allocated. However, this seems like less of a hurdle than you'd think when you look

RE: IP Allocations and moving AS numbers

2007-07-09 Thread Azinger, Marla
Shane- Please redirect your email questions to ARIN ppml or discuss. That will be a better forum for you with these type of questions. I will also email you on the side. Cheers! Marla Azinger Frontier Communications AC Chair -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL

Level(3) filtering (was Yahoo outage summary)

2007-07-09 Thread Kevin Epperson
There is some misinformation in previous posts that I would like to clarify on the Level 3 side of things. Every transit-like connection on AS3356 is prefix-filtered including all parties in this event. On AS3356 all prefix filters and import policies on BGP sessions are audited and

Re: Level(3) filtering (was Yahoo outage summary)

2007-07-09 Thread Chris L. Morrow
On Mon, 9 Jul 2007, Kevin Epperson wrote: There is some misinformation in previous posts that I would like to clarify on the Level 3 side of things. and I'd apologize for hinting that that might be the problem :( Level 3's own registry and known public route registries. As several